Opinion
66-year-old state seeks real foreign policy
Piki Ish-Shalom
Published: 22.01.15, 01:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. Wow! what a defeatist approach
Jerome ,   AKL   (01.22.15)
For a start Mr Jerusalem University, our immediate neighbours, the invented entity, are not interested in peace whatsoever. They are imposing an initial state without resolution of the conflict, in order to turn it into a starting point to fulfil their ultimate aspirations- that is no Jewish state in the neighbourhood. Only a blind and a self defeating leftist can miss the facts. To the palis credit I'd say; donations made by the international community are used for their private bank accounts and to finance a huge PR machine. We, Jews, are only interested in investing our money in the highest returning assets, ie, real estate, FMCG, VC etc..., Do we have a dedicated TV channel? do we have the same PR power as they have? Our spokespersons can't even speak proper English let alone having the sharpness of Saeeb Erekat's tongue. We do not employ people for their talent and merit. Our appointments are politically driven. And this is part of the problem.
2. Excellent article
Dave ,   Sao Paulo   (01.22.15)
Israel has lots of opportunities, both in the Middle East and outside of it. It cannot let the Palestinian issue drag it to international isolation, Israel needs to address this issue seriously and with the intention of solving it in a just way, both for Israelis and Palestinians. There is stiil time. And get rid of Lieberman, for the love of God.
3. good thing you are not in power. we'd be dead
ralph   (01.22.15)
4. No kiddin' ,...
split   (01.22.15)
And some class at least a bucket of it as the latest show of Bibi's diplomacy skills proves ,... For details google “Netanyahu’s Safety in Paris” ,...
5. international policy and acceptance
Doc ,   cape town   (01.22.15)
only suicide will make the world accept Israel. It's a choice ..popularity and demise or stand and survive. The world asks the impossible because it doesn't matter to them if the Jews die. There is nothing worse than the grovelling Jew .. who craves world love and acceptance .. It isn't going to happen. Last time the Jews grovelled ... They went to gas chambers. What happened to "never again" ?
6. I would not wrap my day old fish in this article!
Shep Fargotstein ,   Memphis, TN - USA   (01.22.15)
Just political critisism with no meaningful analysis. Nothing but garbage.
7. It's not foreign policy, it's the settlements
Dan   (01.22.15)
Changing foreign policy will not change the world's view that Israel would rather hold onto and extend the settlements, and have the whol West Bank, than have peace. The accusation that all the wars since '48 were just land-grabs has been 'proven' in many minds by Sharon/Bibi's aggressive expansion of settlements. Israel has not only failed to undermine this pretext for Arab violence, it has legitimized it. Abandon the settlers now, and Israel might find a way back to credibility. Otherwise, it won't.
8. What's needed is to smooth rough edges of Lieberman+reps
Sam ,   Canada   (01.22.15)
9. Another Radical Leftist w. no clue on Middle East and world
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (01.22.15)
10. Piki Ish-Shalom's Op Ed.
David Epstein ,   Laguna Hills, CA   (01.22.15)
In my opinion Piki Ish-Shalom should have let the reader know to what extent he thinks Jews have a right to a National Home and if yes, to what extent it should be defined within the Biblical boarders. I find it difficult to agree with the bulk of what is stated in the Op Ed
11. What kind of a Fool is this ?
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (01.22.15)
Shall Israel or any individual at all, conduct itself according to Worldopinion or others opinions ?. You will loose your personality if you do this and open youself to criticism of evil spirits, and you could even be evil posessed by them. You shall love Your neighbours as yourself yes, but not according to your neighbours opinion but accordinf to your own. Arn.Sweden.
12. THEORIES FOR CLOUD KOOKOO LAND
Ezekial Haim ,   UK   (01.22.15)
Your theories would work if there were no evil.Have not noticed the tremedous destructive human forces on earth.You can wish all the goods thinks and end up dead.Where does that leave you ?
13. Had Israel been a Jewish state as G-d wanted
Chaim ,   Israel   (01.22.15)
no country in the world would be able to harm them. But if Israel wants to be a country like all non-Jewish country in the world, they had no right throwing out Arabs and other countries have the right to boycott them and attack them.
14. Order for living
Rina   (01.22.15)
Israel needs to remember her Covenant with the Creator: the balance of justice and mercy; to care for her people first (good balanced living conditions) and then to care for the rest of the world with perfect balance of justice and mercy.
15. Shame
rina   (01.22.15)
I pity the people calling for boycotting of Israel. They clearly lack truth. Come to visit Israel and speak to the people on the street. You will be pleasantly surprised!
16. The erosion of Israel's standing in the world.
tiki ,   belgium   (01.22.15)
Would Israel have had a population of 80% Arab and 20% Jews, it's politics would be hailed in the world as an example of a vibrant Democracy and a beacon of Human rights. *Ties to Apartheid SA have become an albatross around Israel's neck. Swiss a.o. European ties to the Nazi regime haven't become an albatross around their necks. *BDS is gaining momentum. Funny that these 'humanists fire their 'humanity only against Israel and not against the multitude of other ''occupiers"! * Dialogue based on honesty not on hypocrisy, willingness not aggression. It takes two to tango. It's Israel who has been stretching out it's hand in peace for the last 66 years, only to be mocked by the other side. Suicide is not an option. Massada won't be repeated.
17. peace
atilla karagözoğlu   (01.22.15)
18. respect
atilla karagözoğlu   (01.22.15)
19. love
atilla karagözoğlu   (01.22.15)
20. bravo! well-stated! FYI this piece is PRO-Israel not anti.
Rafi ,   US   (01.22.15)
21. # 4 And obama's NO SHOW in Paris?
BUILD BABY BUILD !!!   (01.27.15)
At least Bibi showed up while obama watched a football game and looking as though he supports terror over liberty.
Back to article