Opinion  Nahum Barnea
Rothschild Boulevard protest: The second generation
Nahum Barnea
Published: 03.12.17, 23:39
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
14 Talkbacks for this article
1. Imbecile Barnea's fertile imagination corruption
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (12.04.17)
2. A bunch of Tel Aviv die-hard Mapainiks does not Israel make.
(12.04.17)
3. underneath protests and barnea
eli   (12.04.17)
underneath the protests, barnea is desperate to reinstall the ehud barak model of govt, that is 2 states, concessions to result in shrunken borders and illusory and usless p promises of peace which will not result unless all the jews convert to islam or move to new york.

israei generals like barak, and shahak, and others have screwed up it big time with their political views after the idf. they simply all of them do not have israeli national convictions. they say they do but they see israel through the lens of the battlefield where israeli is vastly outnumbered, and they conclude we must make concessions, return to 67 borders with swaps and rely on usa promises. why not commit suicide because this is surely a prescription for it. ehud barak was one of the worst pms along with olmert, 2 of the worst for security in israel's history. bibi has been far better thougjh I am no fan. i prefer bennett, saar, feiglin and barkat.

generals have every right to enter politics but barak's experience as pm makes his views worthless. he did not fight terror as pm other than empty air strikes. he should not be listened to.

as for gabbay, who on earth starts out by saying we willl have to make concessions ie herzog and lapid;s views. don't say a word. lets negotiaate and see what happens. and concessions run 2 ways and not land for promises on incitement but land for land. so if haniyeh wants israelis land, then his brohters will have to give arab land and accept it.
4. If Right (Allah forbid) loses the government we're doomed!
(12.04.17)
5. It started...high time.
Tomer ,   Jerusalem   (12.04.17)
Keep it up and let it grow.
6. "The 2nd Generartion" will be the Religious & Sephardi Jew
DemographicsWIN ,   Jerusalem Israel   (12.04.17)
Just as all know the 150-200 year old movements calling themselves "Reform" Judaism
and its sister "Conservative " Judaism are quickly coming to a terminal
end and being replaced by the "Barnea style Assimilated former Jewish movement " that is total assimilation to the point of even becoming a self hating Jews those are the movements in the former Jewish American Community that are on the rise and only them ( in Tel Aviv and Haifa too ) but only there thankfully in American and in Israel is a healthy and
demographically growing Traditional Orthodox Jewish population
they unlike the others will survive and continue the Jewish people
and its march through history the others will very soon disappear
leaving not even a footnote or maybe a small * like the Jews of
Alexandria in some old history book. Jewish history is written
by committed Jews and only by committed Jews.
7. mr.benassi:exactly the opposite!
tomer ,   jerusalem   (12.04.17)
dear mr.benassi, i can understand your comment . But you live IN USA,so you most probably are not quite familiar with israels current internal situation.
(according to mme.hotovely) .We, the israelis are deeply concerned and frankly
are fed up with corruption,cronies,manipulations of legal ssystem,attacks on police,judges and media. We are not "trumpistim".
8. It is time to end the tragicomedy
Tehraniporou   (12.04.17)
Please give the poor pm enough vodka to have sara drunk all day, at her age that the best thing that can only happen to her; Nutsyihahuuu is sensible he may resign with peace of mind if he is assured not having to bear her 24/7. I will send a few glenfidish and cohiba siglos as a consolation if he resign.
Back to article