News
180 Israeli writers ask Netanyahu to nix Nationality Law
Amir Alon
Published: 28.07.18, 21:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
34 Talkbacks for this article
1. Can these men start a political party. They will be Voted in
Eden   (07.28.18)
The idea of democracy is to represent the people in the Knesset.

Its no longer enough to criticize. Blame. These men are educated and elderly. They can easily enter politics to represent the ideas the6 put forward.
2. FORGET ABOUT IT.
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (07.28.18)
For 2000 long ,miserable hard years jews were second class citizens in every place so there is no need for jews to be second class citizens in their homeland in 2018.
3. academics & artists are always the most politically correct
zionist forever   (07.28.18)
Its to be expected that people like this want the nationality law revoked and surrogacy for gays considering these are the kind of people who would vote Meretz.
Telling this lot to get lost won't cost Netanyahu any votes.
4. israel must be state and be the land of the jews and druse
orly   (07.28.18)
druse have fought like jews for the land. israel is the land of the jews and associate fellow druse whose blood has earned them a place.israe must not concede this to israeli writers who want an equal land for all without regard to historic right. this will lead to an arab state so forget it. stick to the nation state of the jews and fellow druse and not one inch more.
5. These are the exact Useful Idiots that throughout the ages
(07.28.18)
have caused the greatest calamities for the "common simpletons"...!
6. The letter isself is racist
Gene   (07.29.18)
It would be very problematic to accuse Israeli elite in racism but the latter is racist: "Those two laws exclude Christian and Muslim Arabs (including Bedouin), Druze and Circassians..." What about atheists, Russians, Buddhists, Armenians and other minorities? (BTW, there are more Russians in Israel than Druze and they also serve in IDF) By excluding these people from the groups that might be hurt by the law the authors of the letter showed their bias toward certain minorities.
7. THESE 180 WRITERS ARE RIGHT
CAPTAIN SARCASTIC ,   SAFED CYNIC HOUSE   (07.28.18)
The nationality Law must be amended ,and replaced with a law which states that jews must be second class citizens and discriminated against as much as possible.
8. countries and religion
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (07.28.18)
Spain proudly describes itself as a christian country, Italy and Poland describe themselves as proud catholic countries,Ireland proudly calls itself Christian, Saudi Arabia ,Egypt ,Morocco ,Turkey and others proudly call themselve islamic, only jews feel the need to be embarrassed to call tiny Israel JEWISH .
9. IF IT AINT BROKE
ALBERTO EINSTEIN ,   SAFED GENIUS   (07.28.18)
Don't fix it ,so just leave the law alone !
10. THE ISSUE
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (07.28.18)
Why should any man or woman have an issue with Israel being the Jewish state ,unless of course he or she is an antisemite ??
11. They're simply too "intellectual" to understand own idiocy:
(07.29.18)
old as this world.....
12. Accomplishment?
BAB   (07.29.18)
Hope Dichter is happy. What exactly did he accomplish?
More votes in the Likud primaries?
13. 180 WRITERS
STEVE ,   JERUSALEM   (07.29.18)
The Israeli media call these guys: "Anshei Ru'ach" which literally means: "Men of Wind". The problem with these shmucks is "The Wind" is coming from below.
14. WHO cares about 180 anti-Zionists...?!
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (07.29.18)
THE PESTILLIANS OF COURSE !!!!!!
15. These people a rosey but unrealistic image of Israel
Shela Ramon ,   Tel Aviv   (07.29.18)
16. The "intelligentia" is rearing it's ugly head again.
tiki ,   belgium   (07.29.18)
The best thing Israel could have done for Israel is finally pass this long overdue law.
17. This is what gives "intellect" a bad name!
(07.29.18)
18. This must be good for Israel
Bar Star ,   JerusLEM   (07.29.18)
if they are against. Many of them were in favor of Oslo and Disengagement.
19. Hold a LGBT march in an Arab town
mordechai   (07.29.18)
Waiting for the left to hold a LGBT march in an Arab town. How come they never do that
20. These people encourage ethnic cleansing of jews from judea
Daniel ,   TA - IL   (07.29.18)
How the racist face of the left shows itself again. The same people who encourage ethic cleansing of jews from judea and samaria and particpated in ethnic cleasing of jews from gaza now show a double standard for something that is not really racist.
Please go to your beloved muslim countries before you crate a muslim racist or racist socilaist state in Israel!
21. so what if they are writers, poets and other literati
C   (07.29.18)
they have no clear understanding of the nationality law.
the sole purpose of the law is to make it clear that israel is the national
homeland of the jewish people.
the law does not prevent other religions from practicing their religion
freely. indeed, non-jews in israel have more rights than arabs would
give to the jews.
muslims do not participate in the national life of israel. they refuse to
join the army and defend the state against enemies of israel.
the arab population of israel has more sympathy with other arabs
in gaza and the west bank territories.
those who signed this letter are post-zionists who in fact do not
believe that israel is a jewish state.
22. Leftist Jews who specialize in groveling to non-Jews
Sam ,   Montreal   (07.29.18)
If Jews are in need of butt lickers they can find them among the Left.
23. Danger ! Post Zionists !!!
180Zeros ,   Jerusalem   (07.29.18)
24. Their collective political IQ: equally 180!
(07.29.18)
25. Leftists make ideal reverse barometers
Chaim ,   Israel   (07.29.18)
These leftist writers may or may not know how to write. But they are experts groveling before Israel's foes. Leftists make ideal reverse barometers. They are wrong about every major issue from Oslo to Disengagement to the Golan to Arafat to...everything.
26. most of the comments to the letter of writers,etc shows
tomer ,   jerusalem   (07.29.18)
exactly the dangerous drifting in israels political "thinking". israel becomes
racist,excluding,inwards directed, isolating and dehumanizing.

Its a complete unnecessary law and completely un-jewish.A disgrace.
27. Israel the Jewish state
Stan ,   Israel   (07.30.18)
I came to live in Israel the Jewish state 57 years ago. It was a Jewish state then and it's a Jewish state now and it will remain a Jewish state as long as there is a Jewish majority.
This law has nothing to do with the Jewish state, it's all about politics and testosterone. The right-wing politicians behaving like a bunch of male turkeys strutting around and and showing their masculinity.
28. Like the proverbial scorpion: they cannot help themselves!
(07.30.18)
Next talkbacks
Back to article