News
Train service to Sderot suspended for fear of anti-tank fire from Gaza
Yoav Zitun
Published: 18.08.14, 01:02
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
14 Talkbacks for this article
1. The description of terrorism
Ezra ,   USA   (08.18.14)
The description is where a terrorist event disrupts the victims everyday lifestyle, and victims are afraid to continue; feeling intimidated. I say, either be a slave, or destroy your enemy. You can't do both.
2. Ata Boy: I want my Hyundai "fortified" too!Are we mad?!
(08.18.14)
3. Where are they?
(08.18.14)
They said ethnically cleansing Gush Katif from Jews was a good idea. They said Israel must develop the Negev instead. Thanks to that stupid move, not only did Israel spend roughly tenfold on defense from Gaza, but now the single most important move to make the Negev viable becomes unusable. Why is Livni silent? How come Herzog doesn't comment? Where is Peres? Why doesn't Galon board the train with her supporters to prove it is safe?
4. Fear not, I am negotiating
PM Booboo ,   Western Al-Quds   (08.18.14)
All is well, I am busy negotiating with our Hamas cousins, and should they stop negotiating I know of a couple more empty buildings we can do, so, let's move on folks, nothing to see here... By the way, has anybody seen my balls, I can't find them...
5. Failure
Jhan   (08.18.14)
A total failure from day one as anyone with half a brain already knew then. Total failure, many dead israeli youths. Gains: zero.
6. Fortify the trains?
(08.18.14)
Chelem at its best. How about building a wall along side the rails all the way from Ashkelon to Sderot? Minister or Defence my arse.
7. Face bookers aka cowards.
Allan ,   USA   (08.18.14)
Israel targeted civilian homes and apartments. Mosques and churches ( 2 churches), hospitals and ambulances. Journalists. Schools ( UN schools included) after the UN informed the israeli army of exact locations ( as if they didn't know ahead;)). Rockets were fired from Every location mentioned above..according to the most $-/$&&/; army in the world. 64 israeli soldiers killed.
8. Only total victory over "Palestinians" willin end suffering.
Chaim ,   Israel   (08.18.14)
The suffering won't ever end till Israel does what must be done to achieve total victory over our mortal "Palestinian" foes. Just like the Allies in WW II.
9. Fortify commuter trains? Is Defense Ministry this stupid??
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (08.18.14)
Fortifying passenger trains against anti-tank missiles is impossible, they would be too heavy to move. Or what, put reactive exploding tank armor on them? What complete idiocy!! You don't fortify the train cars, you fortify the rail line. RPG-type anti-tank missiles lack the range to reach the rail line from Gaza, and wire-guided anti-tank missiles are all line-of-sight weapons, operators have to SEE the target to launch to a hit. So by obscuring the line-of-sight from Gaza border with high dirt berms and 20-30 ft high chain-link opaque fences with camo net along the the 6-7 miles of rail line, from Melfasim to Erez, and the same along the Gaza border itself in this area - ground level missile operators can not get a missile lock on the train because they can't see it, vision blocked by barrier, have to guess. Technology exists now to do this and its cheap. Where do Defense Ministry get stupid ideas like this, fortifying passenger trains against anti-tank missiles? Technology doesn't even exist, take years, and cost would be astronomical to make practical. Hamas could launch anti-tank missiles at passenger trains from tall apartments in Beit Hanun I suppose - Bibi should make clear to the world that if they do, IAF will instantly bring down the apartment building with a rain of 2000 lb bombs, regardless of people inside, since international law allows immediate destruction of active firing positions in self defense, and bans use of apartments as firing positions.
10. Should they
Barney ,   USA   (08.18.14)
Do this reduce gaza to a pile of cement dust barren of any trace of terrorist scum. Just sayin'. After all they do love death . Let's do them and everyone else a favor. It is a win win. Israelis get life and Hamas gets death. Such a cozy arrangement
11. Isnt this pathetic?
Susan ,   Kfar Saba   (08.18.14)
Is there any other country in the world that needs bomb shelters in homes, schools and malls. Reinforced buses(against bullets), anti-missle defense for the home front and now anti tank trains. Is there any end to it? My daughter wrote to friends on face book that we had to run to our bomb shelter. Their reaction-"You have a bomb shelter in your house?"
12. Sang Pengelana Facebook
(08.18.14)
You should know that the absolute worst crime is blasphemy. Read the Koran: the Prophet PBUH respected Torah, you MUST also respect Torah. The Koran clearly writes that Jews are not dirty animals, and by saying so you are insulting many prophets including Daoud, Suleiman and Issa. I suggest you apologize for your blasphemy against the Prophet and Koran.
13. #7 don't make sense
(08.18.14)
You don't make sense. Let's talk schools. Every single school hit by the IDF was being used as a military base. That means that according to international law, Hamas is a war criminal and responsible for all collateral damage, while Israel is great. If you have a problem with that, please tell me what you think about the countless schools Obama blasted.
14. Fortify the Line Not the Trains
Jake ,   Haifa   (08.18.14)
The article says the line should be protected, not the trains. That only makes sense. Where there is a line of sight directly from Gaza to the train line, a barrier should be placed and even a few layers of trees in a row would probably suffice. Why give the enemy a target?
Back to article