Opinion  Aviad Kleinberg
The Left must not adopt the Right's Holocaust discourse
Aviad Kleinberg
Published: 30.12.15, 23:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
7 Talkbacks for this article
1. Even Churchill not good for Jews
Zechariah   (12.31.15)
Although Churchill was proJewish he was a British Imperialist way First . He used to say :I fear looking at Chaim Weizmann so great is my guilt re the Holocaust of the Jews . But in the Islamic world the Nazis were popular . In Iraq at the movies they cheered when they saw Hitler and booed when they saw Churchill . In the battle of El Alamain 1942 many hoped the Nazis would win and go to Cairo . You cannot deny the Popularity of the Nazi El Husseini Grand Mufti of Jerusalem amongst the Arabs of Palestine . Islam has mutated ProFascist then ProNazi in many of its aspects since 1928 Withthe Muslim brotherhood . As for Churchill when they killed Lord Moyne in Cairo because he blocked the escape of millions of Jews to Safety Churchill went ballistic against the Zionist .It was 1944 the war was won . But not the Jewish Genocide . Netanyahu and others are Realistic not trusting the majority of Islam one billion people minimum would massacre the Jews if they had the Power .
2. PM
john ,   toronto   (12.31.15)
Any PM of Israel who is guilty should get a sentence of 10 yrs or more for not keeping the people safe. Depending on the severity of the allegations it can be increased. Otherwise lessons will not be learnt.
3. I am still trying to find a proper adjective to apply to
Allah Blah-bar   (12.31.15)
Mr.Aviad Kleinberg (by no means connected to Nazism), but feel there is not one proper to describe his level of "scuminess"...What a pathetic picture emerges...These were the people running our Justice, media, schooling system. Chilling indeed!
4. Sadly in Israel it's the religious Jews the victims fighting
Reuven   (12.31.15)
for their lives under the sadistic Bolsheviks with the support of the intolerant hate-filled left destroyers of Israel, Judaism and morality.
5. Holocaust discourse
Amit ,   Beer Sheba   (12.31.15)
The Holocaust discourse isn’t useful and detracts from that horror, but the level of threat posed by one enemy or another has nothing to do with the depth of their evil. Hamas / Hezbollah can’t annihilate us, but that doesn’t mean that they don’t want to, or that they wouldn’t do it if they could. Hezbollah pretend they don’t want to exterminate all Jews, but it’s written into the Quran, so they’re bullshitting. Hamas are open about their wishes (except when they’re interviewed on CNN) – it’s written right into their charter. Wanting to exterminate the Jews puts you on EXACTLY the same level as the Nazis, even if you aren’t strong enough to do it – the Nazis failed, despite murdering over a third of all Jews. BDS are trying to eliminate Israel, they may have “hardly had any actual success”, but that doesn’t change their intention. If you seek to destroy Israel, you are our enemy. If you support those that seek to destroy Israel, you’re our enemy. If you’re Israeli and either of the above applies to you, you’re a traitor and an enemy. You can be in favour of separation from the “Palestinians” (e.g. giving them Gaza and part of Judea and Samaria) without supporting BDS, demonizing Israel, or excusing Arab hatred and terrorism. Separation is in Israel’s interest, so the Right can support it too, as well as the Left. Israelis supporting BDS and demonization of Israel aren’t just “Leftists”, they’re extreme Leftists and evil traitors - just like the extreme Rightists that keep slandering the Shin Bet.
6. The "Holocaust discourse"
tiki ,   belgium   (12.31.15)
"Adopted" by the right and must not be used by the left. No, instead the left adopted the Arab Palestinian/Muslim discourse, which is completely inspired by the Holocaust discourse. Mr. Kleinberg, you're an idiot and probably one with a university degree, which makes it even worse!
7. #5, Amit, to give up ANY part of J&S
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (01.01.16)
ENDANGERS the WHOLE of Israel !
Back to article