Opinion  Yoaz Hendel
Let the IDF win
Yoaz Hendel
Published: 12.11.18, 23:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
34 Talkbacks for this article
1. IT WILL TAKE
Larry Liss ,   retired from us army   (11.13.18)
100 DIRECT HITS ON TEL AVIV CAUSING THE BEAUTIFUL CITY SKYLINE
TO CRUMBLE FOR ISRAEL TO SHOVE EVERY INCH OF ARABS OUT OF GAZA AND ANNEX THE ENTIRE STRIP. 5,000 JEWISH DEATHS IT IS OBVIOUS THE GREAT BIBI DOES NOT CONSIDER SOUTH ISRAEL HAVING ANY VALUE
2. Netanyahu needs a backbone
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (11.13.18)
Too bad he will have to borrow one for somebody else
3. Likud fears ICC war crime prosecution from 2014 Gaza War
Steve Benassi ,   Plymouth, MN USAicc   (11.13.18)


wiki/International_Criminal_Court
4. 100% right. Let the IDF win again!
(11.13.18)
5. The IDF will never win.....
DSM ,   USA   (11.13.18)
with Bibi and his ilk in charge. He is a traitor to the sate of Israel and it's survival.
6. Hobson's Choice
(11.13.18)
After severe provocations, Israel invaded Gaza in 2014 and after 50 days of fierce fighting and hollow victories measured in terms of buildings destroyed, Palestinians killed and tunnels destroyed, again withdrew. Four years later we are again at square one. This time the IDF will have to remain in Gaza as an occupying power and tying down the IDF.
7. Prognosis: Bibi will try to sloganeer his way to "quiet".
Daniela Weintraub ,   Cartagena de Indias   (11.13.18)
His bet is that soon the worst of these shocking barrages of rockets will subside, and with time and patience, and his relentless divide-Liberman-and-conquer-Bennett, his maneuverings intended to surf the public outcry will lead to a limited aerial operation with some fancy name that will end up with his behind sitting on the PM's seat. That's his game. Soganeer, threaten, talk tough, do nothing resolute, and manipulate some more until you have quiet. Iran may not be that willing to grant him that from his proxies in Gaza.
8. Target Hamas leaders day and night, few days move in
(11.13.18)
I cant understand how Israel is unable to target all the rocket launchers?

New rule fire a missile that place is hit immediately.
All Hamas leaders targeted assassinations,

This is war against a terror group time to wipe them out once and for all.

Any civilian should move to the baren areas of Gaza of which there are many.

This should be the last time missiles are EVER fired from Gaza especially by the group controlling the area.
Any missile fired will receive an immediate bomb on the firing location.

Anyone touching the border will be shot these are paid terrorists invading a country and attacking not only its soldiers but also civilians,

The job of the gov and army is to protect its borders and citizens, if you are not willing or able to do your job let someone else try.,,

There is only one reason for not destroying Hamas and that is a viable plan to solve this problem. If bib doesn't have one time to destroy Hamas,

The longer we wait the more dead on all sides. This is common sense.
9. Well that was a wishy-washy nothing piece.
Shachar ,   Eilat   (11.13.18)
The army doesn't want to win and Bibi certainly doesn't want anyone harming his precious Hamas. Of course Hamas can be destroyed but only a left/centre gov't will actually do it. Virtually all Israel's wars and major operations were ordered by left leaning gov'ts. BG, Eshkol, Rabin, Peres, Olmert all launched major wars and operations.....what has Mr Security done except give Hamas millions of dollars and supply them with fuel and goods?
10. Try population transfer a la India/Pak...
Trump 2020 ,   Hillary's House   (11.13.18)
Either that or a Sun Tzu or Old Testament-style elimination of the enemy. In the liberal social order wars don't end, they just grind on forever, and ever, and ever, because that's what's humane. And that's preferable to the PR disaster that is a lot of dead people on the 24/7 TV/web/smart phone media circus. Russia ignores the PR issue because Russia doesn't care, and is big enough, and in bed with enough of the other countries that don't care, to give their finger to the West. Brussels, Paris, and Comedy Central be damned. May I suggest we take a page from Russia?
11. Politics is War, War is Politics...
yair ,   New York   (11.13.18)
Politics are part and parcel of war. The Left is trying to defeat you with politics instead of combat, and you must tread carefully.
12. Though bagel to swallow: RIGHTIST govt. on the verge of
(11.13.18)
"dictatorship" (so the Leftists claim), doing absolutely NOTHING for months, while our bitter& mortal enemy burns our crops, terrorizes civilian population, maims and kills at will!
You can spin this endlessly, but the fact (that we all know) remains: Netanyahu has to go ASAP.
13. Win, how?
Peter Paul ,   Lisbon - portugal   (11.13.18)
The only victory possible through force was the overthrow of hamas. Once that was done the only possibility was to give power to palestinian authority, fatah. But would they acept it? Let us imagine they did not. Israel would be handcuffed to gaza with constant attacks against idf. And the according loss of life in both sides. Now let us imagine fatah would agree to rule gaza. Israell would not be better off. Israel would face a reinvigorated palestinian authority rulling west bank and gaza and demanding the isolation of israel untill its demands are met. Hardly a good outcome for israel. In short. Israeli jews got too arrogant. They got used to believe brute force can achieve anything and fail to grasp that a divided palestinian entity was the best outcome possible for israel. Instead of blockading gaza israel should help it to thrive further isolating abbas. But the arrogant israely public opinion fails to see this evidence
14. What about G-d's way
Jake ,   Petach Tikva   (11.13.18)
G-d swore this land to the Jewish people. G-d is inciting the Gazan population against Israel . Israel must reconquer Gaza and resettle Jews there and clear out the land of all Gazans.If not, the conflict will continue with all that entails.
15. It is said
cfspirit ,   fr   (11.13.18)
that the battle in WB not ended since the second intifada.
16. Netanyahu can't wean himself off politicking.
Camilo ,   Caibarién   (11.13.18)
Seven hours of a Bibi-procastinated, security cabinet meeting. It seems that the men either have differng opinions, or that the complexity of assuming in-media-res a plan that should have been worked on over a decade, is overwhelming them under the pressure of of blood and fire, calls to finish Hamas vs calls for restraint.

