News
UN council voices alarm at Israeli cities on Golan Heights
Reuters
Published: 26.04.16, 21:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
33 Talkbacks for this article
1. Golan is Syria
Truth ,   Europa   (04.26.16)
Historically and rightfully.
2. Netanyahu should invite the complete ...
Beary White ,   Norway   (04.26.16)
..Security Council to Israel. Then, as passengers sitting in the back of an open truck, let them travel on the road/through the fields were syrian army daily bombarded the people and farmers of Israel, directly from the heights of Golan. If they have a bit of common sense they will understand BIBI's argument on behalf of Israel.
3. The Golan is in Israel. Europa is where??
DOV ,   USA   (04.26.16)
4. Well thats embarassing
Jason ,   USA   (04.26.16)
How embarassing for Netanyahu and bravo to the UN.
5. Cities!
Claude ,   UK and Cape Town   (04.26.16)
Please could the UN define a city. If the Israeli population of the Golan is estimated at around 30000, we are a long way from having anything resembling a city in this area of land.
6. 'deep concern'
tiki ,   belgium   (04.26.16)
When the 'deep concerned' honourable members of the UNSC would express their deep concern on the real human tragedies/atrocities going on in the world.....and act on them, the world would be a much better/safer place! Instead these deep concerned hypocrites have nothing better to do than voting over a non issue where no human tragedy/atrocity is the issue! Their only 'issue they have is with a country which name starts with an I and ends with an L and happens to be Jewish!
7. It is embarrassing
DOV ,   USA   (04.26.16)
It is embarrassing for those who think they can solve the middle east problem by throwing Israel under the bus. The Golan will always be in Israel regardless of which politician is for or against it. There is no one to negotiate with on the Syrian side and there will never be one. In 1967 IDF held back from reaching Damascus instead they settled for the tundra of the North. Easy to defend and KEEP THE PEACE.
8. Truth, what is Syria?
Mark ,   NYC, USA   (04.26.16)
Is it next to Atlantis??
9. Useless Nations, millions upon millions have died
C   (04.26.16)
useless nations, since your founding, tens of millions have died while you did nothing. you have not lived up to the express purpose of your charter to keep the peace. you keep harassing and bullying the sole jewish state of israel. in the meantime, the genocide in syria keep unfolding, the islamic state is expanding, lybia remains a failed state, the shia terror state flexes its muscles, iraq is being torn appart, borders are erased, africa is being savaged, and the gnom of the gulag in north korea is threatenig nuclear war. the golan will remain part of sovereign israel as a security against the genocide of the jewish people. now mind your own business and try to protect women against rapes and sexual slavery and little girls against forced marriages.
10. Make IDF strong again to get respect
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (04.27.16)
from UN and others
11. IT'S ISRAEL'S OWN FAULT !!!
Fo ,   Belgium   (04.27.16)
The Golan Heights NEVER were part of Syrian real estate! Syrian borders were drawn by the League of Nations as were drawn the borders of the Jewish National Home in Palestine. The Golan Heights were part of the Mandate for Palestine (1922) that gave the Jews the irrevocable right to settle anywhere between the sea and the Jordan River to create their independent state. A right that became International Law, valid to this day, and reaffirmed by Article 80 of the United Nations' Charter. That the British Mandatory in 1923, ceded in a treacherous and disgusting way, the Golan Heights as a gesture of thankfulness to the French Mandate in Syria for having accepted to include Mossul and its oilfields in the British Mandate in Iraq, doesn't make the Golan Heights a property of Syria! In 1967, Israel didn't "capture" the Golan Heights, Israel just recovered the property that was stolen in 1923! Its time PM Netanyahu opens his mouth and tells immediately and officially this historical truth.
12. #1 Europa: but what is "Syria" today? non-existant
Rafi ,   US   (04.27.16)
13. Golan is not going anywhere... whether Syria exists or not.
Rafi ,   US   (04.27.16)
It is a vital, growing part of Israel. Syria had it, misused it - and now it's lost. Meanwhile Israel's using it productively, and it's not being traded for cold or hot peace. Perhaps Israel needs to take more empty land so that the UN forgets about the Golan, and really has something to cry about.
14. Ending Lebensraum
Mark ben Josef ,   USA   (04.27.16)
WWII was started by Germany and Japan. They lost and the UN was formed to outlaw what they had done acquire land and territory by force of arms.. The Geneva Conventions reinforce the ban on such expansion.
