Opinion  Nahum Barnea
Where did the West go wrong?
Nahum Barnea
Published: 09.09.15, 00:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
17 Talkbacks for this article
1. Where did the West go wrong, he asks?
Cameron ,   USA   (09.09.15)
In assuming Islamic lands possessed the cultural strength & wisdom to suppress the feudal and self-defeating qualities lurking within the Muslim creed. Truly, we did err in that judgment.
2. What a load of BS
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (09.09.15)
They are not fleeing for their lives - they are fleeing refugee camps where they were being fed, clothed and free from harm. That is what they are fleeing. Why does the West have to provide them even more?
3. An Article worthy of candidate for Miss Universe or such....
(09.09.15)
4. dead wrong as usual
hy   (09.09.15)
there are over 22 moslem countries well able to take in refugees. NO doubt turkey as encouraged this dump of refugees. Given the upbringing, refugees willnot assimilate, will hate christianity and european culture. Europe knows this well with its current predicament. Barnea continues his outrageous articles best described as a self hating person. He hates himself, he hates his country, he hates almost everything.
5. naive stupidity. oh, well. some one must hire these people.
ralph   (09.09.15)
6. What we do wrong is allowing islam to grow
Berk ,   Amsterdam   (09.09.15)
Before we know all of us are obliged to eat halal and all women should wear a veil. Fact is the EU has a huge housing shortage. The asylum seekers will become very angry if not all of them will get a free apartment. Saudi Arabia has already offered to build 500 mosques in Germany. Mrs. Merkel is still sleeping though.
7. the arab world never went right
richard sherwin ,   herzliyah israel   (09.09.15)
the west didnt go wrong, except for believing arab intellectuals who kept saying they wanted an end to this or that tyranny and the west to intervene (political pressure, military economic et al) to force it on countries that had no history or institutions to support let alone develop anything resembling western 'democracies'. obviously, the refugees arent running towards saudia or oman or iran or iraq... but towards the west that went right, and keeps on going right-- or at least MORE right than any arab or moslem country.
8. You got Bush wrong
Fred Willis ,   Chicago USA   (09.09.15)
Bush only wanted to beat up some A-rabs as vengeance for 9/11. That is the long and short of it. His "Democracy" gambit was just a cover. He forced Israel to give up Gaza and allow elections as a service to his cover story. Time to grow up.
9. Why?
Brad ,   USA   (09.09.15)
Did the West start the war in Syria? Answer: No. Why does the West have to work for an agreement so Muslims will stop killing Muslims? Answer: It doesn't. Where did the West go wrong? Answer: 1) in pressuring Israel to make concessions for peace that never comes. 2) in making agreements with Muslims and expecting the Muslims to keep their word. 3) in letting itself be invaded by third world trash who think they are owed a living. 4) in being dumb enough to believe that Obama wants Justice. 5) in being dumb enough to still insist that Islam is a peaceful religion. Does the author of the above article have any brain waves?
10. europeans and the saxon desperate.........
Calabi ,   Sydney Aust   (09.09.15)
Europeans and the saxon are desperate to adjust themselves to gain foothold and favor from the Arabs for oil, gas & cheap labor. Europe & England have nothing in resources except some technology but CHINA is heading to be Greater China taking over centuries of white domination. China is also gaining foothold in Africa. Hitler said, who ever control Africa control Europe so the future is more than desperate for the Europeans! To start a war with Russia & China? Look what happen the Americans forced the Russian into Sino Russian military pact! What is left for the European to play politics is 1,000,000,000 muslim have nothing big to play with. Now first sell their Churches and then sell their forefathers Names & Heritage. Otherwise if history ever repeat itself the far right will surely take over. Not a good news for the world at large.
11. Unproven mythical fantasy fiction.
Murray the K ,   Brooklyn, NY   (09.09.15)
12. Iran + Russia - what went wrong
i-terrror   (09.09.15)
These two nations allowed their leaders to conduct history's another immoral campaign. These leaders robbed their own nation blind, and plotted to murder both sides in the Afghan, Pakistani, Syrian, Palestinian, Lebanese wars. The West just negotiated with the Putins and Khameneis.
13. Bush's lousy legacy
Larry ,   LA (formerly)   (09.09.15)
It was Bush who really screwed up the ME. He sent troops in to get Sadaam Hussein who Bush 'suspected' of having weapons of mass destruction and never found anything since Sadaam only had a big mouth. Bush's having Sadaam killed instead of putting a democratic government into a place that does not think like Americans nor like Americans did not work well. Instead of a democracy we got total anarchy fed by the Islamic crazies who seem to go up to the top. Bush's legacy is at best that of a person who caused a deep mess in the ME and at worst he could be called a war criminal. Going on to Obama who really cares little for facts on the ground, we are seeing the same thing. Americans seem loath to think and read what is going on. Instead of blind faith in religion, they have blind faith in being blind liberals that all will be OK with Iran. Some one should wake up America before they totally go down the drain.
14. WHERE DID THE WEST GO WRONG?
Erna Toback, PhD ,   STUDIO CITY, USA   (09.10.15)
A very mindful, articulate Op Ed. However, the majority of commentators demonstrate an unsophisticated ignorance of history and vituperative rage towards Arabs in general and the migrants in particular. Commenting on any of their replies would be a waste of time. Hopefully this article will reach a wider audience.
15. West Needs to Act
Christy ,   Boston, US   (09.10.15)
We need to put 'boots on the ground' and clean up these places the refugees are fleeing. Europe is getting swamped with refugees and it doesn't seem like it will end soon. It's one thing to take out dictators, like the US helped to do, it's another matter entirely to make sure a leadership vacuum doesn't lead to a rise of ISIS or civil war. It's in the US' and the West's best interests to clean up these messes. Europe will see a rise in far-right groups because native Europeans feel squeezed and ignored by the sheer number of refugees. I don't look forward to any European Country ruled by a modern-day Hitler - this is bad for everyone. This could happen if you listen to the rumblings going on right now. I have family members in the US Military and I don't look forward to deploying troops to these countries. However, if we don't get them settled down I see more war in the future that could be worse than tackling things now.
16. jails
marc chol   (09.10.15)
European Jails are full of muslims,why? Muslims fight each other in refugee camps,why? Jews sayed the most attacks in germany came from muslims,why? France have 750 places where the police can only go with many cars.WHo live there?? In Malmö every week a bomb,grenade explode now.From who?You know it! Ever heard from Loverboys?Grooming gangs in England?
17. MAMA MIA.....
les ,   canada   (09.20.15)
where do ynet gets all these mental case "contributors"? this is getting really comical. or are they being trained here to become comedians? :))
Back to article