Opinion  Sever Plocker
Trump’s Mideast ‘achievement’: A growing rift with the Palestinians
Sever Plocker
Published: 10.01.18, 23:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
35 Talkbacks for this article
1. Plocker'd feel better in Ramallah than in Israel,Trump spoil
ab   (01.11.18)
-ed his amicable relation with pals and caused their grievance towards innocent Ploceker.Oh woe !!!!
2. Left is dead. Never again
(01.11.18)
3. The Flocker is at it again. Has never had any credibility.
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (01.11.18)
4. Ship Him Out
DSM ,   USA   (01.11.18)
If Plocker lives in Israel. he should be exiled as a subversive. He sounds like he would be more comfortable in Gaza or the West Bank.
5. Rubbish!!
Eran ,   Melbourne Australia   (01.11.18)
What rubbish!! Trump is doing to the Palestinians what Obama did to Israel. The nasty look Trump gives Abbas in the picture attached to the article is the same look Obama gave Netanyahu!!!
6. Plocker
Michael ,   Raanana   (01.11.18)
Better idea, replace Plocker!
7. The state of Israel must not make pact with the Palestinians
(01.11.18)
The state of Israel must not make pact with the Palestinians, because it is written in the Torah, in Exodus 23:32 and 34:12 and Deuteronomy 7:2 that God commanded Israel not to make pact with the inhabitants of the Land of Canaan, that is the Land of Israel, also called "Palestine", and it is written in the Torah, in Numbers 33:50-53 and Deuteronomy 1:8 and 30:5, that God commanded Israel to possess all the Land of Canaan, that is the Land of Israel, also called “Palestine”. Therefore, the state of Israel must not engage in peace talks with the Palestinians.

The state of Israel must explain to the United Nations and to all nations that God gave to Israel all the Land of Canaan, which includes all the Palestine, as it is written in the Bible, in Genesis 12:6-7, 15:13-21, 17:1-8, 17:19, 26:1-5, 28:10-14 and 35:9-12 and Numbers 34:13-29 and Deuteronomy 3:8, and that Israel possessed that land since the year 1466 BCE, and that the Arabs invaded the Land of Israel (Palestine) in the year 635 CE, so that all the Palestine belongs to Israel, including the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, and the Arabs are invaders and must go back to their land, that is Arabia.

The state of Israel must immediately declare null the Oslo Accords and annex the West Bank and the Gaza Strip to its territory and dismantle the Palestinian Authority. The Oslo Accords are null, because they are against the Law of God (Written Torah), because it is written in the Torah, in Numbers 33:50-53 and Deuteronomy 1:8 and 30:5, that God commanded Israel to possess all the Land of Canaan, that is the Land of Israel, that includes all the Palestine. And the state of Israel must not give Israeli citizenship to the Arabs, because Israel is a Jewish state, so that only Jews can be citizens of Israel. This is not racism, because any person, of any race or ethnicity, may convert to Judaism.

The state of Israel must immediately expel the Arabs from its territory, because it is written in the Torah, in Exodus 23:31-33 and in Numbers 33:52, that God commanded Israel to expel the other inhabitants of the Land of Canaan, which is the Land of Israel, which includes all the Palestine. The Arabs invaded the Land of Israel in the year 635 CE, so that they are invaders, and must leave Israel, and return to their own land, which is Arabia. This is not racism, because any person, of any race or ethnicity, can convert to Judaism. Moreover, the Palestinian Arabs are killing the Israeli Jews, so that the Israeli Jews need to expel the Palestinian Arabs from the Land of Israel (Palestine), as self defense, in order to save their lives.
8. Plocker
Raptor318 ,   thornhill   (01.11.18)
Mr. Plocker
This is wishful thinking based on the wrong analysis of a book full of lies.
Mr. Trump is just clarifying what everybody is thinking. The Palestinians have had too many opportunities to negotiate and accept a peace plan and they refuse.The whole world is fed up with their intransigence ! Even and particularly their Arab brothers have had it with them !
It's time somebody shows them the door. Mr. Trump is the one whether you like it or not
9. The mental illness of Jewish leftism on display
Chaim ,   Israel   (01.11.18)
Trump has been a friend of Jews and Israel since long before he became U.S. President. Obama and Clinton have done nothing but try to harm Israel. Yet leftist idiots, like Plocker, insult Trump constantly while bowing to Obama and Clinton.

