Jewish Scene
IDF offers haredim 'women-free' recruitment centers
Kobi Nachshoni
Published: 31.10.14, 22:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
15 Talkbacks for this article
1. As much as I am an atheist:if we don't force meat down vege-
(11.01.14)
tarian's throat, then why should we object to these hippies doing the army their own way? Plenty of stuff to do without lovely ladies...Get off their backs and concentrate on real problems.
2. Don't hold your breath ...
split   (11.01.14)
... they'll find another excuse and another and another ;) ,..
3. Michael Redbourn ,...
split ,   US   (11.01.14)
"The Charidim work in the US and in every other country" ,... Who sold you this crap? Not in US or any country I know. As a matter of fact they're ripping off US welfare system big time ,... Google 'failed messiah' and read some first hand reports exposing their lifestyle, mind set and your ignorance ,... ignorance
4. @Split
michael redboun ,   Aveiro - Portugal   (11.01.14)
There are people all over the world that rip off welfare and most likely some Haridim do so too. The difference that you seem unaware of is that Israel is the only country in the world that allows the Haridim to legally live off of welfare because of their religion beliefs. I personally know of two shops run by Haridim in Arad, Israel and who runs the diamond business in NY. ?
5. We need a Haredi free Israel.
Larry ,   Or yehuda   (11.01.14)
They are truly a cult loosely based on judaism
6. Haredim in the IDF
Yakov   (11.02.14)
So why not let them have separate Prayer Units? Their sole task would be to pray for those on the field risking their lives.
7. We need...
Gregory ,   Eretz Yisroel   (11.01.14)
No YOU need a hareidi free israel but your not getting it. Not now not never so go back under your rock.
8. 5We need a Haredim hate free Israel.
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (11.02.14)
9. We need a haredi Israel and shalom al yisrael.
(11.02.14)
Secular Zionism is b'H becoming less and less. In another few years, Israel will finally be Jewish.
10. michael redboun - 3 out of 4 in US ,...
split ,   US   (11.02.14)
... the rest involved in some murky business ,... Other welfare abusers are a crawling toddlers next to them when it comes to schnorring ,... Why don't you google and read what I have recommended instead of peddling excuses ,...
11. to Michael Redbourn
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (11.03.14)
In the Jewish Land Israel, nobody should be above the Tora laws .
12. THEYALLOW HEREDI WHITE SLAVING TO DESTROY ISRAEL'S DEMOCRACY
Jew 6Pack ,   ATLANTA GA USA   (11.04.14)
THE HEREDI ENSLAVEMENT OF WOMEN IS THE ROTTED SOUL & FOUNDATION OF ISRAEL'S LOST DEMOCRACY AND FREEDOM...SHAME SHAME SHAME.
13. Outrageous hutzpa
Mikhael   (11.04.14)
There is nothing even in haredi Judaism that forbids them to be in the recruitment center when women are present. This is just nonsense pure and simple and the army shouldn't indulge them. Courageous rabbis, and I mean haredi rabbis, can and should speak out against this.
14. it's no secret...heredi are anti-democracy,
Jewbie ,   ATLusa   (11.04.14)
you can't have it both ways...either or... freedom of choice, religion, speech, and democracy, vs. enslaved women, abused children, greedy heredi, nepotism, corruption, no freedom of any choice, religionists kiss 7th century minded rabbinate tushies.
15. @ #4-Split Haredi welfare cheats
Mikhael   (11.04.14)
There certainly are many haredi scammers and welfare cheats in the US, but there are also many haredi white collar professionals (doctors, lawyers, accountants, computer programmers--not that many hassidim, but "mitnaged" types) and even blue-collar workers--in Boro Park Brooklyn one can find haredi auto mechanics, plumbers, HVAC technicians --I've even seen a haredi track maintenance worker on the NYC subway. Of course there are many haredi small business owners too, and many work in the diamond business. In Israel, however, collectively they are rewarded for not being in the workforce in a way they are not elsewhere.
Back to article