News
Experts say no new information in Netanyahu's Iran presentation
Roy Rubinstein, Itamar Eichner
Published: 01.05.18, 10:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. 'smoking gun' - from the start it was a breach.
ron ,   Melborne   (05.01.18)
'smoking gun' is not easy to come by as we know from the Syrian Nuclear program which was found by luck and from the Libyan which no one knew about. When the agreement was reached there was a certification that was required and which was provided by the independent body that Iran had no military nuclear operations. It is now clear they got it wrong. Since they got it wrong from the very start 1. The agreement was entered into under false information, 2. the independent body failed right from the start so why would you expect it get it right now. Basically, the agreement was entered to by the parties under false information and it was material information. Netanyahu showed that to be the case. It is not easy to get the information as one can imagine. Since the Iranians were in breach from day one, since the independent monitor has failed from day one since the agreement was entered under false assertions from day one - what else is required. Do you expect a video feed from the sites in realtime ?
2. TOPPLE THE RABID MULLAHS NOW !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (05.01.18)
3. I know Netanyahu's mindset very well, he has no credibility
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (05.01.18)
4. Yes, Netanyahu didn't make the right point
Dan ,   Cincinnati usa   (05.01.18)
Netanyahu failed in his presentation because he didn't connect the dots. What we hear as criticism is: so what? iran didn't tell the IAEA they had a program. But everybody knew they had a program and that why this agreement is so valuable. Silly nuttyyahoo, you just proved our point!

WRONG.

WHY did the JCPOA ask for a full accounting of past activities? So that all possible means of restarting a nuclear program could be accounted for and nullified.

WHY did Iran not provide the full accounting? Specifically so they could restart the program as soon as they wanted.

AND this is why the sunset clause is so dangerous. It allows Iran to work on non enrichment activities (specifically, long range missile delivery of nuclear weapons), achieve sanctions relief and economic benefits, and then, using the materials that they failed to declare at the outset of the JCPOA, restart enrichment.
5. Lied before and not pinalised......
The Archives ,   Kuala Lumpur   (05.01.18)
Fruit has grown.... lies will grow again. The question is why dictate an agreement with red lines that shall be broken again? How do you erect harsh retribution together with strict observers in a short period of time a treaty is broken to arrest and sieze the infringement before evidence is removed? How do you impose a US base in Iran with a military license to defend the treaty from being infringed within a short period of time?
6. Maybe these "experts" will take Salehi seriously
Jake   (05.01.18)
if they are unwilling to take Netanyahu seriously.
Salehi, the head of the Iranian Atomic Agency, has said recently that it would take just one week for Iran to enrich enough uranium to produce a nuclear bomb.
He also said in the last couple of days that Iran is now in a position to enrich uranium to higher levels than before the nuclear deal.
If true, the nuclear deal has not only failed to stop Iran's nuclear program, it has enabled Iran to get closer to realizing its ambitions of producing a nuclear weapon.
In other words, ignore Netanyahu's warnings at your own peril.
7. The Usual Idiots (former this'nthat) are again trying to be-
(05.01.18)
little "Bibi".
What a pathetic, treacherous bunch!
8. Dead giveaway: word "experts" in the headline! Idiots, yes.
(05.01.18)
9. Simple way to prove Bibi is lying: tomorrow, take a TV crew
(05.01.18)
to the address and show the whole world (on live TV) that you're producing feta cheese there, not A-bomb!
Not doable?
Oh well, then Bibi must be telling the truth....
10. TBer fools rush in 2 support salesman/politician!
Loknah ,   Israel   (05.01.18)
All y'all are wrong. This information shouldn't have been presented as a prime time reality TV segment by the national quiz master.
It should have been shared privately with the appropriate people in Langley, Virginia USA.
11. Yep, #7 it's these "former this & that" who keep you safe!
(05.01.18)
Really it's truly ignorant to attack the security services of the State of Israel.
After all the security services of the State of Israel keep all of us safe and sound.
12. Netanyahu: a 1st class fool should be prosecuted for treason
Rafi ,   US   (05.01.18)
Israeli security officials Shimron and Arad are 100% CORRECT.

This is a sad moment for the State of Israel... once again courtesy of that aluminum siding/ furniture salesman Bibi Netanyahu.
13. Fact is we will not know cos Iran can ban IAEA from anywhere
(05.01.18)
All these officials are totally political. Sounds like idiots who say no guns leads to less gun crime. Obviously.

Same here the Iranian have dozens of facilities including those where they build their nuclear program where they forbid the IAEA from entering.

There is no way to verify anything in the agreement so anyone claiming there is no evidence is basically standing with the EVIL Iran when its clear they tried to create nukes and their intentions are regional and than global domination based on Shiite religious insanity. Khumeini wrote a book on how he will destroy Israel and take over the world bringing in the 12th Imam their messiah.
14. Same officials could have defeated Iran under their tenor
(05.01.18)
Back to article