Opinion
Reimagining Gaza while recognizing reality
Brigadier General (Res.) Shmuel Tzuker
Published: 27.08.18, 23:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
13 Talkbacks for this article
1. After this article by a former IDF Division Commander......
DSM ,   USA   (08.28.18)
it is obvious why the IDF is in a state of inertia when dealing with Gaza. The IDF and politicians should have one goal in mind and that is to protect the State of Israel and it's citizens. Allowing injured Arabs from Gaza to come to Israel for humanitarian reasons such as medical attention is noble, but to worry about squalid conditions in Gaza is idiotic. No matter what Israel does for these people their feeling have always been and will remain to hate and kill Jews.
2. Mark Sherry can make us stronger
DSM ,   USA   (08.28.18)
We need the Sherries of the world to keep us on guard as to what so many people think of Jews and Israel. It will serve as a reminder and make us stronger.
3. What is wrong with the people leading our army?!
(08.28.18)
4. if humanity allocated half
(08.28.18)
the military budget for humanitarian reasons we would all be millionaires .thanks to religion for keeping us there, g-d help us,
5. As long as the desire to do terrorism remains
Riva ,   Betar Ilit   (08.28.18)
deeply in their core, then no one can help them. While most of us in Israel would like nothing more than to have peace with all the Arabs, it is they who have to give up what they perceive as a religious requirement to literally murder Jews, not just take over our country. However, because as a people they are already gulity of the murder of thousands of innocent people, mostly Jews, as well as injured countless more and caused permanent damage to so many, a little "accounting" has to be done. It is personally hard for me to forgive them.
6. Gazans are living right next to an advanced start up nation
Alan ,   SA   (08.28.18)
but are kept in filth and overflowing sewerage by their ELECTED HAMAS leaders WHO THEY THEMSELVES ELECT.... I agree to a very large extent to what Gen Tzuker writes-but what can Israel do to stop the spoilers ie Hamas KEEPING Gaza in a morass (literaly and figuratively). We are in a no win situation as we sit here today. BTW if Judea and Samaria are handed over to Abbas Company ,the same will result there ie Hamas will take over in no time and do just like in Gaza,but on steroids!! Pres Trump and his M E team have right ideas but Pals make fun out of "the deal of the century"-WHICH IT REALLY IS....USA and EU in concert with Israel could fix Gaza quickly but vested EU interests will sabotage every step of the way .... in the same way EU is trying to help Iran become IN TIME a nuclear power and Middle East big power (just to get their paws on Obamas $$$$ he so kindly released to Iran before he left office.)So just keep Israel growing right next door to them and keep mowing the lawn and weeding
7. By "Sinai" th General means Negev,ceding parts of it to pals
ab   (08.28.18)
8. The Gazans are sheep following the leaders.
Sam ,   Montreal   (08.28.18)
The Hamas leaders are saying the number one priority is destroying Israel. Hamas gives lip service to the economy but a poor economy is something else to blame on Israel and rally the fighters. Lieberman wanted to talk directly to the people too but Palestinians hateful of Israel are more likely to listen to their own leaders.
9. Israel should only help "Palestinians" leave forever
Chaim ,   Israel   (08.28.18)
This article is another perverse leftist attempt to justify the obscene misuse of Israeli taxes to support our mortal "Palestinian" foes. This must be firmly rejected by every rational Israeli. The ONLY justifiable and sane form of Israeli assistance to "Palestinians" is to help them leave our land forever. Period.

We also need to replace leftists with patriots, at all levels in major Israeli institutions. These leftists are always brewing dumb, destructive ideas and Israeli citizens often pay with their lives and wellbeing.
10. I'd like to dissect "minds" of lemmings like this Brigadier!
(08.28.18)
11. netanyahu scared stiff
marv   (08.28.18)
bibi ignores Putin's deals with iran and hezbollah because he is scared stiff. he is also scared stiff of any ground war. he just lacks steel to go at it.

his comment about peace down the road via Arab neighbors is naive to the extreme. such neighbors, unreliable in the extreme hate Israel deep down and cannot be counted on period.

bibi had limited experience in business and it shows. he cannot read putin or arab neigbours. a brilliant academic, he has almost no street smarts, he is a nerd without any security skills. that much is obvious. his resume is worthless in the face of security threats.

what leader accepts on a routine basis incendiary attacks on Israeli land and forests?? Bibi lacks guts that is so obvious.
12. "When you all stop using my tax money to wage war on
A ,   OutThere   (08.28.18)
civilians", yet Porky has not an oink when "HIS" tax money is paid to finance:tribal disputes in Afghanistan = $US5 billion...more than Israel
$US1.3 billion to the military dictatorship in Egypt
$US364,200,000 to the phony Hashemite Kingdom of "palestine"/ Jordan
Even Bashar the Butcher gets a cut of Porky's tax money...$US541,500,000 in 2017. *OINK*
13. Dead Israelis while our leader live in fantasyland
(08.29.18)
Back to article