Opinion  Aviad Kleinberg
The Foreign Ministry? No, the Ministry of Divine Promises
Aviad Kleinberg
Published: 27.05.15, 23:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
28 Talkbacks for this article
1. Reality
Zechariah   (05.28.15)
Israel will not be able to build more settlements nor will it be able to withdraw from Judea and Samariah . It will be a Vast Militirized Area with hopefully Vast Missile Huge underground nuclear shelters and a Horrific Deterrant Launching capacity . Negotiations with the Palestinians will be for a Demilitirized autonomy with better than now socioeconomic conditions .
2. How fantastic, that Tools like Aviad are finely relegated
(05.28.15)
and reduced to authors of articles like this one, instead of really influencing our lives through brainless, suicidal, self righteous politics! Go Tzipi!!!!!!!!!!!!
3. Actually we don't need the Imaginary Friend, to claim our
(05.28.15)
Land. Simple history facts show, that no other Nation/People but the Israelites have right to this swath of soil. When anyone can bring forth a proof of "Palestinian" history/Kings&Queens/religion/tradition then we might engage in a conversation. So it is totally irrelevant if Mrs. Hotovely uses Bible or not. Her arguments are solid by default and it's time that the so-called "world" heard it loud & clear! Screw the UN, screw Obama, screw all the Euro-robots. They can hang themselves from the highest tree in the Euro-Kingdom. They are actually doing just that as we speak. We shall not disturb them.....
4. Hotovely
Deborah ,   Jerusalem   (05.28.15)
Finally someone that speaks the that the truth is in our Torah given from G'd and nobody in the world has ever found a mistake on it and no one will!!! Remmember we people and our forefathers where humans with mistakes but the Torah is Perfect and we should follow it to be Better people.
5. YEP
Ed ,   USA   (05.28.15)
Kleinberg says it all. And these are indeed interesting times. It's safe to say that even those most devoted to supporting Israel from diaspora are sitting back on their heels and wondering what could be next.
6. Yet shows herself for what she is ...an old rag
Al   (05.28.15)
Keep on entertaining right wing anti-religious zionists like me. Whenever I post something anti-religious, you post it. Whenever I post something against this rag Ynet, you ignore me. Ynet Yenta you are an alta shmattah.
7. Sexist Kleinberg cannot stand a smart Zionist woman FM
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (05.28.15)
8. you mean she is not peddling the opium you peddle
ralph   (05.28.15)
9. I can imagine any mention of the
DT ,   TA Israel   (05.28.15)
Bible would make the Left and the Left wing press go apoplectic . Good for Hotovely.
10. hot and lovely can do no wrong
Jake ,   Jerusalem   (05.28.15)
"no one in the world shares the outlook of the deputy foreign minister and her friends in the Yesha Council," SO?? No one in Israel seems to share the opinion of Ynet, yet they continue to send out the negative-bots on their site to tell us how bad everything is. No one in the world seems to share Israel's view of our living in 'Palestine' but we will continue to live here and call it Israel. AND we shall succeed. Remember what that famous prophet said, " there is no success like failure, and failure is no success at all." Smell the coffee, the people voted and decided, let the people's choice of a government do something and afterwards see how well they do, instead of sending us the pessimistic op-eds.
11. hotovely
david ,   jerusalem   (05.28.15)
hot 'n' lovely. she has my vote.
12. security arguments have failed
richard sherwin ,   herzliyah israel   (05.28.15)
Ministry of Divine Promises? well... as far as i can see the previous arguments of Israel's security needs persuaded no one who wasnt already pro israel as to the necessity let alone justice of our military behavior. So why waste more money and time on that failed approach? Spend it on some other ministry, like health, education, housing, and leave the apologetics to heaven.
13. Typical Right wing garbage she really is clueless
Janine   (05.28.15)
14. There can be no Diplomatic Solutions to -
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (05.28.15)
- The Word of HASHEM. HASHEM does not give in to the Other One, nor to the People with oppinions from the other One. HASHEM is Streight. and never compromises. May HASHEM bless Israel according to HIS Word. Arn.Sweden.
15. The man in the sky says me real smart, derp derp
Shai ,   Merkaz   (05.28.15)
16. #10: Can't you make a cut-out of Bar Refaeli the FM instead?
Shai ,   Merkaz   (05.28.15)
Just borrow the Urbanica billboard by Cinema City in Rishon and put it in front of the camera. (This is mostly directed at the person who called her "hot and lovely." People should have a baseline for looks, even here)
17. to the FaceBook TBers claiming this paper is on a vendetta..
