News
Participants quit Birthright trip to go on Breaking the Silence tour
Itamar Eichner
Published: 29.06.18, 15:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
47 Talkbacks for this article
1. We salute honest &conscientious Jews who R against apartheid
Khalid Amayreh ,   Occupied Jerusalem   (06.29.18)
2. Of course they don"t know t-truth, willing to meet them
Khalid Amayreh ,   Occupied Jerusalem   (06.29.18)
3. Phoney and Dishonest
Ed ,   USA   (06.29.18)
Clearly planned from the start. These girls are not able to learn. Bigotry posimg as openmindedness.
4. mr
balas ,   jerusalem   (06.29.18)
Many Libturds fall for believing the lie of an occupation instead of the fact of liberation. Jordan was ceded to the Arabs in 1922 after San Remo designated the Jewish Home in their ancestral lands
5. I do not envy them their departure from BGA
(06.29.18)
If the El Al security finds that they left their group on Birthright, those girls will be in for a treat...
6. Pity the parents of such weak minded youngsters...
(06.29.18)
7. Nothing to do with ethics or morality.They think it's cool.
Sam ,   Montreal   (06.29.18)
They probably don't know the difference between Israel and Nigeria. They just think it is cool to show they are anti-Israel or anti-Jewish. Just obnoxious Jews.
8. Saw video the Guide was great sang "Israel never surrenders"
AlwazMinorityOfKooks ,   Jerusalem Israel   (06.29.18)
One of the girls said she "has struggled with her Jewish identity" struggle
no more bye bye..The Israeli Birthright Guide as they were signing
their release of responsibility papers began to sing softly " The People
of Israel will never give up " this seemed to infuriate them and asked
him angrily "What are you singing ?" to which he replied "you know the
world is very very small we will meet again one day I feel sure in maybe
20 or more years and it will be interesting to hear what you have to
say then" Sounds like they were already involved with anti Israel groups
in the States . Today in Jerusalem there were hundreds of happy
Birthright kids enjoying themselves and among them strolling in the
parks and streets were many Palestinian Arab families
out for the
day mingling with the Israeli Jews smiling and their children seemed
to be having as much fun alongside the Birthright kids and the Birthright
kids saw all this too it seems the 5 girls wear blinders self imposed
I wonder if they know or care that the Left wing organizations is
foreign European funded ?!!
9. The real Apartheid is to be found among the Arabs
RealityCheck ,   Jerusalem Israel   (06.29.18)
You will find NO Jews in Arab villages and NO Jews are to
be allowed in any possible Palestinian State. Jews in Jerusalem
that cross the street from their homes like in Armon Hanazeev
know they will be murdered in the Jew Free neighborhood
just across the street . While Arab families feel free to
bring their children into the heart of Armon Hanzaeev to
the playground there and use the many other services
there while they live in Jew Free Apartheid Jabal Mukaber
and Tzur Bahir for just two out of hundreds of examples
of Arab Palestinian racist exclusion of Jews. Interesting to
follow up on the girls and see just how rabid Anti Israel
and Anti Semites they become its a well known pattern
10. naive, left-indoctrinated girls
(06.29.18)
send the to live in Gaza, Iran, or any other of the places they glorify in their dream, and let them learn the lesson on their own skin and expense.
11. THESE FIVE YOUNG WOMEN NEED TO GROW UP .
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (06.29.18)
12. Occupation!
Ariel Duro ,   NY   (06.29.18)
Occupation? It must end!
Arabs run from Jewish Land!
13. Are we sure they were not planted in advance
Alan ,   SA   (06.29.18)
14. Question
paulD ,   Jerusalem   (06.29.18)
Are these the same geniuses that said Kaddish for the Hamas terrorists that tried to massacre Jews? Or, are they just buddies of Waters, who think their purpose in life is to feed the anti-semites hungry for another Holocaust. Imagine going through all that trouble just to expose your mental contamination to the only people on earth that don't want to fry you in an oven.
15. Applauding their Courage, Integrity, Judaism.
anonymous   (06.29.18)
IfNotNow, Breaking the Silence, Miko Peled, author of the General's Son, Jewish Voice for Peace, they speak the truth.

The occupation is harming the collective Soul of Judaism, the Jewish people deserve more than the policies of um, nuance, and Hasbara of the Jewish state, of political Zionism, that has kept them in the dark and lied to.
16. Ms
Hila.solomon ,   Tel.aviv   (06.29.18)
So.obvious this was planned. Free trip infiltrate and breakdown birthrights positive impact. Scripted.timed and the opening compact.of.importance of shabbat to.enable this movement to appear.part.of.mainstream
Their.organisation is riding on birthright s buck
17. Right Wing Racism
(06.29.18)
18. Liberal Intellectual Jews
Tova   (06.30.18)
The liberals think Israel should just give up everything without realizing Hamas can't wait to murder them.

Birthright should sent the bill to their parents. No free trips for deserters.

These foolish young people need an education in Jewish History.

This is a lesson for Birthright sponsors - have each family sign a waiver
that Israel is not responsible for their children if they choose to leave
the group.

19. Drop them in Gaza
Empress Trudy   (06.30.18)
And drive off. It’s a win win
20. curious
David   (06.30.18)
Curious why this problem of buying into anti-Israel propaganda seems to afflict more young women than young men. In any case, anyone who does this should be required to pay the cost of their fare. Birthright Israel is a gift, not an entitlement. Israeli taxpayers and Jewish philanthropists pay for it in order to promote an exposure to Zionism. No one who goes on this trip is unaware of this fact, and they shouldn't act otherwise. If they want to take a trip to "Palestine," they should do so on their own dime.
21. These were implants form the get go. Who said Jews are free
(06.30.18)
from our share of Quislings, idiots, morons and other forms of Leftist pathogen?
22. LOOK ON THE BRIGHT SIDE FOLKS:
PHIL O' SOPHER ,   SAFED GENIUS   (06.30.18)
At least these fragrant ( but angry ) young ladies did not blame Trump !!
23. CONFUCIUS SAYS :
CONFUCIUS ,   SAFED CHINA   (06.30.18)
Do not bite the hand which pays you to have a FREE 10-day-tour .....
24. FIVE GO DOWN TO THE SEA.
E.NID BLYTON ,   SAFED GENIUS   (06.30.18)
25. TAKE FIVE.
DAVE BREWBECK ,   SAFED SARCASM   (06.30.18)
26. GIMME FIVE....OR MAYBE NOT !!
DA RAP ARTISTE ,   SAFED RAP HOUSE   (06.30.18)
27. THANKS..BUT NO THANKS
HARVEY WANKSTAIN ,   SAFED HONESTY   (06.30.18)
28. TONGUE-TWISTER
DA RAP ARTISTE ,   SAFED RAP HOUSE   (06.30.18)
Isaacharoff aint no sucker it sucks to be Isaacharoff.
29. USEFUL IDIOTS FOR BDS
THEODORE HURTSEL ,   SAFED HONESTY   (06.30.18)
30. ARMCHAIR CRITICS.
CAPTAIN OBVIOUS ,   SAFED OBVIOUS   (06.30.18)
Next talkbacks
Back to article