How can you explain the leftist sickness of insulting friends and boot licking foes? I guess, the same way you explain the sickness of an Israeli Jew wanting to see Israel reduced to a 9 mile wide concentration camp. Mental illness combined with a huge death wish.
10. We hope another 7 years
Lou Golan ,   Mi Ami   (01.11.18)
We hope that he will be in office for another 7 years. In just one year, the economy has improved, Companies are giving out bonuses. Illegal immigration is down, the stock market is up, the US military is being built up again, Black and HIspanic unemployment has hit a long time low. Hopefully the wall will be built and the US has recognized Jerusalem as our capital. It keeps getting better and better.
11. It is rather time to dissolve the PLO's PA and...
NadavKatz   (01.11.18)
1. Dissolve the PLO's PA and outlaw the PLO and components

2. Appoint local/regional governors in present day Areas A and B who will also be the governing body of the newly formed Autonomous Arab Area

3. Incorporate the Arab villages that surround Jerusalem and the Triangle into the AAA

4. Apply Israeli law over present day Area C

The above contour is anchored in universal and Jewish morality, and in international law and UN Charter, and it is designed to usher peace, security, dignity and prosperity for all, Arabs and Jews alike.
12. Attorney at Law
Ross Gallen ,   Irvine   (01.11.18)
Trump is the best thing that happened to the US and Israel. I am tired of the stupid pronouncements that predict his doom. These talking heads know nothing about America or how the American people feel towards the Palestinians. Frankly the American people are fed up with the Palestinians and their 6th generation of welfare. All they do is engage in the criminal enterprise of terrorism. Trump got it right!
13. President Trump is so beautiful. How I wish I could be near
Rivkah   (01.11.18)
him and soak up some of his radiance. I felt his love once and it was so wonderful: his attention at reading a letter I sent was so radiant.
14. Trump achievement
Franklin Paredes ,   Quito   (01.11.18)
Of course, it has been better for the people of Israel, the rift is a clear consequence better now than latter. It looks like there is a rift that will lead to war, and Israel better be ready to it.
15. Plocker at his plotzkiest: takes a world-class cretin to
(01.11.18)
postulate the conclusions he arrives at in this hair rising article!
16. Like appeasing the PA did any good
Scot ,   Ramat Gan   (01.11.18)
For 25 years, successive administrations have been appeasing the palestinians allowing them to get away with murder, incitement & not demanding any concessions. Obama bent over backwards to appease Abbas, including stabbing Israel in the back in the UN & demanding a settlement construction freeze It has gotten us no closer to peace
17. Coockeyed outlook
Hayyim Edinburg ,   Ra'anana ISRAEL   (01.11.18)
Sometimes Plocker takes the cake for his leftist ways. President Trump will serve out his full term. He is far more conscious of the "Palestinian Lie" and
is taking the correct steps to attend to it. He will not advise any Israeli leader that it is necessary to give away half of our tiny country
18. Abu Mazan speaks
Judah ,   Jurusalem   (01.11.18)
what a Plonker, did Hanan Ashrawi write this article?
19. the ausa is not a third world nation
larry ,   nyc   (01.11.18)
a UNITED STATES PRESIDENT DOES NOT GET IMPEACHED for doing there job within legalities ,
with the excpetion of obama
TRUMP WILL REMAIN IN OFFICE AT LEAST 3 MORE YEARS.
this is not a banana republic .sorry liberal op ed NOT going to happen wishfull thinking on your liberal mind
20. "Don't believe a word the Palestinian leadership tells you"
C   (01.11.18)
presidents since bill clinton have said so.