Jew-C ,   JewLandia (Israel)   (05.28.15)
Obviously you aren't living in Israel and you don't read or speak Hebrew...all Media outlets in Israel are reporting the news accurately and the news is this: The Israeli Right thinks that they have won everything and they aren't listening to anyone...doesn't matter if it is the right wing voice of reason expressed by President Mr. Rivlin or external non-Jewish voices of reason. Basically these people are going to lead to the destruction of the State...and then once we are all in exile again...they will continue to blame someone else instead of taking responsibility.
18. Divine promises?
tiki ,   belgium   (05.28.15)
Zipi Hotovely is no Zipi Livni and thank G-d for that!
19. TELL ME MR. KLEIBERG, OH SORRY, PROFESSOR!!!
FO ,   Belgium   (05.28.15)
What a caustic critic you have in store against Mrs Hotovely saying "we must go back to the basic truth of our right to this land". Right she is, and I hope she will add and explain next time, that it is based on application of INTERNATIONAL LAW. And you, Mr. Kleinberg, sorry, Professor, you continue to juggle with "occupied territories". Never heard at the Tel Aviv University about, let say... the San Remo Conference, the League of Nations' Mandate that gave the Jews the irrevocable right to settle anywhere between the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River, including the Golan Heights, in order to create their independent state, a decision valid to this day in International Law? Never heard about Article 80 of the United Nations Charter? Not even aware about the real meaning of UNSC Resolution 242 as explained by its author? Of course all this must remain classified at universities as Tel Aviv or Ben Gurion. When ignorance or stupidity, or both, are on the verge of treason...
20. TELL ME MR. KLEIBERG, OH SORRY, PROFESSOR!!!
FO ,   Belgium   (05.28.15)
What a caustic critic you have in store against Mrs Hotovely saying "we must go back to the basic truth of our right to this land". Right she is, and I hope she will add and explain next time, that it is based on application of INTERNATIONAL LAW. And you, Mr. Kleinberg, sorry, Professor, you continue to juggle with "occupied territories". Never heard at the Tel Aviv University about, let say... the San Remo Conference, the League of Nations' Mandate that gave the Jews the irrevocable right to settle anywhere between the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River, including the Golan Heights, in order to create their independent state, a decision valid to this day in International Law? Never heard about Article 80 of the United Nations Charter? Not even aware about the real meaning of UNSC Resolution 242 as explained by its author? Of course all this must remain classified at universities as Tel Aviv or Ben Gurion. When ignorance or stupidity, or both, are on the verge of treason...
21. I am left-wing and find the attacks on Hotovely and Shekad
Shachar ,   Eilat   (05.28.15)
to be in the poorest taste not to mention condescending and sexist. They are two bright and capable young women who will do the job they have been elected to do. The fact that they say what they think is highly commendable in the very cynical political arena. While I don't agree with their views they are a breath of fresh air and for all our sakes, I hope they succeed.
22. Hotovely is plain wonderful! I hope she never changes
Chaim ,   Israel   (05.28.15)
Hotovely is beautiful inside and outside. She is absolutely correct that Israel should claim our 4,000 year old Homeland and stop talking about "security". Stop deferring to fictional "Palestine". Hotovely is a wonderful change from cowardly leftists, who do nothing but harm Israel. She is plain wonderful! I hope she never changes. The facts are so overwhelmingly pro-Israel that nobody can mount a rational fair argument against Jewish ownership of this tiny land.
23. #10 brains and good looks, hot dog!
Larry ,   LA (formerly)   (05.28.15)
Why be stuck with brainless women like Livni and Bar On (Meretz) and Yackamovitch who lack charm and grace, when we can have some one with brains and looks like Hot and lovely Hotovely? Go, Hotovely, go!
24. To my Left-wing friend
Bill, Tel Aviv   (05.29.15)
If you write about this woman like you did in the article we will never have the days of Rabin. Where are the big men like Rabin?
25. #21 is to be commended for keeping an open mind
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (05.28.15)
26. i'll take her divine over your delusional.she's more realist
ralph   (05.28.15)
27. HOTEVELY
DANIEL ,   JERUSALEM ISRAEL   (05.29.15)
SPINOZA WRITES IN A TEXT CALLED "TODAY THE JEWS" THAT THE JEWISH PEOPLE HAVE SURVIVED THANKS TO 2 FACTS: CIRCUMCISION AND HATRED FROM THE OTHER NATIONS. THIS IS EXACLT THE DARWINIAN JOB OF HOTOVELY AND THE LIKES OF HER: UNCONTROLABLE AGENTS WORKING FOR THE SURVIVAL OF THE JEWISH PEOPLE, WHICH MIGHT WORK ONCE AGAIN,, BUT CERTAINLY NOT FOR THE SURVIVAL OF ISRAEL
28. Yediot? No, the ministry of mind control and propaganda.
(05.29.15)
Back to article