News
Lieberman seeks to ban poet from Army Radio over Tamimi poem
Yoav Zitun, Tova Tzimuki and Ran Boker
Published: 23.01.18, 12:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. Courage is Thinking your Thoughts Aloud
David Miltier ,   Kibbutz Gat   (01.23.18)
I fully stand beside Ahed and am proud that there are such persons as Yehonatan Geffen among us. As with Nazi Germany, in the end it will be dissenters like Geffen who will be remembered and honored by history. Yes, those who speak out against the evils of this 50 year oppression will be those who redeem us against fascism and apartheid.
2. GEFFEN NEEDS HELP
STIGMUND FREUD ,   SAFED PSYCHIATRIC   (01.23.18)
Anne Frank ,and Tamimi are two very different cases....
3. I DO NOT CONDONE VIOLENCE
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (01.23.18)
But Yehonatan Geffen needs a good slap.
4. Thank you Tamimi and Thank you Yonatan! You're HEROES!
ironbutterfly ,   Naples, FL   (01.23.18)
5. BAN DICTATOR LIEBERMAN
THEODORE HURTSEL ,   SAFED HONESTY   (01.23.18)
6. Tamimi
M Cohen ,   Johannesburg   (01.23.18)
Tamimis aunt must really be great according to Geffen She helped blow up the Jerusalem restaurant.
7. Boycott
Jez ,   Netanya   (01.23.18)
If one bans things they will hasten their way into the world stage. Silly move
8. Tamini is more like Hitler than Ann frank.
BUILD BABY BUILD !!   (01.23.18)
She's no hero she's a punk kid who's being used as the men of her tribe lack cojones or a reason or cause to act like fools.

9. Geffen is right
BBB   (01.23.18)
The blonde 'Arab' needs medicine and a jail sentence so she may rethink the error of her ways.
10. # 1 David evils of this 50 year oppression?
BUIDL BABY BUILD !!   (01.23.18)
Is this the same 'occupation' that allows you to reside in Israel?

You sound like you're mentally disturbed.
11. WHAT GEFFEN SAID
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (01.23.18)
Geffen made a fool of himself, comparing Anne Frank to Ahed Tamimi was shameful and ridiculous. Geffen should feel embarrassed by what he said. But what ever happened to free speech? Avigdor Lieberman has got too big for his boots lately, banning Rabbi Eliyahu of Safed and also Rabbi Aviner from talking freely. Lieberman is a Dictator who does not understand the concept of freedom of expression and free speech ,he wants to ban anyone who he disagrees with ,which is very dangerous.By the way ,why is Avigdor Lieberman Minister of Defence ? what does he know about defence ?
12. #1 SPOKEN LIKE A TRUE SNOWFLAKE
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (01.23.18)
Go live in Syria or Jordan ,what are you doing in Israel?
13. LIEBERMAN MESSED UP
CAPTAIN OBVIOUS ,   SAFED OBVIOUS   (01.23.18)
All Lieberman had to do was to simply ignore the incoherent and chlldish ramblings of Geffen .Dictator Lieberman wishes to ban everything he does not fully agree with ,he wants to forbid freedom of thought and freedom of speech in Israel.
14. TO AVIGDOR LIEBERMAN:
THEODORE HURTSEL ,   SAFED HONESTY   (01.23.18)
Sir, I , and many others ,also strongly dislike the stupid comments made by Geffen ,who apparently defends terrorists , Geffen made a fool of himself. But banning people who you disagree with is not the way to go, it is a very dangerous path and democracies do not operate nor behave in such a way. You come from soviet Russia which banned and outlawed freedom of speech and wish to import Dictatorial thinking into Israel, DON'T BOTHER.
15. When Tamimi is tortured and hanged comparison will be true
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (01.23.18)
16. Geffen, being a talented idiot, suffers from occasional
(01.23.18)
euphoric state of Elevated Academic Pomposity and nothing can prevent it.
I applaud the sentiment behind Lieberman's proposal, but don't think it should be implemented.
anyhow, Galey Tzahal-radio is a rabid, leftist chimera only found in a disoriented countries like our State of Israel.
17. Why does YNET ALWAYS use flattering photo ?!
MediaMakesHerAStar ,   Jerusalem   (01.23.18)
There are many photos of her but the Media
Always choosing the most flattering photo
Making her look like a star The Media is so superficial
Asthetics are their “god” maybe show the
Handsome faces of the soldiers she
Violently kicked Did this “Star” leave
Bruises on his leg
I wonder how the soldiers she injured feel
About the star status she is given
Really disgusting shame on the
Media no sympathy from Gergen or his
Draft dodging son Aviv for the soldiers either !
18. Far-leftist and far rightist extremists make the news
Sam ,   Montreal   (01.23.18)
Mainstream Jews of the centre left and right are less entertaining so it is the extremists who make the news and their minority opinion is given star status.
19. Why does YNET ALWAYS use flattering photo ?!
MediaMakesHerAStar ,   Jerusalem   (01.23.18)
There are many photos of her but the Media
Always choosing the most flattering photo
Making her look like a star The Media is so superficial
Asthetics are their “god” maybe show the
Handsome faces of the soldiers she
Violently kicked Did this “Star” leave
Bruises on his leg
I wonder how the soldiers she injured feel
About the star status she is given
Really disgusting shame on the
Media no sympathy from Gergen or his
Draft dodging son Aviv for the soldiers either !
20. No wonder Tamimi is always smirking
Ian ,   Newcastle upon Tyne   (01.23.18)
She knows she's got the useful dupes covering her back, even leftist Jews lime Geffen.

If Geffen placed Tamimi on the same level as Anne Frank, he's lost his moral compass.

THREE CHEERS FOR ISRAEL!!!
21. Leftist Post Zionist Media will now play him 24/7
SelfHatingMedia ,   Jerusalem   (01.23.18)
22. Tammimi girl openly supports suicide bombings terrorism
(01.23.18)
23. Army Radio allows terrorist supporters to push agenda
(01.23.18)
cant make this up. Army Radio allows people on to support terrorism and violence against their own soldiers. What shameless people on the left as usual.
24. Geffen
Michael Berman ,   Jerusalem   (01.23.18)
If Geffen cares so much about the palistinians he and his family should move to Gaza.
25. Geffen it’s pure garbage
Phoenix   (01.23.18)
Geffen and his son are the nectar of the filth.
Filthy leftist parasites together with all the rest of the leftists should be deported to Gaza.
26. Geffen=typical far left elitist
C   (01.24.18)
he has no understanding of history.
Next talkbacks
Back to article