abbas has succeeded in insulting and angering even his best
supporter, barack obama.

the arab palestinians, creations of the kgb, think that they
can bully the american superpower. now trump is trying
to teach them a lesson.
21. Jerusalem
C   (01.11.18)
jerusalem has never belonged to so called palestinians.
jerusalem has been jewish for three thousand years.
even during the five hundred year ottoman occupation
jerusalem was a jewish city.
why does the left want to give jerusalem to the arabs.
is it out of cowardice, or is it out of stalinist ideology.
22. When we got to finish with ghetto mentality?
Avram Goldsmith ,   Toronto -Kiriat Gat   (01.11.18)
Sure Trump can standing fabrications of Pal narrative and identity theft and being no a birocratic politician is putting straightforward the root cause of
the conflict, hopefully with financial repercussions to stop the Pal madness..
Would Israel the stance and not fear from their own shadow and act straightforward to dismantle the threat????
Seems as political trend is going in this direction as political unity is a must, as no place for faulty ideology ghetto style!!!!
23. Honestly this is one of the worst articles in YN I ever read
Alan   (01.11.18)
What's wrong with Trump and Bibi' .Two great gentlemen. The drop in Dem support for Israel is directly proportional to the number of ethnic US citizens who are dyed in the wool Dem voters.By 2040 for example there will be more US Moslems than Jews! So what does anyone expect of Dems.
24. Trumps achievement in the ME.
tiki ,   belgium   (01.11.18)
A rift with "the Palestinians".

Time for these Arab free lunchers to be catapulted back to their right proportion.....terrorists coming from Arab countries.

After this has been achieved a solution must be found with Jordan /Palestine about borders & Palestinian fugitives in Judea & Samaria.
25. THEY WERE ACCUSTOMED TO....
Robert ,   Israel   (01.11.18)
Palestinians have become accustomed for most of the world to scratch their back and they felt very comfortable that way. They received money without having to work for it, they received guns, rockets, knives, in order to continue provoking those who are not muslims (and other muslims, too). So it was easy to give away money to terrorists families as none of them had to work for it. Now somebody put a stop, a big STOP on them. It was the first time when palestinians did'nt get what they wanted and like an ugly child, they started to scream.
26. “WhineNet” declares war on US President
WhineNet-“News” ,   Jerusalem   (01.11.18)
And the 60 million American adults voters who support him that’s a lot of
Powerful Americans to offend “WhineNet” good luck
Hope your hate of him and then reaches their ears
27. A rift with the "palestinians"
A ,   OutThere   (01.11.18)
is an asset to Israel and the U.S.
28. A month ago Ynet "experts" predicted Trump pressuring Israel
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (01.11.18)
Now The Flocker is unhappy that the opposite happens and Arabs are the ones being pressured
29. It is Plokers Job on the line not our President
Nsanowi ,   NYC   (01.11.18)
I predict if Plokker keeps on writing nonsense he will be out of a Job.
As for our President I predict he will be in for another seven years.
30. Sheding Tears over a Rift with the Palestinians
Jossef ,   Nahariya   (01.11.18)
Steve Plosker gives all of us an example of what the Israeli left has become, and why they will remain marginal politically for a long time to come. When Steve Plosker accuses Trump of creating a rift with the Palestinians that "will reverberate for years;" and that because of Trump's policies toward the Palestinians US "leadership is finished and it’s time to replace it, just like it’s time to replace our own leadership," one can think for a minute he/she is reading a statement from Saeb Erekat. Yedihot Ahronoth just keeps outdoing itself by publishing radical leftists, each one more extreme than the one before. Using Steve Plosker language, while he does not know how long Trump will remain in office, I know that he probably will outlast Yedihoth Ahronoth current publisher, who will have to sell the paper or go out of business.
Next talkbacks
Back to article