15. Syria is no more
Willian UK ,   Uk London   (04.27.16)
Bro sorry about that but Syria is gone. There is no Syria anymore the land will be splited to apease bashar and kurdish and separtist groups. SO END GAME. You chosed to flew war instead to face it GAME OVER
16. The world is saying: israelis are theifs.
Why   (04.27.16)
17. GOLAN
samuel ,   Montreal   (04.27.16)
Can you enlighten me with a few references?
18. GOLAN
samuel ,   Montreal   (04.27.16)
GOOD OBSERVATION.
19. Turkey invaded Cyprus and transfered populations
Avi L.   (04.27.16)
Turkey invaded Cyprus and transfered populations ... where are the UN? In some deep oil pocket for sure.
20. The U.N. is totally evil & doesn't deserve any support
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.27.16)
The U.N. is almost certainly the number one promoter of Jew hatred worldwide. It attacks freedom. It has dreams of creating a world dominating government. It is a totally evil organization that does not deserve a penny of support.
21. Give the Golan Heights back to Syria?
nibor ,   israel   (04.27.16)
Syria that has slaughtered hundreds of thousands of its own citizens that had an excellent view of Israel's Galilea valley when they jointly attacked with Egypt against Israel and lost not so many years ago? Israel's annexation is of deeper concern than what is going on in Syria? Who the hell are they trying to placate and why?
22. UN has no credibility when it comes to the Mideast
Shep ,   Memphis, TN - USA   (04.27.16)
The UN is about as worthless of an organization - dollar for dollar - as any in the history of time. 500,000 people have been killed in Syria using weapons supplied by all the members of the Security Council. So why would anyone consider their proclamations as origonating from a moral high ground.
23. #1 Golan is NOT Syria
Daniel ,   Not Europa   (04.27.16)
Historically....as in before the breakup of the Ottoman Empire...The Golan was part of that empire. Syria was part of that empire and Israel and Jordan were one large unified part of that empire. Historically if a nation lost territory in a war where they were the aggressors, they lost the land for good. Historically and rightfully Syria ( country arbitrarily created without regard to natural borders or tribes within those borders by Sykes-Picot) has no claim on the Golan.
24.  1 million soldiers and full arsenal weapons
mati   (04.27.16)
golan is israel. if UN thinks otherwise, send over 1 million troops with 1000 planes, 200 ships and nuclear weapons to try and take it. israel will wipe out anyone trying to take it.
25. Re:11, There is no truth in anything you said
Truth ,   Europa   (04.27.16)
A bunch of lies in an attempt to rewrite history.
26. IT'S ISRAEL'S OWN FAULT !!!
FO ,   Belgium   (04.27.16)
The Golan Heights NEVER were part of Syrian real estate! Syrian borders were drawn by the League of Nations as were drawn the borders of the Jewish National Home in Palestine. The Golan Heights were part of the Mandate for Palestine (1922) that gave the Jews the irrevocable right to settle anywhere between the sea and the Jordan River to create their independent state. A right that became International Law, valid to this day, and reaffirmed by Article 80 of the United Nations' Charter. That the British Mandatory in 1923, ceded in a treacherous and disgusting way, the Golan Heights as a gesture of thankfulness to the French Mandate in Syria for having accepted to include Mossul and its oilfields in the British Mandate in Iraq, doesn't make the Golan Heights a property of Syria! In 1967, Israel didn't "capture" the Golan Heights, Israel just recovered the property that was stolen in 1923! Its time PM Netanyahu opens his mouth and tells immediately and officially this historical truth.
27. The UN is null and void !
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (04.27.16)
28. Golan Peace Conference
Ed Stack ,   Boston   (04.27.16)
Invitation to peace conference on regarding the Golan Heights Invitees: Countries who claim historical ownership of the Golan, are legally authorized to negotiate for the residents of the Golan, empowered to spesk with the state of Israel about the Golan. DATE May 30 The results of this conference will be final Apply here to attend
29. pathetic UN
Lauren ,   Israel   (04.27.16)
Delegitimizing Israel's right to defend itself against Hamas in the Gaza Strip and criticizing our methods of responding to terrorism in the streets of our cities isn't working for the UN, so now they're once again denying our right to defend our border with Syria and ISIS in the Golan Heights. The UN is a pathetic front for Israel haters and our enemies
30. TO SAMUEL, MONTREAL # 17
FO ,   Belgium   (04.27.16)
Dear Samuel, in need for a few references? Read talkback # 11 and check its veracity on Internet. Unfortunately the Israeli "Hasbara" is a joke, as said once the British Jewish journalist Melanie Phillips!
Next talkbacks
Back to article