News
Coalition parties agree to delay vote on contentious nationality bill
Moran Azulay
Published: 24.11.14, 15:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
22 Talkbacks for this article
1. The PC-idiots opposing this bill have no idea as to the
(11.24.14)
damage they're inflicting upon the morale of the Jewish, patriotic population of Israel and I tend to believe that's the majority. The frustration is about to boil over, as we can see in the more frequent cases of Jews taking law into their own hands (price-tags included). How about thinking about our "own". No, Arab citizens of Israel have yet to prove they really belong & mean it! Just look at the Druze.
2. elections now!
Maxwell   (11.24.14)
get the lefitsts out of the government! they are anti-democracy. they want to label judaism as a religion. that is is wrong! judaism is NOT a religion. It is a NATION. IT SHOULD BE A NATION STATE for the sake of Democracy!
3. Lapid is discriminating against Arabs in housing
Scott ,   Ramat Gan   (11.24.14)
Lapid claims to be against the Jewish State bill because it will discriminate against Arabs, which is untrue, but he's discriminating against them now. The elimination of the VAT tax for Israelis buying their first new home only applies to those who have served in the army or done national service. Most Arabs have not served in the army. This is discriminates against them because they are not required to serve.
4. who is the prime minister?
cecille   (11.24.14)
bibi is afraid of livni with her 6 seats and fiery mouth filled with hamas rocketing israel and lapid with his phony references to begin and jabotinksy. How can bibi fight the arabs when he is afraid of these 2 as he scrambles for a compromise-his life story. He has hopes and ideas but no backbone or conviction. Weinstein and friedmann's critiques should be ignored. arabs claim every part of israel as their inheritance and nation while herzog and bibi coward behind compromises and cement barriers. This is why so many died in world war ll. Jews are a conflicted people, stilll sick. Likud, boot him out and open up for a ful contest.
5. FIRE HER BIBI..... Should have done it long time ago!!!!!!!!
Liora   (11.24.14)
Easy! Just like you did Danny Dannon.
6. Such a bill will easily pass in next Knesset
Chaim ,   Israel   (11.24.14)
Loathsome Livni and her party will be politically extinct. Lapid's awful party will be decimated in the next Knesset. Such a bill will easily pass.
7. unrighteous politicians
Rina   (11.24.14)
are easily manipulated by Islam (and Rome for that matter). Their time is running out, because the Nations eyes (currently veiled) are going to be opened in the Land of Israel (Isaiah ch 25). Manipulation is witchcraft.
8. There are humans and there is God
US citizen ,   US   (11.24.14)
any human counting on itself or some bunch of humans will be sorely disappointed; humans counting on God, at least, have the possibility of obtaining His mercy as He will have mercy upon whom He will. All we humans can provide for ourselves is death. Thanks and praise be to the One who offers, provides, and provides for life.
9. Nationality Bill
Harold ,   USA   (11.24.14)
I see no comments posted by Sarah B., Build Baby Build, A Belgium on this important article. I thought they are Jewish.
10. Livni is often wrong
CJK   (11.24.14)
the declaration of independence clearly states that we "hereby declare the establishment of a jewish state in eretz israel." if israel is not a jewish state, then what is the purpose of her being? the entire world understood that a jewish state was established and declared as a refuge for the jewish people. zionism is the right to self determination of the jewish people. if livni rejects hatikva as the national anthem, then what would she substitute for it. livni and the clueless lapid seem to want to turn israel into an american state. does livni want to revoke the law of return and flood the country with millions of enemy aliens. it is very difficult to understand what she wants exactly. it is naïve to think that democracy is practiced the same way in all countries. jewish values are in fact the source of much of democracy in the world.
11. on the so-called democracy thing
CJK   (11.24.14)
is it democratic that arab muslims in Israel refuse to serve in the idf while they receive social security, health benefits, the right to free speech, free press, free association, free religion, free education, freedom to incite against the state, freedom to hoist the palestinian flag, the isis flag, freedom to riot, freedom to form arab parties which enter the knesset. if the arabs refuse to sing hatikva they should be allowed not to sing. it is insane to deprive the vast majority of the population from singing hatikva because it upsets the arabs who are ready to murder us.
12. The Jewish State Bill does not harm minorities
Scott ,   Ramat Gan   (11.24.14)
It states what is a matter of fact & what should've been done long ago- that Israel is the state of the Jewish people. It guarantees the rights of minorities and their freedom to preserve their language & culture. There is nothing unusual about the wording. All countries, France, Ger,many, Spain, Japan, etc. give priority to their own nationals & their descendents regarding granting citizenship. Opponents of this bill favor granting citizenship to infiltrators & creating autonomous zones in the Galilee & Negev for Arabs.
13. AGREE WITH THE LAW
Eitan Eldar ,   Ramat Gan Israel   (11.24.14)
I am fully ok with it.
14. Seperate state from religion
Nancy   (11.24.14)
No to religious coercion
15. Nationality Bill
Saul ,   England   (11.24.14)
Yet another one sided narrative from the Ynet liberal left. There is no harm in addressing the reality that the State of Israel is a 'jewish nation' within a free and democratic society. This is the fact, and you should exel your fashionable and theoretical fears on this matter. If the law does not pass in it's entirety now, it will be brought up again in the future to be expanded on. Livni signed a coalition pledge to vote with the party that she is now a member of. Not to be selective as to what she like and does not like and so chooses when to agree or not agree. It is she that is undemocratic by procedurally halting a committee vote last week by undemocratic procedural means. She acting alone and without consensus on that day.
16.  I would rather
ky   (11.24.14)
have Israel as a state that has a Jewish majority than an exclusive Jewish state. If Israel is to survive in the modern world it must emphasize that it includes all religions and races on an equal and fair basis. Let it be a shining light to show the way, to a middle east that decapitates those who are not followers of the faith.
17. The nation is for new elections
Danny   (11.24.14)
when hopefully we'll breath a sigh of relief when Lapid and Livni will be chucked out of the coalition.
18. Jews already have their own country and still ashamed of
(11.24.14)
their Jewishness. They'd rather go back to Europe and be with goyim.
19. whole world knows Israel is Jewish state
(11.24.14)
Even if some deceive themselves into thinking otherwise. The declaration of the state of independence by Ben Gurion encapsulates what we need to know. The rest is constitutional and civil not statutory and command.
20. Separate state and religion
Daniel   (11.24.14)
Israel is a state for all Jews and should remain so, not the sharia-like state the right-wingers try to impose on Israel. In Israel, every Jew should have the right to live a life in harmony with Judaism, but every secular Jew should have the right to live their life without imposed sharia-style religious laws.
21. Nationality bill
ILetzter ,   Tel Aviv   (11.24.14)
I have seen the worry and crticism of Bibi. However , there is no need for worry. Bibi will back down and surrender to Lapid and Tzipi, as he does every time. Even if talks tough , it is only temporary.
22. Like comments :-)
Joya   (11.24.14)
4, 7, 9, 10 & 11 Cheers
Back to article