Opinion  Aviad Kleinberg
The Temple Mount state is coming
Aviad Kleinberg
Published: 07.02.18, 23:39
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
25 Talkbacks for this article
1. we didn't settle Uganda. We came to Israel because that's
jos recht ,   la   (02.08.18)
home of the Jews no matter what happens. Arabs want Temple Mount State, Jews want to live in our homeland. After a millenniums of: Expelled, raped, murdered, warred on, and barred entry, now the return.
2. We should be building regardless of terror attacks
Scott ,   Ramat Gan   (02.08.18)
The fact is that a nation of 8 million Jews, soon to expand to 10 million in coming years cannot have the majority living in the narrow stretch of between Ashkelon & Haifa. The price of apartments have skyrocketed & are out of reach for most Israelis the Gush Dan. Traffic has become so congested in the center, it's become a daily nightmare.

The settlements must be expanded & there must be more. This does mean there will be one state with an Arab majority like the left always hysterically threatens. It means that area C, which has only 60,000 Arabs will be part of Israel & areas B & C will have greater autonomy, with possibly Jordan taking administrative control (& they will if international donors give them enough money).
3. security is more important than a foolish dream I agree
DOV ,   USA   (02.08.18)
4. It is the Leftist's behavior that is "not rational", that
(02.08.18)
much is obvious to anyone with a functioning brain.
"Terror" is a made-up entity: ISLAM is the proper name for what we've been experiencing tens of years now.
"Soon in a theater near you", dumb world!
5. Yeeeesssss
Lucifer69   (02.08.18)
Build baby build
6. aviad-you are deluding yourself
earl   (02.08.18)
arabs don't want you in Tel Aviv let alone Judea and Samara. you ignore reality much as Hitler was ignored in his early days of rise to power- IE it won't be so bad.

Olmert was one lousy failure as pm especially in security-he was awful. one thing he did however, was extremely revealing-he offered Mr. president Abbas, his own state, flag and all, some right of return though Olmert used different language, a bisection of Israel to link Gaza and west bank under plo sovereignty, most of west bank and East Jerusalem. This would have killed Israel, Abbas ran away from it.

aviad- zohar says to you and us, get the hell out of Tel aviv and go back to Poland or go to New York. just get out.

but no, aviad has the solution.

just as disunity of jews occurred at ancient times with Judea and Israel being 2 separate states, so disunity persists even now.after all what the Jews have suffered, Aviad has the nerve to not be able to see what is happening on the ground, This is an indictment of some of the Jewish people who think like aviad. they hate the gun, they hate being sovereign, they prefer to be dzimmis under the sultan Abbas.

after the holocaust, it is forbidden, forbidden to relinquish security and defensible borders period.

7. Yes to “Temple Mount country “not just state
Esther Thangjom Scho ,   Efrat   (02.08.18)
This will happen and the writer of this article will be the first one to welcome to put the inaugural stone ...
8. whatever the name of the state
khaosh ,   here   (02.08.18)
i think they used policy to kill not religion something organised
9. For left the answer is always to give in to terror
Mordechai   (02.08.18)
The left always have the same answer which is to give in to the terrorists.

Indeed she doesn't want to stop the terror which is he excuse to support anti semitic denial of Jewish rights to pray on the Temple Mount.
10. # 5 Thank you!
BUILD BABY BUILD !!   (02.08.18)
I hope I live long enough to visit the third temple.
KEEP BUILDING !!
11. When's the first stone to be placed for the third temple?
BUILD BABY BUILD !!   (02.08.18)
It's coming soon I hope.
12. Riddle
Rotem Adler ,   Paris - France   (02.08.18)
What do the Israeli left, the Palestinians and the RC Church have in common?

Answer: Their inextinguishable hatred towards Orthodox Jews and settlers, whom they would like to see burned at the stakes placed in the main squares of all the great cities... or in the Polish death camps.

Rightists who are against Orthodox Jews and settlers are simple infiltrated leftists disguised with kippas and Jewish books.
13. Nothing Imbecile Kleinberg writes is worth a moment reading
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (02.08.18)
14. reality vrs ideology
larry ,   LA   (02.11.18)
there is nothing better than wanting to live in peace with the Arabs. Israel has wanted this for more than seventy years; even before the state of Israel was created.

The reality of the situation is that the Arabs do not want us here. We are dihimis, second rate people and have no business taking 'their' land and ruling over them. It is against the Koran (yes, I have read it).

Not building in the West Bank areas was forced on us by the Americans. They believed the Arab lies that building was a deterent to peace. The truth is different. The Arabs are a deterent to peace.

We were promised this land by Balfour, by the UN, by the Brits (who seemed to renigh on their word) and even by God Himself! We fought a few heavy battles and wars to win this land from the Jordanians and we can do with it exactly what we want.

If we decide to build where we want it is out right and not the right of the Arabs to tell us what to do any more than we can tell them to stop the corruption and making women second class citizens.
Back to article