News
Historians, politicians slam PM's 'distortion of history'
Ahiya Raved
Published: 21.10.15, 10:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
1. The Hitler-Mufti meeting occurred shortly BEFORE Wannsee
Jake   (10.21.15)
Wannsee Conference was THE turning point, when the Nazzis abandoned any idea of mass expulsion of the Jews from Europe and formally committed themselves to total extermination of all Jews. Apparently these historians are minimizing the implications of what was decided at Wannsee.
2. A LUCKY BREAK
Falcon1 ,   USA   (10.21.15)
A major ”lucky” break is coming soon to you Israel. Yahovah remembers His covenants with you, which are EVERLASTING.
3. Mythical 'palestine' remains Hitlers heirs
BUILD BABY BUILD !!!   (10.21.15)
of that there is no doubt. ISIS, Iran, Arabia et al. still insists on murdering Jews no matter who initiated the idea first. The Nazi's fell and so shall his Arab heirs from hell. KEEP BUILDING !!!
4. Nitpicking liberals
Dan Silver ,   San Diego, USA   (10.21.15)
The "mufti" was indeed supportive of killing Jews. That is a fact. The article is a massive deflection of the fact that...well... moslems have always, in all of history, wanted to kill Jews...Yet, these "people" focus on a quote and try to dilute the overall fact that moslems will always and forever be terrorists who want to eliminate Jews from the world - any other discussion is a deflection from that reality.
5. The Israeli Left will rather die defending Arab Nazism!
(10.21.15)
6. Yo, Thea of FB:"sympathetic?! He was a general in the SS!
(10.21.15)
7. Bibi and the Mufti
Alegra   (10.21.15)
Bibi is so at easy to twist reality,and now also history. When Obama said, Bib is not speaking the truth- he knew what he says. Bibi is a liar and a stupid one! He is only doing damage - never fixed anything
8. Jews Exterminated because of Nazi Defeat
Zechariah   (10.21.15)
With the failure to conquer the USSR quickly the resistance of Leniningrad severe losses in the attempt to conquer Moscow and the USSrR counterattack Dec6 1941 which threw the Nazis back 100 km the Nazis decided that Extermination by Gas as well as shooting and Starvation would begin in full . It needs to berememberedthat a million Jews were shot by the Einsgrappen from June 22 1941 to December 1941 as a revenge for Russian Resistance . The declaration of war on the USA on Dec 11 four days after Pearl Harbour was the Nazi Fuehrer declaration of extermination of the Jews . The Nazis among the Arabs of whom Husseini was the most prominent were then and are now - for the Genocide of the Jews but know of the Sampson option as a Reality Capacity .
9. What Netanyahu was factually CORRECT
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (10.21.15)
Not that the Germans needed any help in the matter. The Grand Mufti complained to Hitler after touring a deathcamp that the Germans were too soft on the Jews as well. He also raised two SS Divisions to aid them in their genocide
10. World oh world
Brenda Gleason ,   Cleaveland, Ohio   (10.21.15)
The world just cannot realize that these cracker converts are not Jews and have nothing to do with the most likely extinct Hebrew people that inhabited this land during the prophetic era.
11. Netanyahu and the Mufti
Michael ,   Haifa   (10.21.15)
Two insignificant characters vying with each other to be more dangerous for Israel
12. Bibi ir wrong, Abbas is correct
Gene   (10.21.15)
Common, these were not Nazis or Mufti but Zionists, as Palestinian leader explained to the stupid media in his doctoral dissertation.
13. On questions of History Bibi is more reliable
sasha ,   Bilbao, Basque   (10.21.15)
Son of his father, Bibi has probably heard this claim from ben Zion Netanyahu, which was a very serios historian. I do not think those who criticise him, especially on political side are Bibi's match. Let the historians discuss this question.
14. likud-meet asap and replace bibi
james   (10.21.15)
what the hell is bibi doing arguing highschool history lessons which do not do anything for the defense of israel. \never mind mufti. \yaalon- do your own defense policy and make it strong not calm for calm bibi who offers concessions and whines every second sentences. \arabs are attacking very well indeed. . this is not high school debating time. \bibi is clueless on how to lead and what to do. \he has no idea on his own. \force him out and appoint bennett interim pm until new elections.
15. Netanyahu sullies the memory
Sarah B ,   Tel Aviv/London   (10.21.15)
of 6 million Jews for his personal political purposes shocker. All the time Israeli politicians do this, it allows the holocaust deniers to gain traction. The Mufti was not a nice person, but neither was he the architect of the Holocaust Hitler had declared in 1940 that if the United States joined the conflict the Jews would pay the price. Wannsee was simply the place where Hitlers avowed policy was put into action. The facts of the Holocaust are known, no need to do anything other than stick to the facts. Netanyahu has done the unforgiveable, he has lied about the origins of the Holocaust. In doing so he disrespected the souls of 6 million people murdered, because, and only because of their religion
16. Comment on hitler
Sabri abualruz ,   Amman Jordan   (10.21.15)
Natanyaho absolutely wrong and has no evidence at all , to say that haj al amen al hussaini plotted with hitler to exterminate the Jews Palestinians as I have commented so many times have no hate towards any nation on the surface of this fiendish world , but what we see now , is (Palestinians fight to regain sovereignty on their land Palestine which they were evicted from Time has come , for the whole world to recognise their right of LIBERATION AND INDEPENDENT STATE ! PALESTINIANS ARE NOW THE ONLY NATION IN THE WORLD UNDER OCCUPATION ! ENOUGH 1000 years of scattering and lost ....
