Opinion
The Holocaust Law: Origins of revisionism in Poland
Alexander J. Apfel
Published: 02.03.18, 23:58
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. Why to protest?
gh67   (03.03.18)
Let us admit that just as many Poles were ready to murder Jews, there were just as many Jews, too, who participated in the crimes of the communist dictatorship.

Our main goal should be to force our common enemies to stop their ongoing genocidal policies.

Let us hope that we can defend the planet from the Kremlin plots.
2. Communist Jews killed millions, got Hitler, WWII & Holocaust
Steve Benassi ,   Duluth, Minnesota   (03.03.18)
Also see Nakba Law
3. Immediate consequence must be stopping suicidal deliveries
ab   (03.03.18)
of Israeli military technology to Poland whose population harbours such hatred to Jews.
Reasons for the hatred may be interesting for sociologist ,philosophers,historians and allcomers, but Israel would be committing even greater mistake than the hapless Jewish population o the wartime Poland in trusting Poles,Jews mostly didn't have any choice,but Israel does have a choice : pretending that Poles (not an abstract Poland) are trústworthy or deriving logical conclusions from the past and present.
4. Do we, Jews and them, Poles really need each other that much
(03.03.18)
I'm asking, because if we can live our respective lives without acknowledging each other, then maybe in 200 years we can become friends again....?
5. Isn't it pointless to try and force two nations that just do
(03.03.18)
not like each other to smile& pose for the camera all the time?
I'd give it a rest.
6. Propaganda
Sky Blue ,   București   (03.03.18)
This is the tippical propaganda wich is brainwashing the israely people since childhood.They take a completely isolated incident în Yedbawne, wich was the ONLY antisemitic pogrom done by the poles during the war and try to make it bigger then the hundred of thousands of jews saved by the poles,. When soviets entered Yedbawne in 1939 jews started to cooperate with them in large numbers in the repression of the local polish population. When soviets withdrew, the locals decides to take revenge in the jewish comunity.. In Kielce a polish youngster was beaten up by jews, then a polish man was shot by jews as well and this is how the pogrom started
Let's tell the entire truth, , not only half of the truth.
7. thank you Ynet, Dr Apfel for well-written summary & analysis
Rafi ,   US   (03.03.18)
8. Jedwabne is a good starting point
Tomek ,   Poland   (03.03.18)
as it was a direct consequence of Jewish participation in ethnic cleansing of Poles in Soviet-occupied Poland between September 1939 and June 1941. I understand that Jews would prefer to ignore this particular aspect of WW2, but by doing so they will never be able to fully understand their own narrative. Once this one is done and dusted, the collaboration with the other totalitarian regime, the Nazis, should be dissected.
9. Fake News merry go round is turning faster& faster....
(03.04.18)
Back to article