News
Erdan defends actions against US student in detention
Associated Press
Published: 10.10.18, 22:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. trying 2 close the door after the fact!
(10.10.18)
She came to Israel for a Hebrew University Jerusalem Campus visit in December 2017.
So why didn't Erdan and his dream team catch her then?
Or is there another part to this story that someone isn't sharing?
2. What is the security issue
Discerning One   (10.11.18)
When everyone is a terrorist or security threat, no one is a terrorist or security threat.

Criticizing Israel's policies is not anti-Semitic.

You can't claim to be a democracy and behave this way.

The anti-BDS laws that were passed in the U.S. when no one was looking are slowly be challenged.

True democracies embrace free speech.



3. Haha, she wants to "come home..."
Hornet ,   D.F., MX   (10.11.18)
Go back to Florida baby, where you belong.
4. BDS
BDS   (10.11.18)
Allow her to stay and to attend Free University Of Gaza
5. If she can boycott Israel
shmulke ,   w. coast USA   (10.11.18)
...then certainly Israel can boycott her.
6. "Justice for palestine" representative
tiki ,   belgium   (10.11.18)
Has nothing to look for in Israel.

Put her on the first plane back from where she came so she can continue her 'justice for palestine' in Ford Lauderdale.

Enough already!
7. New York Times contradicts itself
C   (10.11.18)
obviously the new york times accepts the legitimacy of the bds movement.
the bds movement agitates for the boycott of israel, a sovereign state.
but the new york times criticises israel for detaining a boycott supporting
person who wants to enter the sovereign jewish state of israel.
as usual, the sole purpose of the new york times is to defame israel.
8. Keep her there. She's an enemy combatant.
Brad ,   USA   (10.11.18)
She's made her bed, now let her sleep in it. She wants to study human rights, huh. Well human rights includes the right of Israel to defend itself, and protect itself against the bloodthirsty rabid dogs that surround it.
9. Israelis are not even allowed in transit in almost all Arab
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (10.11.18)
hell holes
10. Sherry,1924 American-anglo agreemnt Palestine for the Jews..
(10.11.18)
11. Israeli leaders behave like Imperial powers...
(10.11.18)
You know imperial powers beling to illegitimate leaders who have usurped power from the people and now are quaking in their boots least the people realizr what these leaders have done.
Back to article