Opinion
Thank you for arresting the rabbi
Yizhar Hess
Published: 25.07.18, 14:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
20 Talkbacks for this article
1. The Orthodox say a circle has 189 corners, Conservative:197!
(07.25.18)
2. Conservative is already busy extinguishing itself
Ben ,   NYC   (07.25.18)
In the USA, the size and influence of the Conservative movement are declining at an alarming rate. The movement does not need the government of Israel or the Rabbanut to "declare a war of extermination on non-Orthodox Judaism." Conservative is already extinguishing itself through assimilation and apathy. I am surprised that anyone would try to repeat in Israel this failed Amercan experiment in lite Judaism.
3. The Masortis deserve support. Where do I send contribution?
Michael ,   California, USA   (07.25.18)
4. religion in Israel
Maurice Rosenfeld ,   Antwerp   (07.25.18)
Israel is a theocracy, this is undeniable. The rabbinate has powers that are impossible to break.These powers were given to the Rabbinate by the Rabbinate itself. This is the definition of a theocracy.
Whether Orthodox, Reform, Conservative or whatever, unless there is a separation of chuch and state in Israel the situation will not change.
5. does any1 lawfully now why these 2 cant get married?
(07.25.18)
yes the rabbi is an imposter, he has never been to prison for bribery or fraud,
we need a shasrab now,glory be ,under his pie.
6. Crook "rabbit" pocketed money
Uri ,   NY   (07.25.18)
Never paid taxes. Thief! Jail scum! "...your rabbit???" LOL!
7. Marriage ordained by a Rabbi
Tova   (07.26.18)
is not determined whether that Rabbi is ultra orthodox, modern orthodox, hasidic, conversative or whatever they call themselves. None of these terms are in accordance with the Torah, GOD did not tell the people of Israel to choose whatever denomination they want in order to be Jewish,

All these terms are created by people who choose for themselves how Jewish they think are. The Ultra Orthodox are more Jewish nor do they know the Torah more or better than regular Jews who study Torah. GOD does measure a person by "how Jewish they are" For GOD sees our hearts and know our minds. As written: David was a man who was after GOD's own heart. This tells us David loved GOD, even though David was not perfect.

So when it comes to marriage, The Rabbi job is to marry the Jewish couple under the Chupah. Not to judge how Jewish they are. If the Ultra Orthodox
continues to deny Jewish couples from being what they consider legal marriage. Then the Ultra Orthodox is breaking the Law of Marriage.
8. So tragically funny: these two(three,four?) squabbling over
(07.27.18)
who's God exists "more" :-))
Of course in reality it's pure political power play....just like any old secular rascals!
9. The Way in Which This was Done was a HUGE SIN in HALACHA!
Mordechai ,   San Francisco, USA   (07.27.18)
Dr Hess is right. I attend an orthodox shul and was married by an orthodox rabbi. I am not orthodox. To treat a Rabbi this way is inexcusable. What was done here was nothing more than a PR-stunt to make the ultra orthodox feel good. Israel had a HUGE PROBLEM with diaspora Jewry and this mean spirited waking up of a rabbi at 5:30AM shows that who is minding the insane asylum called Israel when the police, the arm of justice can impose on a person not threatening to hurt anyone like this. As president Rivlin states: the way in which this was done was way beyond the pale of decency. I live in San Francisco. I grew up in a frum community. I know of VERY FEW people including rabbis who would approve of the way this was done. Investigate? Sure! But to humiliate a rabbi this way. SICK!!! Go ask an Chabad rabbi if you think I am wrong.
10. Leave him alone movement dying natural death
PutTheLightsOut ,   Jerusalem   (07.28.18)
11. “Conservative Reform =Meretz at pseudo Prayer
MickeyMouseJudaism ,   Jerusalem   (08.05.18)
12. dirty facts about reform (in the country I live)
Ex Oleh Chadash ,   BR   (08.07.18)
You have to pay 1000 for a seat in the synagogue during Yom Kipur.
It's not a synagogue, it is a teather.

I was for Reform when I was young, I remember those people calling to my home to ask me for money all the time. Bunch of crooks.

My ancestors in poland were neither Reform, nor Orthodox, nor Conservative, they were pure genuine authentic Jews - as simple as that.

Something goes wrong after WWII.
Back to article