News
Giora Eiland: Hamas wasn't defeated, but suffered significant military blow
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 05.08.14, 09:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
9 Talkbacks for this article
1. What does a Victory for Gaza look like?
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (08.05.14)
First A REWRITE of the Hamas Charter that promises to SERVE Gaza not destroy it REMOVE any reference to the destruction of ANYONE or ANY STATE. Its not only OBNOXIOUS but TOXIC for Gaza Society Second The disbanding of Militias who have shown so clearly through the actions of that MADMAN Psychopath Deif that they ARE out of control...and with them still armed THERES IS NO WAY FORWARD for Gaza Third Joint Multi National Border Security with International Observers protecting and guaranteeing Egypt, Gaza, Israel borders Fourth New INDEPENDENT Gaza Economic Body charged with accounting and assigning aid and taxes with TOTAL TRANSPARENCY Fifth New INDEPENDENT Gaza Reconstruction Body charged with reconstruction of damaged infrastructure and homes Sixth Lifting Egyptian and Israeli Blockade
2. Israel won round one
Larry ,   LA (formerly)   (08.05.14)
But the fight isn't over until one of the fighters can't come out of his corner or unless there is a knock out. We, unfortunately, must wait for the next round to know who will win.
3. lifting of blockade only if hamas & jihadists defeated
C   (08.05.14)
the terrorists cannot be rewarded for their war crimes. they must be defeated and expelled.
4. its israels turn to allow them to live.
eddiE ,   sa   (08.05.14)
There is no difference between hamas and anti semitism which has been with us for millenia in spite of our attempts to get rid of it --- We have tried being "nice" to our enemys and it has not worked in the past But now we have more options than before so lets start using these new options in gaza.. and I dont mean giving food. Giving food and medicine is the same old method for letting us live as extracting from us in the form of "jew tax" ..It is now israels torn to extract the "tax" Has the IDF left the cement factories standing ???
5. Gaza
at ,   Karmiel, Israel   (08.05.14)
Why does Peri say, "...Israel gives Gaza electricity, water and other goods...."? We don't GIVE Gaza anything, but we do SELL them many things. Sales to Gaza is a profitable branch of the Israeli economy bringing in $2 billion a year. So, when Peri, who knows better, says GIVE instead of SELL, he is trying to paint a picture of a humanitarian Israel which is not in accord with reality.
6. #3 wrong again
(08.05.14)
The original Egyptian ceasefire proposal wanted to achieve just that. Kerry and Obama rejected that ceasefire, and demanded a ceasefire that would be a Hamas victory and leave Hamas in power.
7. Duh....?!
tom ,   tel aviv   (08.05.14)
8. Political cowardice
P. henry ,   Longmont, co.   (08.05.14)
Bibbi turned into (bend over and grab your ankles,PERES).what about the dead Israeli soldiers and civilians,always again political hack BIBBI.ALWAYS again and again ,
9. 6
C   (08.05.14)
those two will be gone in two years.
Back to article