Opinion
Jewish nation-state law can only cause damage
Daniel Friedmann
Published: 23.11.14, 11:36
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
13 Talkbacks for this article
1. this law is for future not today
zionist forever   (11.23.14)
This bill basically says that the way things are today will be the way in future and it protects these national symbols etc. Israel is gradually becoming a more secular and politically correct country, this bill means and 20-30 years from now Israel will be a Jewish state still. If we create a palestinians state you can be sure next battle will be with the Israeli arabs who demand a religion neutral state for all and the world will support it and because many leftists are not comfortable with the Jewish state concept anyway they just need the political sutuation to be right to push it.
2. what arrogance. this dunce has nothing to offer. just air
ralph   (11.23.14)
3. Bottom Line
BL   (11.23.14)
The land belongs to the indigenous people (Palestinians) The european-jews has no connect to the ancient jews. You can call yourselves whatever you want, but you aren't ethnic jews.
4. the lefties and Satmar +Neturei Karta
m   (11.23.14)
I hope you understand this mr. Freedman. I'm sure you are offended but at least they have a reason
5. Well, being a Professor he simply HAS TO prove again, that
(11.23.14)
higher education says absolutely nothing about basic education & straith "seychel"! What a waste of mind..
6. "Merciful" ghetto Jews have no place in the government
sa   (11.23.14)
These "merciful" ghetto Jews who have more mercy on Arabs are exactly whom our Sages are referring to with their saying: Those who have mercy on criminals are cruel to the merciful. GET OUT OF ISRAEL NOW!!!
7. Michael Pielet = Deputy chief fascist
Stan ,   Israel   (11.24.14)
I too am an Israeli patriot. Unlike you, I am not an idiot, I understand international politics, whereas you and Rabbi Akiva and Bar Kochba before you, think that you can piss on the world and they will think it's rain.
8. Supporting the new big that re enforces Jewish Israel
mark ,   thornhill, Canada   (11.24.14)
The new bill is a good start in separating those supporting Israel from those that don't. If you are not supporting a Jewish Israel, you are supporting anti-semetism. Antisemites will not compromise, no matter what they get. To the contrary, they will be empowered to want more and eventually to exterminate Jews, as history has proved We are either with Jewish Israel or not. There is no middle ground. The only peace process that works is the one imposed on a defeated enemy.
9. This editorial is wrong! Dead wrong!!!
Shalom Peres ,   Verdun   (11.24.14)
The unmentioned and most important part of the new law is that only jews will in the future have a vote on this subject. In the past if arabs reached majority of vote they could overturn the status of Israel's jewishness, as well as the law of return.
10. #3 excellent post
(11.24.14)
You have summarized the Israeli Leftist position perfectly, and why they hate the Zionists.
11. Good grief, a voice of reason!!
crooksmesiter ,   Sydney, Australia   (11.25.14)
Too bad we don't see this sort of comment more often.
12. Pielet vs Stan
m   (11.25.14)
Love Pielet, he loves Israel
13. Good article.
Luiz F Haddad ,   Niteroi, Brazil   (11.26.14)
As a true friend of Israel, I congratulate Ynet for Daniel Friedman's good text. Of course, Israel will be always a Jewish State . Her flag (David's Star) does mean it. But not "only Jewish". Muslims, Christians, and other minorities, since they affirm loyalty, deserve full citizenship. If a Palestinian State is created, through a so desired peace's agreement, Arabs will have to opt between the both nationalities. I think Israel needs a written Constitution, approved by the people in a "referendum", after being by the Knesset. It will enforce very much her democratic system. Salutes.
Back to article