Bibi's compulsion is to keep sitting on the PM's chair for the sake of it. Thus any war is risky to his behind's stability in polls -which he has a OCD about-. So he bets this will subside while he maneuvers, sloganeers, manipulates, bombs empty shacks and talks tough. Israelis keep buying what he peddles.

He's not the selfless, principled and resolute statesman Israel sorely needs. He's a politician addicted to politicking. He can't wean himself out of it, and his corrupt advisors are happy keeping him always on the cusp of any wave.

This is the hour of wisdom and strength, not of posturing and procastinating.
Like · Reply · 6m

Speaking my mind
17. Let the IDF win! Let Israel win! This land is ours. The end.
Chaim ,   Israel   (11.13.18)
Hendel is 100% right. Israel was intended to be a strong, gutsy little VICTORIOUS nation. But we have lost our bearings. Instead of treating "Palestinians" as the defeated mortal foes they are, we BEG them to talk peace. This is truly sick! Let the IDF win! Let Israel win! End defeatist B.S. forever! This tiny land is ours. End of story.
18. IDF needs a capable Chief of Staff to win
Bar Star ,   Jerusalem   (11.13.18)
a not the one that we have now. Eisenkot is a failure. He will sacrifice our boys for the safety of "peaceful Palestinian civilians". This is what he has done in the past. And he said that he was proud of it.
19. How to win
Yehuda ,   Ashdod, Israel   (11.14.18)
The way to 'win' is to make it not worthwhile for anyone in Gaza to attack us. I think that there is a relatively simple way to do this.
1. Close the border. Entirely. No water. No electricity. No 'humanitarian' supplies. Nothing. If the Egyptians are interested, they can ship whatever they want into Gaza. Including weapons. Who cares? (See point 3.)
2. For every projectile that crosses the border from Gaza, whether missile, rocket, bullet, grenade, bullet, or rock, the Air Force will destroy 1 square kilometer of Gaza, working inward from the border. Scorched earth. Anything moving in a scorched earth zone will be shot on sight.
3. If the Gazans attack the border, we will be at war, and we will decimate them.
4. Inform Hamas, the PA, the UN, the USA, and anyone else who cares of these policies.
5. Ignore the world's reactions. They lost the right to criticize Israel many years ago.
20. Iran, Syria, hiz and then ham in that order !
Moshe Israel ,   Tivon, Israel   (11.14.18)
The IDF exists to defend Israel NOT to satisfy the immediate wishes of so
many that write "destroy ham " .
Israel has serious enemies :
1. Iran 80 million people; led by religious nut cakes: a 2 light year above the irritation caused by Gaza and ham
2. Syrian - hiz : led by fat and skinny fumblers, still 1 light year, above the minor hostilities of ham
3. Finally , finally we reach the troubles that Gaza and ham represent,
True more than "troubles" for Israelis in Sderot ...

Gaza ham are a minor training event for the IDF .
Israeli worriers that think the IDF should eliminate ham ...should explain who take over the day to day operation Gaza and WHY the new owners will NOT be say twice as bad.
21. Bennett for DM, Ofer Winter for Chief of Staff
Bar Star ,   Jerusalem   (11.14.18)
It is time to reshape defense establishment and get rid of incompetent generals who are unwilling to do what needs to be done.
22. Spliting Gaza so the problem would be reduced ?
M ,   M   (11.14.18)
Gaza and West Bank are different populations with different political reality.
Maybe if Gaza strip is splited the problem could be reduced.
A more visible way to go for Gazans would be there just on the other chunk of the strip.
23. To Chaim, Israel, at nr. 13.
Sjoerd van der Velde ,   Hoorn Holland   (11.15.18)
Let us not underestimate the influence of "islam" and anything that has to do with it (almost 2 billion) .Unfortunately"islam" is bad and evil for the free, human and democratic world, including Israel. Prohibid/fordid that criminal ideology and fake-religion, by law and legislation and let us end diplomatic relations with countries with "islam" dictatorships (more than 50), the so-called organization of islamic cooperation, founded in 1969, until they forbid "islam".
Next talkbacks
Back to article