Opinion
Words can kill
Carmi Gillon
Published: 26.08.18, 00:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
53 Talkbacks for this article
1. Carmi Gilon lies about Im Tirtzu are akin to Nazi lies
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (08.26.18)
2. NIF democratic, Zionist? Gilon lives on another planet!
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (08.26.18)
3. junior
ha ,   ha   (08.26.18)
If the above article is a foreign entity paid political advertisement it should clearly say so in accordance with the new law and reveal its sources. Like paid by Hum-ass 30 euro.
4. Democracy has spoken u r the fascists
(08.26.18)
Unable to accept an opposing opinion which the majority support.

Comparing the rightwing to antisemites without a hyphen. You cant even spell a word which is used by these antisemites.

Than the usual left wing comments comparing to terrorists and fascists with no real examples.

Jew haters read these articles and it creates more antisemitism.

Those who oppose the nation state law oppose Israel and the mandate for Palestine. Look in the mirror the fascist orgs are those on the left funded by the EU. Remember the EU also funds Jewish land theft, Nazi education and terrorist salaries. Wonder who is really on the wrong side.
5. What about freedom of speech?
Gene   (08.26.18)
It is funny to hear such suggestion from the fighter for civil liberties. Are those liberties not for every citizen? Then how about members of the Joint List who openly incite against the state of Israel? Should be they banned too?
6. Amir didn't do it and everyone knows that
dave ,   tzfat/phila   (08.26.18)



Yigal Amir claimed from the outset that he decided to assassinate Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin as a representative of his community, and against the background of rabbinical rulings and provocative chants of "banish Rabin with blood and fire" by right-wing leaders.
7. Never has a true red fascist spoken more hateful words!
(08.26.18)
8. This anti-Zionist, anti Jewish, self-hater belongs in the
(08.26.18)
annals of infamy in the Jewish nation's history.
What a piece of clueless Judaeo-Quisling!
9. Garbage unworthy of Israeli citizenship! Talking about Gilon
(08.26.18)
10. Peddle your BS in Al Jezeera, Gilon!
(08.26.18)
11. C.G ,friend of supporters of terror like Herbert Pundik Abu
ab   (08.26.18)
Ron Pundak shouldn' be pontificating.
Yes,words can kill,like words penned by this Herber Pundik in Danish daily "Politiken" ,"Bomber who saved Peace" about the creature who murdered 19 Israeli teenage girls in front of "Dolphinarium" in RA.
Same Pundik who together with PFLP was organizing anti-Israel demos in front of the Israeli Embassy in Copenhagen where Carmi Gillon was Ambassador-and was dined and wined as Ambassador's guest.
Go figure..

12. Possible misprint?
P   (08.26.18)
In the first paragraph it says " I received a nice thank-you note from them to which I responded that it should be forwarded to the Im Tirtzu movement." the rest of the article is against the Im Tirtzu movement. Am I missing something?
13. Forgetting all the terror perpetrated against Israel & Jews
C   (08.26.18)
even today, as we write, hamas is sending thousands to the border on
gaza to invade israel.

are the intifadas forgotten?! thousands of israelis murdered.

nearly thirty thousands were murdered by invading arabs since
war of independence.
14. New Israel Fund is a far left American organisation
C   (08.26.18)
the new israel fund works for far left foreigners who care only about
enemies of israel.
they meddle into the internal affairs of the jewish state without any
accountability for their actions.
no other country would accept that foreigners meddle into their
internal affairs.
the motivation of the new israel fund is not classical zionism,
but far left socialism.
15. carmi gillon
morris   (08.26.18)
carmi is full of it. j street and protestors against west bank settlment are in bed with palestinians. they harass israelis at every turn.
16. ynet stoops down to pro-Gilon censorship,not letting facts
ab   (08.26.18)
in talkbacks pointing to Gilon friendship with supporters of terror like Herbert Pundik ,Abu Ron Pundak to be published.
My talkback describing Pundik who had penned "Bomber who saved Peace"(murder of 19 Israeli girls in Dopolphinarium in TA) bomber being "saviour of Peace",being guest at Israeli Embassy in Copenhagen,with Gilon as Ambassador to Denmark, is still "loading".
Likewise ,another talkback which sys "Speaking about Gilon.::" is empty,so nobody'd would know other uncomfy facts about Gilon.
Just wait to moment when Gilon&Co would assume power,Israel'd become another arab country.
17. Fact, that thrash like Gilon has risen so high up the ladder
(08.26.18)
in Israeli politics says everything about who ruled the waves here.....
18. Well said all of you commentators!
Stan ,   Israel   (08.26.18)
You just prove that Carmi Gillon is correct..

When this article appeared this morning, it was followed by the one about 3 Arabs almost being beaten to death on a Haifa beach.
The article before that told of how masked settlers from an illegal settlement stoned left wing activists.
Two examples showing how Im Tirtzu and other extremist NGOs are turning Israel into a fascist state.
19. democracy shmemocracy.
MR CYNIC ,   SAFED CYNIC HOUSE   (08.26.18)
20. NIF= Notorious:Infame:Fiendish
Alexander Scheiner ,   ZY, Israel   (08.27.18)
The NIF is a US NGO. The NIF is usingthe very same PR technique as the Falastinian do. The NIF is unrelated to the Jewish State Israel and unrelated to Judaism. The prime enemies of the NIF are Zionism and the liberal democratic values of Israel.

The NIF supports the Falastinian cause and is the prime promotor of the anti-Semitic BDS.

For more information about this evil NGO please read financingtheflames.org.
21. Separate from the minorities among us.
Brad ,   USA   (08.28.18)
More like separate us from the Muslim terrorists among us. You can tell that Gillon is full of hopps as he uses way to many words to say almost nothing, and doesn't get to the point.
22. Do not trust the evil NIF
Alexander Scheiner ,   ZY, Israel   (08.28.18)
NIF = Notorious:Infame:Fiendish

The NIF is an evil US-NGO, like similar organisations such as the KKK and Naziorganisations.

For well documented Information please read financingtheflames.com. In this book documents the support by organizations close to the Islamic and Falastinian Terror and Christian anti-Semitic churches.

The members of the NIF and ist supporters are generally self-hating Jews or even pathologic self-hating Jews.
23. Gilon should be refused a glass of water, even in a desert!
(08.29.18)
24. He knows he funds the enemy and compares us to fascists?
(08.29.18)
25. Carmi part of Rabin/Oslo conspiracy theories
(08.29.18)
26. Jewish community needs to work to get along better
barry ,   North Providence RI   (09.07.18)
Though not an Israeli, as an outsider I still find the hate expressed by this group Im Tirtzu appalling. My perspective from living and working in a community with very few Jewish people is that we are a very small community and need to try to get along even if we have some disagreements.
Next talkbacks
Back to article