Opinion  Ben-Dror Yemini
Judges are not God
Ben-Dror Yemini
Published: 21.04.18, 12:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
12 Talkbacks for this article
1. Judges are not gods,but neither soldiers who murder Pal kids
Haim Haim ,   HAIFA   (04.21.18)
2. Surely Aharon Barak thought himself a Messiah!??
(04.21.18)
3. A voice of reason. Yemini is not Smolani today.
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (04.21.18)
4. Of course judges are not God
Bertram ,   London, UK.   (04.21.18)
Whoever said they were? This sounds like an Aunt Sally - setting up someone or something in order to knock it down. An independent judiciary is indispensable for the operation of a democracy. Yes, a parliament makes the laws and the government executes them. The judiciary exists to check that the laws are being executed fairly and reasonably, and in accordance with the intentions of the lawmakers.Can't see what's wrong with that.. .
5. Likewise: Politicians are not Kings!
(04.22.18)
Mr. Yemini...please do take your sharp analytical and intellectual skills and write up an op-ed which proves the following: "If judges are not G-d, then Politicians are not Kings"
...I am asking you to write this because you know that I know that you know that there are many old time liberal (in the European sense of the word) right wingers who would NOT agree with what you have written here. BTW all of us old time liberal right wingers would however agree that you have the right to express yourself as you wish. And we have the right to respectfully disagree with you.
6. Leftist High Court judges are anything but godly
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.23.18)
The High Court can't be allowed to continue in its present form. In the first place, judges have no business making laws. M.K.s are elected to make laws. The ONLY legitimate role of judges is to interpret laws. Period. The High Court must be made subservient to the Knesset.

Secondly, the composition of the High Court must change to reflect the will of the vast patriotic majority of Israel and Israel's best interests. Leftist High Court judges are anything but godly. They should all be replaced by patriots.
7. Judges follow the Law
Tova ,   Canada   (04.24.18)
That all they do. Judges are chosen for their ethics or moral views. Whether it is Israel. Canada United States or Europe. No country has a supreme court that considers the human conditions.

Not even the United Nations has an ethical or moral stand on human rights.
Judges follow the court of Law.

It is the political leader of any country and his congress that will ultimately go against or for what judgement is made.

Judges are humans who study law. which usually has very little to do human rights anywhere in the world.

8. Olmert, Deri and other are god?
Avi L.   (04.24.18)
They are good at getting voted nothing else

Politicians are trying destroy the judiciary, they already tried some time ago with a delegitimation campaign, now with Bibi and (alleged) accomplices seeing the gate of the jail they try again in order to rule unrestricted and without check nor balance of power.

A coup simply said
9. Sometimes the " 'right' is right".
Brad   (04.24.18)
Looks as though Yemini has redefined "99%" to mean "sometimes".
Back to article