Opinion
Moving Jerusalem from heaven to earth
Donna Robinson Divine, Asaf Romirowsky
Published: 18.12.17, 23:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
5 Talkbacks for this article
1. Stop making Jerusalem into something it never REALLY was :
(12.19.17)
"international" cradle of "spirituality" and start regarding it as a (relatively) normal city, that happens to belong to the Jewish nation, that (albeit after having been absent for a short spell) has returned, this time to stay.
World nations never had any interest or active connection to the "spiritual" part except in their various books of creed; something akin to Shangri La...
For us Jews, it is real, both on paper as well as in real history related timeline
2. Rapture wrap your politics in religion only works in the USA
Katanga ,   Israel   (12.19.17)
Here in Israel we know better! We wrap our religion in politics! We wrap our religion in politics because we know that b'atid ya'vo (in the future to come) only the Jewish religion holds true redemption!
Meaning that these two op-ed writers have exactly no idea what they are talking about other than to take their political point of view and attempt to turn it into a religious statement. Doesn't work!
3. A Fine Declaration
Larry Winer ,   Oak Park, MI   (12.19.17)
While I appreciate the declaration, Trump's words should have been accompanied by action. The ambassador, as well as the embassy, will remain in Tel Aviv for the foreseeable future, and an American born today in Jerusalem does not have Israel listed on either the birth certificate or passport. Yes, a fine declaration.
4. 2 the Opinion Piece writers: what r u excited about?
JML ,   Israel   (12.19.17)
I would be more impressed if instead of carrying on about POTUS 44, you would call out POTUS 45 for his empty statement on Jerusalem.
If POTUS 45 were making a REAL statement and US policy change on Jerusalem then POTUS 45 would have ordered the US State Department to:
1. immediately change ALL birth certificates of ALL US Citizens born in Jerusalem read Place of Birth: Jerusalem, Israel
2. immediately change ALL US Passports of ALL US Citizens born in Jerusalem read Place of Birth: Jerusalem, Israel
Yes, "Jerusalem, Israel" instead of "Jerusalem, Jerusalem" which is what those two documents read today.

If POTUS 45 were making a REAL statement and policy change on Jerusalem then POTUS 45 would move the US Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem instead of signing his second (2nd) Presidential Waiver preventing that move for another 6 months.

If POTUS 45 were making a REAL statement and policy change on Jerusalem then POTUS 45 would quickly choose one of the four (4) properties that the US already owns in Jerusalem and re-purpose it and turn it into the US Embassy.

In other words, POTUS 45 forces me to quote Israeli Minister of Culture and Sport, IDF Brigadier-General (retired), Member of Knesset Ms. Regev: "Cut the Bull$hit!"
In closing please do allow me to ask you: what are you all excited about? ...POTUS 45 is NOT actually doing ANYTHING substantive for Jerusalem, Israel.

Instead of using "the best words" POTUS 45 should issue real policy changes for Jerusalem...because otherwise all he is doing is spitting into the wind and calling it rain!
5. Me and my cat
Bisbis ,   Earth   (12.19.17)
But god is in heaven and on earth
Back to article