News
Livni: PM's response to document shows why US, Palestinians don't trust him
Itay Blumental, Roi Yanovsky
Published: 08.03.15, 11:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
42 Talkbacks for this article
1. If near truth reveals Arabs Belligerant and Feral
Zechariah   (03.08.15)
The Power lies with the Belligerant and Feral Palestinian War lords backed by WarLords in all of Islam .Clearly the Abbas could not deliver Jordan Valley Verifications to the Jews or the Demilitirizations .One Base is the so called Peace Dividend which is now whittled away by ISIS the Shia Revolutionaries and El Nusra as well as the Neonazi Right and PolPot left .The least Venomous but also dangerous because of extreme Niave consciousness are the internationalists.
2. finally
adam moe ,   earth planet   (03.08.15)
i believe this....
3. NOT an Offer
Mark ben Josef ,   USA   (03.08.15)
The document displayed is not an offer. It is merely a basis for negotiating based on the principles outlined in UNSC 242 & 338 and the Geneva IV Conventions. Horrible as it may appear to the ultra right wingers, it is a sensible and reasonable approach to a start of negotiations, nothing more.
4. What is so interesting ...
Devorah   (03.08.15)
is that the Left and Ynet publish these talking points as if Bibi had committed a crime. Yet, these are the very terms the Left would agree to as quickly as possible. Ynet, you are tripping over your own feet and causing your allies on the Left to look like idiots.
5. Only Livni the fool would trust Arabs blindly.
(03.08.15)
Always trust Arabs. They never lie or imagine stuff.
6. If this was Bibi's offer and it was turned down
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NYC   (03.08.15)
Think about it, if Bibi had offered all this (and Olmert actually did) and Abbas turned him down it would have been touted world wide as proof that Abbas does not want peace. This is Obama's proposed draft that both Bibi and Abbas rejected. It is only being "leaked" now to hurt Bibi
7. How can anyone vote for Zionist Union?
Steve   (03.08.15)
It will mean a Palestinian state at Israel's throat, will it not?
8. Pals didn't accept proposal or else we would have heard it.
Sam ,   Canada   (03.08.15)
The Palestinians are only prepared to accept free concessions and don't accept anything that leaves a Jewish state for the long term. What we get are Israeli Prime Ministers making ever greater concessions as the US and EU demand. Israel must stand up for itself.
9. israelis don't trust livni .Netanyahu track record
michael   (03.08.15)
has been consistent. As oppose to livni's imploding political parties that she leads. The track records speak for themselves.
10. You can't trust "Excerpts"
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (03.08.15)
chosen by Livni. Half truth is a whole lie.She didn't, most probably, show Bibi's condition absolutely unacceptable for Abbas.Proof,Abbas did not agree. That way,Abbas was the bad guy and Bibi the good one. Trust Bibi with his tricks of an old fox.
11. The Palestinians are the obstacle to peace.
Serge ,   Antwerp, Belgium   (03.08.15)
So, once again Israel accepted to compromise and the Palestinians refused.When will Obama and the EU understand the Palestinians are an obstacle towards peace.
12. Is ynet is publishing this because the
lucifer69   (03.08.15)
elections? What else?
13. American document
Haim ,   Ra'anana ISRAEL   (03.08.15)
Your article is full of lies and untruths. The document you refer to was an American suggestion and had nothing to do with Israel or Mr. Netanyahu
14. Looks like a good basis for peace
Harri ,   EU   (03.08.15)
Other option is one state for Jews and Palestinians with equal rights and right of return for both.
15. .......but NO ONE trust you or the nebech!
oded ,   usa   (03.08.15)
16. And I don't trust U.S. Admin - so there !
barbara ,   Haifa   (03.08.15)
17. Obama's lackey-Livni the Leftist
Brod ,   USA   (03.08.15)
Livni cares more for Obama the Islamist than for Israel. Her pathway imperils Israel. Obama is busy pouring resources and sending his thugs to meddle in Israel's election so he can help his Leftist Lackeys to do his dirty bidding of dethroning Israel's Conservative government, and enable himself to be 'ruler' of Israel. It is time Israelis open their eyes and not be led to the gallows of their political destruction and surrender their sovereignty.
