Opinion
Trump's shock to the system
Maj-General Gershon HaCohen (Res.)
Published: 11.01.18, 17:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. Israel needs to retake all our lands given to "Palestinians"
Chaim ,   Israel   (01.11.18)
Israel has suffered, and continues to suffer, endless terror, wars, rockets and grief due to our mad policy of giving our land to our mortal "Palestinian" foes. Israel needs to retake all our lands.

Our retreat from our South Lebanon Security Zone resulted in tens of thousands of rockets pointed at us from there, continuous terror and wars from there. This is all true of our retreat from Gaza too. Israeli concessions and retreats are the root source of practically all Israel's most serious problems.
2. Unfortunately you're clueless regarding Trump, giving him...
Rafi ,   US   (01.11.18)
... far more credit than he's due.

Fact of the matter - as even his own supporters readily admit - is that Trump actually THINKS VERY LITTLE about anything... including what Israelis may or may not believe relative to land swaps for stability....

By all accounts, he has the attention span of a 5 year-old child.
3. land for stability???
Darnell Potts ,   North Bergen, NJ   (01.11.18)
there never was a choice between land and stability. the choice was between land or the promise of stability by the terrorist group PLO. We have seen the value of their promises.
4. Trump's decision is from healthy instincts not deep thinking
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (01.11.18)
5. Indeed: Israeli society will not give up territory for paper
C   (01.11.18)
israeli society has woken up and realised that it owes nothing to a
group of terrorists.
jerusalem has been a jewish city for three thousand years.
king david had built the city more than a thousand years before
the advent of islam.
the presence of muslims in jerusalem and in the land of israel
is the result of islamic imperialism and conquest.
the islamic ottoman empire ruled and colonised jerusalem
for five hundred years until defeated by the allies in wwi.
yet even during ottoman rule, when jews were expelled from
jerusalem, the city remained jewish.

jews have been praying for jerusalem ever since the babylonian
exile.
never again will jews give up their ancient capital, soul of zion,
or parts of the jewish homeland.
many millions of jews gave up their lives for their faith and
for their national identity throughout the roman exile.
europe was turned into a jewish graveyard by christian
europe in its unmitigated hatred of the jew.
yet, despite the horrors of the shoa, the jews liberated their
ancient homeland. a small jewish army, ill equipped, fought
off the combined arab armies during israel's war of
independence.
since then, israel has fought many wars, wars in which muslims
attempted to annihilate her.
today's jewish state and jewish armed forces are powerful.
never again will jewish children be marched into gas chambers.
whatever it takes, israel will survive as a jewish nation.
prayers for the peace of jerusalem.
6. Nice article for Ynet some truth
(01.12.18)
7. No legal basis for Pal state - Cancel Oslo - Destroy PA
(01.12.18)
8. It is time for us to act:
NadavKatz   (01.12.18)
The Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) set out in 1964 to bring about the demise of the liberal-democratic and sovereign nation-state of the Jewish people, the State of Israel, and the "cleanse" that which is defined by international law and UN Charter "the national home of the Jewish people" of its Jews" through all means and in stages if necessary. The PLO expressed the above in its Charter as the thrust of the document and has not amended its goal to date.

I, therefore, suggest that after nearly a quarter of a century of permitting the PLO to change its ways, without any success, the State of Israel ought to take the initiative, and within the context of universal and Jewish morality, international law and UN Charter, and in order to usher peace, security, dignity and prosperity for all, Arabs and Jews alike, ought to take the following steps without a delay:

1. Dissolve the PLO's Palestinian Authority (PA) and outlawing the PLO and its components

2. Appoint local/regional governors to presently Areas A and B, who, collectively, will also form the governing body of the newly formed Autonomous Arab Area (AAA)

3. Incorporate Arab communities around Jerusalem and Arab communities in the Triangle/Ara Valley into the AAA

4. Apply the Israeli legal system throughout presently Area C

This contour, I trust, will meet the desire of the relevant population, Arabs and Jews alike, who seek peace, security, dignity and prosperity for them and their families.

9. Dividing Jerusalem
Moshe   (01.12.18)
The author is wrong when writing that Trump's declaration about Jerusalem is against dividing it. The US president said that the future boundaries of the Israeli capital would be determined by the two pertinent parties.
10. If the US can survive, Trump & cohorts are all going DOWN
Rafi ,   US   (01.13.18)
... in smoke over the coming year. They'll ultimately occupy a place in infamy next to Nixon, Halderman, Erlichman, Dean, et al.

So to the right-wing Ynet haters & foamers who've proclaimed themselves here... you're betting on the wrong horse and a fascist one at that.

We'll see what you have to say a year from now. Hope you enjoy the taste of crow, even tho it's not kosher.

By the way, for anyone remotely familiar with the doings of the current US Administration (including GOP Senators & advisors), this article is clearly a bunch of bloviating nonsense & wishful thinking.

Whatever Gen. HaCohen's purported expertise is, he should stick to it - and stay out of US foreign policy analysis.
11. news flash: Trump & cohorts are all going DOWN...
Rafi ,   US   (01.13.18)
... within the next year plus. They will occupy places of infamy (if not pen cells)in US history next to Nixon, Halderman, Erlichman, Dean, etc.

So to all the right-wing desperadoes foaming at the mouth here in vain hope that Trump will be around to save right-wing, corrupt Netanyahu/Sheldon Adelson policy in Israel... fasten your seatbelts and prepare to taste crow (not kosher FYI).

As to Gen. Gershon HaCohen... not certain what your area of expertise is, but it's clearly not US foreign policy. This article is one of the biggest piles of bloviating nonsense Ynet ever published...

Your broad generalizations "Russian thinking... is non-linear and non-predictive" are right out of a consultant's BS book.

Your attribution of deliberate strategy to the documented chaos in the White House (that even right-wingers such as Steve Bannon acknowledge) is completely divorced from reality.
12. gerson, too many elites still believe in concessions
eli   (01.13.18)
herzog, livni, gabbay, gal on and lapid, an olmert clone still mistakenly believe in concessions and appeasement as a way to turn palestinians into reasonable partners. they will not beome that way in 1000 years. only if israel is decisive and more independent will arabs understand israelis sovereignty. herzog is an embarassment, livni is a nut, lapid is as dumb as olmert on securty and gabbay is a phony, positionning himself in the centre when he is like meretz.
Next talkbacks
Back to article