News  Magazine
Telegram exposes Mossad chief's warnings about Yom Kippur War
Yaron Drukman
Published: 18.09.18, 14:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
19 Talkbacks for this article
1. GOLDA WAS A DISASTER
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (09.18.18)
Golda Meir was told that there would be a big war but she refused to attack because she was worried about "what the nations would say about us ."
2. YOM KIPPUR WAR
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (09.18.18)
Israeli leadership was afraid of being labelled " the aggressor" if they attacked egyptian and syrian armies in 1973 ,so Golda preferred 3000 israeli dead rather than being criticized.
3. WARNINGS :
MR CYNIC ,   SAFED CYNIC HOUSE   (09.18.18)
What good are " warnings " if those in power fail to heed those warnings and act on them ?
4. failure to prepare
michael ,   new york   (09.18.18)
The issue is not why warnings were not passed.
The main issue was that the army was not ready to repel an attack regardless of warning. That is a military failure.
5. Interesting article ! At least Israel had one of the greates
TEHRANIPOROU   (09.19.18)
T assets of its history; general ariel Sharon who saved Israel as a soldier and as a politician. The sabra and chatila massacres is the only that can shatter his stature
6. ineptitude @ highest levels still very disturbing to read
Rafi ,   US   (09.18.18)
"Follow protocol" (in this case, let the guy sleep)... in return for 1,000's of IDF casualties, and a military/diplomatic setback for a generation. Definitely worth a good nite's sleep...

ARE YOU KIDDING ??
7. OF COURSE WE WARNED !
MO SAD ,   SAFED   (09.18.18)
8. AN UNCOMFORTABLE TRUTH :
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (09.18.18)
Israels' arab enemies ,Egypt and Syria ,in 1973 had scant respect for an old lady grandmother figure a.k.a Golda. Arabs respect strong macho men, that is their mentality or way of thinking. If ,instead of Golda Meir , in 1973 Israel had a strong and macho man as Prime Minister, suchas Netanyahu or Ariel Sharon, Egyptians and Syrians would have been much less eager or willing to go to war against Israel. Now ,this may indeed be unpalatable and not ' politically correct" but I am convinced this it true .
9. YIHYE BESEDER .
MOSHE CYNIC ,   SAFED CYNIC HOUSE   (09.18.18)
10. ARABS ARE UNCOMPLICATED
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (09.18.18)
Arabs respect and fear strong men ,they are unafraid of old grandmothers like Golda.
11. Revelations
steve ,   beer sheva   (09.18.18)
This has been known now for over 20 years. Clearly your reporters have only just left school!
12. A War needs two idiots
moishe   (09.25.18)
A War just needs two idiots,
one who is willing to sell his weapons
and the other who is eager to buy it.
periiod.
No Weapons to sell
No Weapons to buy.
That's simple, isn't it?
13. I can vouch it was not a surprise attack!
IDF Veteran ,   Raanana   (09.25.18)
I was a regular IDF soldier in an Anti-Aircraft unit along the southern side of the Suez Canal. Friday, the day before Yom Kippur... a full day before the war broke out, Egyptian Migs fighter jets violated Israeli airspace along the Suez Canal, probably on a recon mission. We were put our on high alert to man our battle stations, to be ready to shoot the planes down. At the last second we were ordered NOT to fire... The next morning on Yom Kippur(!!) we were ordered to carry gas masks. No explanation was given. That was about 5 hours before the "surprise attack"... The IDF was indeed in the picture about what was going to happen!...
14. ABOUT WARNINGS OR NOT...
FO   (09.27.18)
Declassifying this nonsense! The military and political levels got continuous and alarming information from commanders at the Suez Canal, but they were ordered to keep their mouth shut! Why? Because Israel was in a period of an electoral campaign. The slogan of the leading MAPAI party, with Golda Meyer as Prime Minister was: “YOU NEVER HAD IT SO GOOD!” So for Golda and her party it was inconceivable to order a general mobilization that could afterwards result in the loss of power (what indeed happened a few years later, because of this MEHDAL, a catastrophic blunder). Golda Meyer, Moshe Dayan and C° hoped that the Arabs will understand their “difficult situation” and postpone attacking Israel till after the elections, if at all… The rest is history with nearly 3000 death!
Back to article