Jewish Scene
A rabbi in Iran—the Neturei Karta's fight against Israel
Kobi Nachshoni
Published: 25.02.17, 23:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
12 Talkbacks for this article
1. It's Amos Schocken's rabbi ! He can't be anti-Israel!!!!!!
ab   (02.25.17)
2. This is the decisive proof: religion can and does destroy
(02.26.17)
otherwise well functioning brain cells! No other explanation for this seemingly insane behaviour. This is beyond what any rationale-based explanation can provide.
3. No hope for traitors
Alexander Scheiner ,   Israel   (02.26.17)
Unfortunately, those traitors are permitted to live in Israel instead of deporting them. Neturei Karta does not contribute to the Jewish State Israel, nor to its people and definitely not to Judaism.

They are a treacherous Jewish sect of pathological self-hating Jews. They must be outlawed.
4. They are not Rabbis! - Part 1
Will Smit (Aerosmit) ,   Israel   (02.26.17)
They are not Haredi and do not deserve to be called Jews and most certainly do not deserve to be called the revered title of Rabbi, as they are definitely not our teachers, neither our leaders, nor shepherds of our flock, rather they are lowlife scum vermin traitors, who should be excommunicated permanently from Judaism (Karet) for their high treason and treachery to our religion, country and people.

There was an infamous incident a few years ago which highlighted this issue. The antagonising Palestinian society of a certain UK university invited one of these individual "Rabbis" to speak, in order to rub up the same university's Jewish society in as strong a way as possible. But this wasn't new, as they had previously successfully and appallingly invited George Galloway and a certain British Muslim doctor, who had previously infamously said that he'd gladly blow himself up in Israel in a pigua, if the opportunity arose. So you can certainly see the type and calibre of individuals that inspired the Palestinian society there! Back to the story though.
5. They are not Rabbis! - Part 2
Will Smit (Aerosmit) ,   Israel   (02.26.17)
Prior to the invitation of this “Rabbi”, the university’s Jewish society, the Jewish student community and the local Jewish community protested and did their utmost to get him barred from speaking, due to his incitement of hatred, but the leftist pro-Palestinian university encouraged the talk, due to so called free speech and the talk went ahead amongst a large furore and controversy. The “Rabbi” who came was called “Rabbi” Cohen and the Jewish society made sure to have a large presence at the talk, in order to rebut all his lies and slander and to show their general disgust, contempt and non-acceptance of this individual (who called himself “Rabbi”) to the general populace that didn’t know any better. During the Q&A session after the “Rabbi’s” talk, the beloved student chaplain of the university (also by chance called Rabbi Cohen, but this time an actual and wonderful Rabbi!) stood up and even though he was usually a lover and accepter of all Jews, the extraordinary and vile nature of this situation showed, as he stood up and simply said, “I am the only Rabbi Cohen in this room” and then sat down again. And this chaplain was ultra-orthodox, so this manifested that even the most religious Jews (who potentially could be more extreme in their religious outlook) are repulsed by these so called “Jews”, which is certainly a more profound and louder statement than any other less religious Jew could make. Thus all of Klal Yisrael should turn our backs on these disgusting and shameless individuals and all of their ilk.

6. They are not Rabbis! - Part 3
Will Smit (Aerosmit) ,   Israel   (02.26.17)


Therefore the authors of this article and anyone else for that matter, should not be giving these individuals a platform or publicity, nor any credence whatsoever and should certainly not be calling them “Rabbi”. Judaism is a great believer in free speech and acceptance of all Jews in our religion and culture, as is done in any polite, democratic and modern day society, but what these people espouse and say, is not polite and is certainly not free speech, rather the evil incitement of hatred and even murder and which is part of a disgusting, medieval and anti-Semitic society.



These individuals are the biggest traitors you can find in Judaism and they should be excommunicated and the authors and anyone else who has the audacity to call these individuals “Rabbi”, should hang their heads in shame. Eze chutzpa! Eze busha ve cherpa!

7. DEPORT these sickos to Iran !
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (02.26.17)
8. actually their views on many religious issues are similar...
Rafi ,   US   (02.26.17)
the heredi and their Nuturei Karta bretheren aren't called "Jewish Taliban" for nothing...
9. Time to take away their citizenship and evict them!
tiki ,   belgium   (02.26.17)
They should be treated as every anti Israel terrorist!

They don't deserve to be in Israel to pollute the ground they walk on and the air they breath.
10. Naturei Karta are irrelevant
C   (02.26.17)
they are not only anti-zionists and defilers of the sovereign jewish
state of israel.
the nature karta are jew haters of the most extreme kind.
they associate with and praise jew haters over the entire world.

they praise the holocaust denying genocidal regime in iran, the
islamic terrorists, louis farakhan, etc....
their religious arguments are not based on the torah, but on
false interpretations by some deceased rabbi.
however, in the large scale of international affairs, they are
largely irrelevant.
11. Actually, they should be deported from Israel ASAP, I see no
(02.26.17)
objection, not legal nor on moral grounds!
12. Ignore them and they will disapear
Robert ,   Antwerp   (02.26.17)
Each time an article is being published about the neturei karta sickos it gives them a forum they do not deserve. Through that publicity they manage to influence more haredim. Censor them!!!
Back to article