News
Father of Israeli Arab shot by police: Killing inhumane, deliberate
Hassan Shaalan
Published: 09.11.14, 09:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. The Fall Out from Zoabis Incitement
Tim ,   Brighton   (11.09.14)
2. Just look...whilst these young hotheads
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (11.09.14)
In Israel are stirred up and fanaticised by Israeli Arab MKs when the inevitable occurs..they say...'Nothing to do with me mate' That's why politicians in the PA and Israel MUST jointly appoint a body that have got to work out ways to ensure calm and stability Because lets not forget. Instability and violence damages not only Israel but hugely damages the PALESTINIAN West Bank Economy and Society...it makes it almost impossible to negotiate an Agreement towards Statehood. NOBODY WINS The Palestinian Diaspora is full of well meaning potential Investors with BILLIONS of Dollars who want to play a part in Palestinian Nation Building...but they will only invest when there is stability, open trade flows with Israel, Jordan, Egypt and beyond and an educated aspirational and dedicated workforce...NONE OF WHICH THE PA has delivered So before there is any more macho talk by Barghouti and others about IntiFartsdas think of the phrase 'Shooting MYSELF in the foot'
3. WHY?!So next time he cannot plunge a knife into Jewish heart
(11.09.14)
That's why he deserved to die. Hate of this magnitude cannot be cured by few months/years in an Israeli prison-Jihad University!
4. You forgot to teach your son not to attack people w/ knives!
Druze   (11.09.14)
Hope today the jihad doesn't taste so sweet.
5. Why he wasnt shot in the leg ? WHY DID HE HAVE A KNIFE?!
David ,   Israel   (11.09.14)
6. A closer read
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.09.14)
"This will affect not just the town's residents, but all of Palestine" He lives in Israel, not "palestine." However, if he wants to live in "palestine," we should accommodate him and his entire extended family, and deport them all to Gaza.
7. TO RAUF HAMDAN
TEL DA TRUTH ,   SAFED OBVIOUS   (11.09.14)
Dear Mr Hamdan ,I am sorry for your loss ,however perhaps you should have raised your son differently and taught him NEVER to attack and threaten ARMED Policemen ? Your son was an adult and he had to live and die with the consequences of his actions .In no country in the world can a young man threaten police officers with a knife or other weapon and not expect the police not to react .
8. SOMEBODY IS IN DENIAL
MR DENIAL ,   DE NILE   (11.09.14)
If poor Mr Hamdan is brutally honest with himself ,and that admittedly is a very hard thing to do ,he will come to understand that his son was not as innocent as he would wish to believe, video evidence shows his son threatening armed police officers which is always a dangerous proposition.
9. Irrational argument
Scott ,   Haifa   (11.09.14)
Proverbs 10:1 The proverbs of Solomon: A wise son brings joy to his father, but a foolish son brings grief to his mother. Proverbs 17:25 A foolish son brings grief to his father and bitterness to the mother who bore him. Proverbs 19:18 Discipline your children, for in that there is hope; do not be a willing party to their death. The father should be held responsible for producing a child that would confront armed police offices with a knife. I do not feel a touch of sadness for an inevitable result. The boy was responsible for his behavior. Bottom line: lawlessness, and they just don't get it.
10. נתניהו תתבייש אתה וממשלה הימין המתרפת אנחנו אזרחים המדינה !!
Nazaret Nazareth   (11.09.14)
11. Rauf Hamdan - would you shoot me in legs if I attacked you ?
barbara ,   Haifa   (11.09.14)
12. SHOT IN THE LEG?
Robert ,   Israel   (11.09.14)
Should I suppose that Khair Hamdan was also thinking in stabbing the soldier sitting inside the van in his leg while he kept forcing to open the door ?. The footage clearly shows Khair trying to break the window with his knife just where the soldier's face was. Shoult Israeli police ask each terrorist if they already have a previous criminal rekord before taking drastic measures?. This is war and at war it is you or me, so I prefer it to be you.
13. Israeli Arab shot by police
ISSY DYKMAN ,   GANEI TIKVA, ISRAEL   (11.09.14)
It is heartbreaking that this has happened, but with all the stone or rather rock throwing it was only a matter of time before something tragic would happen. It is also time that the Arabs of East Jerusalem & Israel realize that there is from now on a price to pay for their actions.
14. If you attack police you get shot. No questions asked.
Danny   (11.09.14)
15. so for the arabs
JL ,   israel   (11.09.14)
anyone can attack the police with a weapon..but if hes running away he should be allowed to get away..im happy they shot him..and why should they shoot him in the leg?..so we have to pay his hospital bills?..
16. it was deliberate
(11.09.14)
The policeman deliberately shot Khair Hamdan because Hamdan tried to murder him with a knife. Advice to Hamdan: don't try to kill people, you won't be shot. A long ago time ago, maybe 1992, a member of the elite Yamam force was attacked by an Arab armed with a knife at Armon Hanatziv. Due the orders at the time (given by Rabin who did not want to "enrage" the Arabs), the Yamam officer drew his gun, shot in the air, then tried to aim at the attackers leg. Thanks to idiotic orders and his efforts to spare the life of his attacker, he left a widow and baby daughter who will never know her father.
17. Deport the whole family
steve from raleigh   (11.09.14)
Shoot whoever stays behind.
18. When Child Killers are Heroes
David ,   New England   (11.09.14)
When Palestinians call someone a hero for running over a three year old girl, I feel no sadness for Palestinians killed for attacking the police with a knife. If you bring up your children to live in peace, then there will be peace. You live in a civilized country that has many benefits, there are people living in the streets in India that would love to trade places with you and have the advantages you have.
Back to article