Opinion  Sever Plocker
New Polish remembrance day: Manipulation or moral message?
Sever Plocker
Published: 11.04.18, 23:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. Read old Newspapers
Oro   (04.12.18)
Frok 1933 to 1938 700000 jews fleed from Poland to germany.Also all other minorities where terrorized and killed.Poland had little wars before with all neighbours.England called them Shakals.Perhaps Poland dont want that people knew it...
2. STOP this non-sense garbage, and Lies
ironbutterfly ,   Naples, FL   (04.12.18)
"Some 250,000 Jews who fled the ghettos, the trains and the death camps were turned over to the Nazis by Polish people, and thousands were murdered by their neighbors..." ???????????????????

Interesting, how the writer of this "essay" got this number ???
What is his source ?
Or he just likes to throw imaginative numbers in air ???
Next year he will change this number to 350,000...650,000..500,000 ????
YES, there were not 10 or 50 POLES who saved thousands of jews.
These were HUNDREDS of them, and each of them saved from one person, or one family to 20-100 jews and more.
WHY nobody mention that ???
WHY israeli media doesn't like to write about these glorious people ???
It's DISGUSTING all these "essays" how bad were Poles.
This is a typical jewish philosophy of most jews related to Holocaust - to spit and slander Poland which also saved most of jews of any other country.


3. How many Jews are saving Palestinians from Zionists
Steve Benassi ,   Duluth, MN USA   (04.12.18)
4. FAR SEER
DAV ZEE ,   Brookhaven   (04.12.18)
THE SAME POLITICOS THAT SENT A MILLION JEWS TO THEIR DEATH CAMPS, send up the same FAKE NEWS baloney
5. Oh boy, Plotzker: how naive can one be?! "National pride"?!
(04.12.18)
6. Every country honours it's heroes and tries to forget it's
Shachar ,   Eilat   (04.12.18)
villains. This is a necessity, it keeps a country united and functioning. That Poland is honouring people who saved Jews is fantastic, their motives are irrelevant. That Polish kids will learn about people who saved Jews is a massive step forward, something unthinkable in the communist era. This is a massive victory for Yad Veshem and Israel's determination to keep the memory of the holocaust universal.
7. This photograph does not show President Duda apologizing
Tomek ,   Lublin   (04.12.18)
He is greeting former Israeli ambassador to Poland Shevah Weiss.
8. Poles must be left to their destiny/national "character",
(04.12.18)
that unfortunately includes virulent antisemitism.
Just accept it and let's move on.
It's not the end of our (Jewish) world!
9. Grabowski's "research" in a nutshell
Tomek ,   Lublin   (04.12.18)
1. Polish Jews in 1939: 3,500,000
2. Escape rate from ghettos at 10%: 350,000
3. Polish Jews in 1945: 150,000
4. Polish Jews killed by Christian Poles (2)-(3): 200,000

This is pure, unadulterated nonsense. But he is preaching to anti-Polish choir.
10. Repent
MIKE   (04.13.18)
Jewish people need to first tackle the dark history of collaboration of Jewish ghetto councils and Jewish ghetto police with Nazis. Complicity of tens of thousands of these "officials" was crucial in final solution. Painful, but they should do it. "Why did you cooperate in the destruction of your own people?" asks Jewish philosopher Hanna Arendt in " Eichmann in Jerusalem", page 124
Back to article