News
Netanyahu: We'll surround Israel with fences to 'protect from predators'
Itamar Eichner
Published: 09.02.16, 19:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. Fences
Mike ,   Edmonton, AB   (02.09.16)
The are dozens of fences, walls that were built and every single one of them fail to achieve the purpose they were built for. Chine wall, Adrian's wall, Berlin wall, Bar Lev line, Maginot Line,come to mind.
2. Very good idea.It worked well in old East Germany.
Alan ,   SA   (02.10.16)
Israel's small size lends itself to such a security measure... Go for it please
3. Trump or Bibi Bibi or Trump a fence will solve everything
miki ,   tampa   (02.09.16)
4. FENCE
Rau   (02.10.16)
Good but please make sure the fence not erected on somebody else land....
5. Where is the freedom? Jews are imprisoned in Israel.
Rich ,   Toronto, Canada   (02.09.16)
6. Throughout history
Sagi   (02.09.16)
all walled cities, forts and castles eventually fell. Defense is always a bad option, offense is the correct way to go.
7. P.M., Sir, they are already digging their way in!
Jew-C ,   JewLandia (Israel)   (02.09.16)
and also these fences you speak of, will they include or exclude Judea and Shomron? What are you going to do with the Arabs living there? will they be living in a secure compound within a secure compound? Sir, with all due respect...have you really carefully thought out this plan?
8. Root Out Terrorists And Rid Israel Of
(02.09.16)
Them. One way or another.
9. AMAIN AND AMAIN!!! USA SHOULD DO THE SAME!!!!!
Rvkh   (02.09.16)
10. 1 Mike, Edmonton, AB: Your post errs. Hadrian's Wall kept
Rvkh   (02.09.16)
the Jews who migrated to Scotland out, the blue faced warriors who were so fierce, Rome feared them and built a wall to protect the Roman outposts. The Great Wall of China worked very well at keeping the Mongol hordes of Ghenghis Khan and others out of China. The walls on Israel's borders work well to keep people out although that does not prevent tunneling. The Berlin Wall worked very well for the purpose of keeping East Germans in East Germany. WALLS WORK if policed and patrolled.
11. #1 you are wrong
Moshe ,   Israel   (02.09.16)
The Berlin Wall for instance, caused that only few dozens of Germans managed to cross it into West Berlin, over its long duration. Likewise, the Israeli fences are a great success. Such is the southern fence, which virtually stopped the infiltrations from Sinai, and the one north of Samaria, which eliminated the thefts of Palestinians from Israeli farmers (not to mention the Gaza fence).
12. Will fencing surround ONLY Jews? If not, not worth anything
Chaim   (02.09.16)
It's Israeli Arabs, those Fatahs, who are the terrorists, so what's the pointing of fencing? You can fence your own home which doesn't have any Arabs, but you can't fence an entire country and include terrorist families. How silly!
13. Too bad that millions of Palestinians will be inside
(02.09.16)
the fence. You might as well go into a cage with a tiger.
14. To No. 11.
Bertram ,   London, UK.   (02.10.16)
Moshe, the point is that the Berlin Wall eventually came down. The East German regime - as with other Communist states - met its end as a totally bankrupt entity. Such walls are built out of fear and weakness, not from hope and strength. Israel must surely reflect the latter, not the former, or else it will have re-created for itself a ghettoised existence. Hardly Jewish liberation.
15. Don't encamp yourself
US citizen ,   US   (02.10.16)
Eretz Israel provides greater manueverability. I will trust and give thanks to the One that provides.
16. Israel and the world
Jorge Toer ,   Scunthorpe   (02.10.16)
I want ear premier minister of Israel declarations, BBC , and news paper's In UK ,,Nathanyahu said wild beasts, Here in Israel said, predators. SOME PEOPLE DONT SAID THE TRUTH. ??????
17. #5
Harold ,   USA   (02.10.16)
The famous Andrew Sister's song came through - Don't fence me in.
18. # 14 Don't you see the difference ?
Moshe ,   Israel   (02.10.16)
The Berlin Wall was erected to avoid East Germans from fleeing to freedom, not out of "fear and weakness". The proposed Israeli fence is aimed at preventing Palestinian terrorists from murdering innocent Jews, and as the Gaza Strip fence proves, it capable of achieving its goal. Thus, such fence provides Israeli citizens "hope and strength".
Back to article