News
Supreme Court allows entry to Hamas kin for medical care
Associated Press and Ynet
Published: 27.08.18, 19:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
17 Talkbacks for this article
1. Send them to Qatar or Iran
Avi L.   (08.27.18)
2. Yemini should write oped about Supreme Court terror enabler
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (08.27.18)
3. how come there is not a picture of the women?
jore ,   la   (08.27.18)
4. ISRAEL IS ONE OF THE MOST HUMAN COUNTRIES, IT CAN BE SAID
SJOERD VAN DER VELDE ,   HOORN HOLLAND   (08.27.18)
5. supreme court says treat the people who want to kill you
mark   (08.27.18)
public safety outweighs humanitarian considerations. most Gazans want to kill Israelis. the Israeli court is detached from reality period.
6. Shame on the court. hamas is holding ISRAELIS.
David ,   Hartford USA   (08.28.18)
Until the bodies and captives are returned, nobody from Gaza should be allowed to enter Israel. NOBODY.

The court says the women may enter. I say the hospital should make them comfortable BUT NO TREATMENT until the Israelis are returned.

Hamas (and all of Gaza) are laughing at the court.

"Hey Jews! We have some bodies of yours! And our incendiary kites have torched thousands of acres of your crops! And we still send have our snipers shooting at you! But you HAVE to let our sick women in! Na na na na naaaaa! Heck, we don't want any third-world Muslim hospital, we want the best! NOW HEAL OUR WOMEN WHILE WE PLAN OUR NEXT ATTACK ON YOU, YOU STUPID JEWS!!
7. stupid decision. destroyed anoth bargain chip to get POWa ba
(08.28.18)
8. Supreme court destroying Israel
Lucifer69   (08.28.18)
9. irrational and illegal decision
C   (08.28.18)
the hcj does not have jurisdiction over national security matters, nor over
foreign policy matters.
gaza is an enemy territory.
the women in question are enemy aliens.
the question whether they personally pose a threat to israel is irrelevant.

furthermore, the women have the possibility to go for treatment to numerous
other countries.

countries have the right to prohibit entry into their territory to enemy
aliens. such decisions are based on sovereign rights.
such decisions are not based on tender hearts.
such decisions are based on cold calculation of national security.

some might say that this decision is not such a big deal--but it is.
it gives hamas terrorists that have sworn to annihilate the jewish
state additional ammunition in their propaganda war.



10. If even one woman dies they will blame Israel
DSM ,   USA   (08.28.18)
It is obvious Israel's Supreme Court is courting world opinion rather than doing what is best for Israel. I doubt if these judges realize Israel is at war, even if it is not a declared war. The one true fact is that Israel will never be thought of in a positive light by human rights organizations nor most of the world because it is a Jewish state.
11. Medical treatment for Hamas
Gidon ,   Tel Aviv   (08.28.18)
Unbelivable !! ...and will they pay?? or will the Israeli tax payer have to cover the huge expence? ...has Israel lost its mind?
12. these justices should not imagine that they are superior
C   (08.28.18)
their decision is purely political.

they have no authority over gaza.
they cannot render judgments over hamas.
the residents of gaza are subject to sharia law as imposed by hamas.
13. With court like that there's no need for elections at all!
(08.28.18)
14. Is being kin to a Hamas official a criminal charge?
Shela Ramon ,   Tel Aviv   (08.28.18)
Is being a relative of a Jewish terrorist like Barouch Goldstein a charge? Does Israel have a Nazi-like Justice system?
15. Time to make it a law not bargaining chip
(08.28.18)
Back to article