News
EU ambassador to Israel: 'Death penalty will not advance us'
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 07.01.18, 21:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
25 Talkbacks for this article
1. What's the relevance of Giaufret's opinion?
Alexander ,   Tel Aviv   (01.07.18)
The capital punishment may not be consistent with European values, but you see, we are no Europeans, we are Jews, and this isn't Europe - this is the Middle East.

I fail to understand Giaufret's interest in and concern for Israel's domestic affairs. If Israel chooses to legalize capital punishment for terrorism, this is actually a domestic Israeli affair and concern.

Is Giaufret insinuating that since Europeans don't approve of capital punishment in their native European countries, Israelis/Jews may approve of capital punishment in Israel either?

He merely wanted to make EU's stance clear? And why is the EU's "stance" on Israeli domestic affairs relevant?

I'm not even remotely interested in Giaufret's or the Europeans' opinions neither on Israel nor on our domestic affairs.

Giaufret is a typical classic old school native White Christian European anti-Semitic 19th and 20th century European style imperialist - the same old racist condescending attitude to Jews and non-Europeans, always finding an excuse to lecture non-Europeans on non-European soil what to do.

Just like Western Rome fell approximately 1500 years ago - the great scourge and curse of the ancient world, European civilization too will fall apart, and there will be a cry of joy across the globe when the European scourge and curse falls once and for all.
2. The EU is against Israel
Tova ,   Canada   (01.07.18)
Giaufret doesn't have a clue of what he is talking about. Jerusalem is a Jewish city, capital of Israel that all he had to say. Christian history is embedded in the Torah and the New Testament is based in Judaism. Evangelical Christians are very much aware that Israel is a Jewish state and Christian Zionist support Israel. Which is completely different that the vatican which rejects Israel.

The UN rejected Israel claim to Jerusalem. That is a declaration of war against Israel. Their rejection is that of Pharoh. When he refused to listen to Moses. Pharoah declared death to his household announcing the death of all jewish children. In doing so, Pharaoh declared the ruin of Egypt. And now the UN has declared the ruin of Europe.
3. how much .....
steve s   (01.08.18)
How much oil is purchased by EU nations from Saudi Arabia? The same Saudi Arabia with a very active death penalty law. The EU are hypocrites.
4. "A violation of human dignity." The man is a jackass.
David ,   Hartford USA   (01.08.18)
Where is the 'dignity' in stabbing an Israeli in the neck? Where is the 'dignity' in slaughtering a family asleep in their beds? Where is the 'dignity' in butchering rabbis at prayer?

The EU ambassador, how shall I say it, is a shmuck. Jewish lives have no value to him or the EU, but we must keep Muslim murderers alive until they die of old age in prison or are released at the request of the EU as a goodwill gesture to Abbas and ilk.

The death penalty should be used for every terrorist that is convicted of killing an Israeli. Every would-be terrorist should know that if they kill, they will die. But that's what they want anyway, to be killed and be rewarded with their 72 virgins. Their executions will simply prevent them from ever taking part in any future terrorist activity.

So while the EU pulls out its collective hair in angst while its citizens are being murdered by Muslim psychopaths, at least Israel can take a stand and say 'no' to terrorists.

The EU, a cesspool of pandering idiots watching their countries self-destruct. At least England finally woke up and got out.

I wonder if Ambassador Giaufret would still hold the same opinion if it were his family that was mutilated and butchered as they slept?

Just look at his smirk. The man truly is an idiot. Maybe that's the singular qualification to be an EU ambassador.
5. Re; French Ambassador statement
mark c smilovitz   (01.08.18)
Mr. Ambassador,
You talk of human rights and dignity for terrorist receiving the death penalty?
Really? Have the French come to acknowledge the deprivations inflicted upon Jews in WW2? Are those railroad tracks still functioning? Yes the ones that transported hundreds of thousands to the death camps? Did you ever ride a train on those tracks today and wonder about the dignity of those poor souls who used the same tracks that you are riding in luxury?Your people were terrorists by murdering Jews and you are lecturing Israelis about justice? Shame on you..Study your people's history!!
6. EU ambassador to Israel: 'Death penalty will not advance us'
leo ,   usa   (01.08.18)
Did you try?

Cannot say much about terrorists, but I personally will be highly satisfied.
7. Euro-apparatchik babbling platitudes about...nothing really!
(01.08.18)
8. Same hypocritical arguments as Amnesty Association
Avram Goldsmith ,   Toronto -Kiriat Gat   (01.08.18)
First : As same regarding Nazi , criminals, drugs cartels, intended mass criminals, as self deference they should be killed on spot .
Second: ME is place where Arab societies doesn't respect basic right as sacred life, their cruelty behavior pass any European Law Basics, as Arabs are abusing the Democracy in order to achieve their goals, they will bend any law system by knowing of none consequence as this how they operate.
So you don't have any right to preach to Israel how should approach to criminality based on Jewish hate which happening in Home Land, for the last Jewish experience id defending innocent people in Europe started with Holocaust and continues to day with sharp antisemitism again.
9. Why doesnt EU tell Iran this or is $$ more important to EU
Alan   (01.08.18)
10. The EU ambassador is babbling.......like those who send him!
tiki ,   belgium   (01.08.18)
"We don't believe that death penalty is constructive".
You also didn't believe that anti terror road blocks/walls were constructive!

"EU money for PA & UNWRA must be transparant & for the right causes".
I hope he doesn't believe his own BS..........we don't!.

"Jerusalem is important for the three monotheistic religions".
Israel never denies that.......but there is only ONE landlord.

"Jerusalem is a very sensitive issue".
No, it isn't. European Judophobia is making it one.

"It's against our European values".
Jews have for centuries experienced European 'values'.

The problem with the Europeans is that they talk when they need to be quiet and are quiet when they need to talk!

Israel knows the EU number and it should be changed before it becomes relevant again.

11. Are Israelis demented?
David ,   New york   (01.08.18)
That they would actually think it's a good idea to do anything the EU ambassador tells them to do?
Back to article