Opinion  Ben-Dror Yemini
Sometimes, just sometimes, the Palestinians are right
Ben-Dror Yemini
Published: 15.02.18, 17:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
31. Good article
Itsik ,   Jerusalem   (02.17.18)
Hope ppl understand
32. After further review,
Brad   (02.17.18)
Yemini and the "Palestinians"(no such thing) still have a perfect record. They are wrong again. All of the land, Gaza, West Bank, whatever, is Israel, and only Israel. That means Israelis can go and live anywhere they want in Israel. That's it.
33. Of course Tamimi disagrees
Mordechai   (02.18.18)
She says the residents of Tel Aviv are all illegal settlers who must be slaughtered so Palestine is liberated from the river to the sea.

The same argument was used to give up Gaza and all that did was bring missiles to the Gaza belt. It brought no peace. Indeed it cost more lives.

Of course the left wing politicians promoting these policies ensure their children get nice safe jobs as jobniks in the army while they let the rest of our children fight in combat units.
34. 100 yrs of stealing Palestinian Land by Intern. Zionism.
ironbutterfly ,   Naples, FL   (02.25.18)
Out of 33 kibbutzim on border with Lebanon, 32 kibbutzim are not "established" kibbutzim, which are sitting on former arab villages, whose inhabitants were forced to leave to Lebanon. It's a known fact and if somebody would like to know more details how it was done and by whom, visit there and have a talk with those who remember these events in 1948-1950.
And so are many other "established" kibbutzim. And this is just a tiny pixel how israel was "built".
35. Don't Fall for Arab Propaganda
A Simple Jew ,   Beer Sheva   (03.03.18)
This girl is Pallywood at its best. And, Yamini is a true shlep to fall for it. His commitment to Israel is so weak that he can be disheartened by a teen-age girl's theatrics pushed by her terror supporting stage mother.

Does Yamini know that the Tamini family produced a terrorist bomber? Does he know that "Shirley Temper" has expressed the desire to die as a martyr?

If he does know, then he is grossly remiss in not reminding us. If he doesn't, then he is incompetent. Disregard everything he says.
36. Dirty love.
Avraham   (04.07.18)
The author definitely falls in love with this young (17 years, not 16), blond with blue eyes provocatior.
37. If the shoe were on the other foot how would you react?
expatokie ,   mazkeret batya   (04.08.18)
good article and well thought
38. Arabs got to go!
yoni zimm ,   Hebron   (07.11.18)
Arabs get out of Hebron & the rest of Jewish Land!
39. Don't Fall for Arab Propaganda
A Simple Jew ,   Beer Sheva   (07.18.18)
Dror makes a fundamental error--namely that making a significant, unilateral concession will improve our position.The Arabs don't hate us because Jews live in Hebron or Neve Tzuf, rather they hate us because we live anywhere in Israel.

Make no mistake, Dror's suggested pull-out will be seen as a great Arab victory.

If we follow Dror's advice and leave these areas we teach the Arabs the following lessons; 1. Jews can be driven from their homes through violence. 2. If you keep up the pressure Jews will split, rather than unify, as liberal Jews like Dror will turn against their fellow Jews, and counsel surrender. 3. Arabs are willing to fight their land, and the Jews are not. Therefore, the Arabs should attack us even more ferociously.
40. coincidentally only.
(08.05.18)
If Palestinians have some luck then certainly Israel has strong justification,
especially where our new villages are concerned.
The justification comes from the constant Palestinian attacks on those villagers, that otherwise would harm Israel itself.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article