18. Israeli's don't trust LIVNI or OBAMA!!!!!!!!!!!
Sabra   (03.08.15)
THAT'S what matters!
19. More proof Herzog & Livni are Obama puppets
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.08.15)
Every single thing Livni did, in her political life, harms Israel. Especially her idiotic cease fire with Hizbullah, which cost Israel victory in Lebanon. Livni is one of the five worst politicians in Israeli history. This article offers more proof Herzog and Livni are nothing but pathetic Obama puppets.
20. Zippy, fact of the matter is ...
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.08.15)
... I wouldn't trust you as far as I could throw you and, quite frankly, you have gotten so fat, I couldn't throw you two centimeters. But I still don't trust you. Aligning yourself with Budgie (isn't that a parakeet?) doesn't make you any more trustworthy. It makes you a fool. Time for you to retire. You have long outlived your usefulness. And Budgie the parakeet never had any to begin with. Just fade away, can't you? Do you so enjoy making a complete fool of yourself? We all know about your "illustrious" career with the Mossad. Ninety percent of which you spent on your back. Go away. You're a national embarrassment.
21. Question is, why did Abbas reject this document?
Jake   (03.08.15)
It gives the palestinians 100% of what he said he wants. Netanyahu is correct when he says Israel has no partner. Livni and Herzog seem to be deluded otherwise.
22. Livni and Herzog are Obama\s lackeys
Menachem ,   Israel   (03.08.15)
We Israelis don\t trust Obama or his lackeys Livni and Herzog. We want a leader with a spine who looks after Israel\s interests and not spineless doormats like Livni and Herzog who woud sell their own mothers in the market if it would advance their careet.
23. I believe Mr. Netanyahu, it's beyond him
Moshe B. ,   Los Angeles, CA   (03.08.15)
I believe PM Netanyahu is telling the truth. The proposal at issue is quite reasonable, it's something close to a fair solution. It might lead to a real peace agreement. But it's quite clear that peace, never mind fairness, are not what Mr. Netanyahu seeks. His goals are land theft, ethnic cleansing, and perpetual war. So it's very easy to believe that he would never sign on to a reasonable proposal like the one at issue here.
24. What would it take.....
Rica   (03.08.15)
To shout this women mouth from all her low class lies. I wounder.
25. What's new?
Yani ,   Australia   (03.08.15)
Why is this a surprise, considered believable or important? It's just more of the same BS that has been going on for 66 years. Clearly Israel covets Palestine and that has been the way of it from the start. The only logical conclusion is that due to pointless piece talks Israel-Palestine is going to return to the days of violent resistance from the Palestinians.
26. Zeepee...No one trusts you!!!
NYwoman   (03.08.15)
Zeepee you have done nothing for Israel. In fact you have done much harm. You have nothing to show. No accomplishments even when you wanted to give everything up. You licking up to our enemies. Any Israeli citizen that votes for you and the nerd needs their head examined. I hope that the people of Israel get smart....and will not elect this horrible part.
27. Livni
Harold ,   USA   (03.08.15)
She is right. No one believes Netanyahu but they do believe Nicholas Sarkozi's statement about Netanyahu.
28. Livni
Ray Comfort ,   Lachapelle, Haiti   (03.08.15)
Since she's an Obama fan, open up your borders to all your neighbors! It has a wonderful effect on the citizenry.
29. This women nose is deep in the hind side of U.S
Fergnsen   (03.08.15)
30. Mark ben Josef #3 minor issues
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (03.08.15)
First UNSC 242 has nothing to do with it and is a RECOMMENDATION. Second 338 is a RECOMMENDATION. Third the Geneva IV Convention demands that the ARAB COLONISTS leave. Just mere facts that all of the above violate numerous real international laws including several articles of the UN Charter
Next talkbacks
Back to article