News
Polish PM: 'No Jew could have been saved without Poles'
Amir Bogen
Published: 06.03.18, 13:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. AND I HAVE A BRIDGE FOR SALE...
MR CYNIC ,   SAFED CYNIC HOUSE   (03.06.18)
2. WARNING : BS ALERT.
THEODORE HURTSEL ,   SAFED HONESTY   (03.06.18)
3. Past versus future
BUILD BABY BUILD !!   (03.06.18)
the Poles would have more favor if they had NOT instituted a law of denial and making it illegal to mention the Polish death camps.
Many nations have pasts that are less than perfect yet, rather than to deny their past, they learn from their mistakes so as to not repeat them in the future.
Not the Poles.
To me, that's one added blunder to an already checkered Polish past.
Poland remains anti semitic and they seem proud to be seen as less than mentally sound.
Perhaps the Poles believe that denial is a river in Egypt?
4. Poles were Accomplices; active participants
Joseph ,   Fort Lauderdale   (03.06.18)
In a hundred years, your twisted truths may be accepted. But you were accomplices. You were active participants. You help round up your Jewish neighbors, stole their businesses, real estate and personal property. After you kicked them out of their homes, you stole the furnishings and personal properties, threw out the belongings and moved in. My family had real estate and centuries of property in Kielce. You Poles stole everything and think you can deny it with a trumped up law. Go F...K yourselves. you dirty little minded scum. I have avoided visiting Europe waiting for the evil doers to die.
5. Rabbi Boteach is due for an operation
DR .PEPPER ,   SAFED MEDICAL   (03.06.18)
Shmuley Boteach needs an operation to remove his nose from the polish prime minister's backside.
6. TO POLISH PM:
CAPTAIN OBVIOUS ,   SAFED OBVIOUS   (03.06.18)
Sir, no jew was saved ,not by the poles ,and not by any other people.
7. Absolutely untrue,both numbers and facts are false :Only 150
ab   (03.06.18)
000 survived,not 300.000 ,and mostly on the territory of then USSR or even in Germany,in camps
Those who survived in Poland,yes,sometimes because none of the neighbours knew they were Jewish or thanks to Poles,whose greaterst fear was other Poles would betray them,as they mostly did.
8. I am no doctor but you probably imbibed the hatered of Poles
Tomek ,   Lublin   (03.06.18)
with your father's milk.
9. SOME Poles were menches, many were bastards.
David ,   Hartford USA   (03.06.18)
Most of Poland looked on while the eradication of Jews took place. Could they have stopped the German nightmare by standing up to the Nazis? Could the townspeople have physically blocked the entrances to the camps without themselves being murdered?

How would any of act if a local family came begging at your doorstep for safety and you knew that harboring this family could easily get your entire family killed? Are you sure your own neighbors wouldn't snitch on you for the reward money? Might they like to live in your house?

What happened in Poland is a disgrace to humanity. But the Poles were stuck between a rock and a hard place: the Poles knew the Nazis would kill them at the slightest provocation and the Nazis made laws requiring the Poles to turn in Jews; it was hard to be a non-participant.

Yes, many Poles turned in Jews for rewards and stolen Jewish property. Too many. But some good Poles did save some Jews, that can't be denied. Alas, too few.

Did Poland save a half of its Jews? Maybe a quarter of its Jews? Ten percent of its Jews? No. That's the sad fact. The Nazis wouldn't have accomplished so much if the Poles, in general, hadn't looked the other way.

Did the world learn anything? About looking the other way?

The Rwanda genocide? We looked the other way.

The Syrian genocide? We're still looking the other way.

Poland has millions of skeletons in its closet. It can never change that.

But before we all point our fingers at Poland for what happened in the past, let's see if our elected leaders can put an end to the wholesale killing of innocents that's happening under our very noses today.

10. more Jews would have survived then killed if they not there
jos rech ,   la   (03.07.18)
were not there.
11. Polish "truth" - "heroic assistance" to their Jewish in WW2
gena ,   Melbourne   (03.07.18)
Ethnic Poles collaboration with the Geman Gestapo, no Jew could escape German Death Camps and Ghettos on Polish soil. 300000 Jews survived because they escaped to Russia, not because of the Poles "heroic assistance" and Morawiecki knows those facts but inflects them. The numbers assisting German Gestapo are immeasurably greater than those that saved the Jews, where those who saved the Jews were the exceptions and themselves were afraid of their Polish "brothers and sisters".
12. This Polish grudge (if true) could've been handled so much
(03.07.18)
better and more gracefully.
Actually ANY other way would've been wiser than this bumbling crowd of amateurs have embarked upon.
Now they're reaping the (unexpected?) fruits....
Back to article