17. Comment on hitler
Sabri abualruz ,   Amman Jordan   (10.21.15)
dear editor yOur YNET news , doesn't accept facts , and publish the truth , racism , alienation is the motto of your magazine , Good media , must say and publish the truth and reality , I wrote two comments both cancelled , and you and the whole world know well the fact , how Israel was created , and Palestinians are the indigenous people of the land exactly like Indians the original people of USA , I know well this my talk will not be approved and will not be published , but I have to say time and again , GOOD MEDIA GIVE AUTHENTICATED REAL NEWS !
18. Article WJ, January 16, 2015
(10.21.15)
Why Hitler Wished He Was Muslim The Führer admired Atatürk’s subordination of religion to the state—and his ruthless treatment of minorities. By Dominic Green, Jan. 16, 2015 3:55 p.m. ET ‘It’s been our misfortune to have the wrong religion,” Hitler complained to his pet architect Albert Speer. “Why did it have to be Christianity, with its meekness and flabbiness?” Islam was a Männerreligion—a “religion of men”—and hygienic too. The “soldiers of Islam” received a warrior’s heaven, “a real earthly paradise” with “houris” and “wine flowing.” This, Hitler argued, was much more suited to the “Germanic temperament” than the “Jewish filth and priestly twaddle” of Christianity.
19. Bibi has a point
MadDad ,   Johannesburg RSA   (10.21.15)
You should not discount it because of what the popular view is Also it makes sense and the timing is right
20. Oh Yea
Eshkol Hakofer   (10.21.15)
bad bad liberals, huray to jewish rednecks, no?
21. Media distorting Bibi's remarks
Shep ,   Memphis   (10.21.15)
I totally agree with what Bibi said and detest those like Herzog who intentionally distort the "intent" what Bibi was saying for political gain.
22. Mufti or no Mufti ,...
split   (10.21.15)
The zionists were making deals (kastner train) with nazis while they loaded the Jews to trains on one way trip Auschwitz and other camps less than a year before WWII ended ,... Mufti had no more influence in Berlin than his housekeeper and that's the reality ,...
23. # 4 ,...
split ,   US   (10.21.15)
"moslems have always, in all of history, wanted to kill Jews" ,... That's why they offered them an asylum in Ottoman Empire after they got expelled from Iberia and other European countries later? ,... According to Alexander Scholch, a renowned professor and expert on Jewish- Palestinian relations, the population of Ottoman Palestine in 1850 was about 350,000 inhabitants, roughly 85% were Muslims, 11% were Christians and 4% Jews, why they didn't kill them then? ,... Why did they live in relative peace and harmony until the zionists showed up? ,... Idiot !!! ,...
24. Guy Schoemann @ FB ,...
split   (10.21.15)
Not so, according to Alexander Scholch (you can check who he was) the 1922 British census recorded the population of Palestine as 757,000, of which 78% were Muslims, 11% were Jews, 10% were Christians and 1% were Druze. You can confirm it ar wiki and other sources. This number was underestimated after '48 by zionists deliberately to deligitimize them and their claim to that soil as a nation ,...
25. Pinhead Yishai A. Kohen @ FB ,...
split   (10.21.15)
"Al-Husseini had met Adolf Eichmann, Adolf Hitler's chief architect of the Holocaust, several times to settle details of the slaughter' Zionist's negotiator Rudolf Kastner met with A. Eichmann on regular bases less than a year before WWII ended. Due to their deal they send 600.000 Hungarian Jews on one way trip to Auschwitz to save 1600 his zionist handlers relatives ,... In regard to you link to your source "Page not found" ,...
26. The bad thing about humans is
US citizen ,   US   (10.21.15)
we're human; the good thing is one is as good as the next and it's been said none good but the One who is greater than all of us mere humans.
27. Bibi
Zvi ,   Toronto   (10.21.15)
Beside to be a liar I tghout Bibi woul have a higher intelecctual level. What a shame for the country
28. Dear Scholars.....
E-SCHOLAR   (10.21.15)
See that Eichman tried to meet the mufti. The mufti was in contact with Hitler probably from 1933 or even earlier. It would not be a surprise to discover mufti communications with Stalin too. The mufti actively advocated to close the gates of Palestine to deny asylum to the Jewish refugees. Irony of history, the same muftis of today force free Syrians from their homeland. The reformed Germany is a different nation now. A great welcome is greeting the victims of the mufties in Germany. This may mean the end of the islam of the muftis.
29. History is a Biatch!
Koose E Mack ,   NY US   (10.21.15)
Talk Show Host, Dr. M. Savage did a Radio piece on the history of Pan Arab Nazi collaboration. Those who believe that the Intifada and Jew Hatred are about the occupation of Palestinian Lands are full of it. Arabs were killing Jews in Palestine long before the establishment of the State of Israel! The majority of Arabs hate Jews from the time they are old enough to walk! Palestinians need no excuses to hate us other than their religious beliefs.
30. No the first time zionist distorted history
James USA   (10.21.15)
"A land without people, for a people without a land" "Egypt attacked first it was afterwards that israel responded" "We thought the USS Liberty was an Egyptian horse transport ship" "Missiles was being fired from UN School" "Rachel Corrie threw herself under the bulldozer"
Next talkbacks
Back to article