Opinion  Ben-Dror Yemini
Erdogan is not a benevolent sultan of old, he's a monster that must be stopped
Ben-Dror Yemini
Published: 24.12.18, 12:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
35 Talkbacks for this article
1. This article is spot on
Bertram ,   London, UK.   (12.24.18)
Erdogan is a nasty piece of work. A populist ethno-nationalist who abuses democracy to silence critics and oppress minorities.
2. Erdogan is responsible to 1800 Million Muslims &80 mil Turks
Shulamit Ramon ,   Tel Aviv   (12.24.18)
He is not responsible to a few million fanatical Jews who want to rule the world
3. Erdogan is a brilliant but evil Neo-Ottoman
Dovid ,   New Yawk   (12.24.18)
10x smarter then Ayatollah Khamenei of Iran
Never has an Islamist been so Machiavelian and clever like Erdogan. Since many educated and wealthy Turks opposed his Anti-Attaturk leanings suppression of the media and force was needed thus a fake coup. He made deals with the Iraqi Kurds then turned on the Kurdish people. Turkey is receiving billions of Euro's for keeping Muslim migrants out of Europe. Despite being anti Zionist and a hater he actually allows trade with Israel to grow.

We love the Hashemites because they are weak. Turkey is anything but weak. To occupy Northern Cyprus and bellyache about Gaza and West Bank is hypocritical beyond belief.
4. TURDOGAN IS A WANKER
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (12.24.18)
5. How can you say such things about Trump's new Best Friend???
miki ,   jerusalem   (12.24.18)
6. The degree of antisemitism of Muslim thugs is irrelevant to
(12.24.18)
us Jews.
What's relevant is, how to maneuver the international waters, knowing that most of the time the currents are against us.
Regardless of apparent, temporary pro-Israeli/pro Jewish stance of world leaders, we must know& BELIEVE, that the distance between them and full blown Jew-hate is but few steps at the most.
7. Why Europe
AP ,   lyon   (12.24.18)
Why Europe should stop this dictator ,why not Israel ,arabic countries,USA, East Europe
8. same as 1933
Yisroel ,   Ashdod   (12.24.18)
NOTHING LEARNED by the "WORLD"
9. Turkey and NATO
steve ,   beer sheva   (12.24.18)
Interesting to know Turkey's position in NATO if he attacks Israel.
10. why Europe?
philipp   (12.24.18)
the US is handing Erdogan the keys to the Middle East.....
11. moishe rabeynu
moishe   (12.24.18)
he is not a 'monster' because despite his large military he is no match for IDF.
and he knows it. just like Iran. big talk. bully small acts. but you never know what crazy people will do.
12. Spot On Description
Joyce Fraser ,   Chicago, USA   (12.24.18)
of a mass murderer/hate inciter - Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey - who becomes more emboldened and enabled to create conditions of most dangerous apathy in and by 'The West', which in turn will likely be the cause of huge permanent destruction to our planet, and perhaps Hundreds Millions to Billions of human deaths.
13. When multi party clash will begin in Syria to carve it up
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (12.24.18)
we will see how Turkey with Erdogan at the helm will fare.

My opinion is that not too well
14. Turkey is a primitive, powerless semi-democracy. Nothing
(12.24.18)
good in the offing....
15. Turkey out of NATO
Miles Greenberg ,   Kapaa   (12.24.18)
Erdogan calls Trump his good friend! Trump needs to stick it to Erdogan but I suppose the gains from mutual benefit may preclude such a righteous move. Where is the Moshiach ?
16. A monster Runamuck on the World
charlie ,   tampa   (12.24.18)
Erdogan and his Fascist government remind me of Adolf Hitler and Nazis Germany .There is a similarity between the two. There is propaganda in Turkeys school system,government run media , religion and family ,taught to children at early age . Erdogan is a national fanatic radical Islamic terrorist that wants to be a world ruler and knows how to stir the masses in his country to do his bidding. Erdogan longs for a Neo Ottoman Empire and that is his plan . He is anit West, anti Israel ,and a threat to the World peace. I blame Western corporations investing in Turkey and building Turkey to be powerful. I blame United States for selling high tech military technology to Turkey. Cyprus a European country that is occupied by Turkey since the 70s ,and this has not stopped United States,Germany,France,United Kingdom ,from investing in Turkey and selling military technology to Turkey. There is no repercussions to Turkey when they break international laws so they will continue to do so .America created this monster, and one day the same monster will attack its creator .
17. “He must be stopped”.
Avi ,   NYC   (12.25.18)
Why don’t you go ahead and stop him then?
18. great article. But Erdo's now BFF with STABLE GENIUS, per #5
Rafi ,   US   (12.25.18)
In fact, Erdogan can probably tutor Trump on how to clean up all opponents in the military, press, legal & educational fields...

Two peas in a pod... both of whom are demonstrated enemies of freedom - and the Free World.

Elections of 2020 cannot come fast enuf!
19. whatever U think of Erdogan, he's just been awarded a major
Rafi ,   US   (12.25.18)
slice of Syria by America's Stable Genius...

And apparently as a result of a single phone conversation.

The "Art of a Deal" at work!
20. Aha!
Jackie costa ,   Sylhet   (12.25.18)
"You either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain"

This article reminds me of another opinion peace praising Erdogan till death about the economic miracle and reform he was bringing and also about another article from BBC(probably) after the coup, about how much the people like
21. Ynet has a double standard on Jews vs anyone else aswell
(12.24.18)
22. Exactly how media, idf, Israel treat the plo, Abbas........
(12.24.18)
23. He ain't no 'monster', he's a giant on clay feet, running a
(12.25.18)
backwater country, where they eat too much baklava & Delight!
24. Turks don't count. Only the US& Russia and distant 3rd:China
(12.25.18)
25. Mad Erdogan is an Islamist, member of the Muslim Brotherhood
C   (12.25.18)
trump, like obama before him, is making deals with mad dog erdogan.
hopefully netanyahu will not bow down to trump and make deals with
erdogan for the sake of us policies.
26. How can you say this about Donald's new playmate???
Shachar ,   Eilat   (12.25.18)
Israel is also guilty of aiding the butcher from Ankara. Our silence, reparations and constant apologising to this dictator have helped make him bolder. There is a lot of trade between Israel and Turkey (my factories biggest customer is Turkish) and everyone is sweeping his crimes under the mat to protect that trade. It is grossly hypocritical and ultimately self-defeating. Erdogan is an enemy who is aiding our enemies, especially Iran.
27. Would you stop Hitler?
Kenneth Baumgardt ,   Newark DE   (12.25.18)
Who would like to go back to 1933, stop Hilter before he comitted his terror? No WWII, no holocaust. Of course, time travel is a fanciful wish. But here we have a new Hitler, well along on his rise, and once again the target is Israel, and more specifically Jerusalem, the apple of God's eye. Perhaps the last one fortold by the prophets.
28. Kurds are Muslim, Balestinians are Muslims, yet Erdogan
Lou ,   Bucharest   (12.25.18)
kills only Kurds. Europe is made of comfortable people, cowards. We know them too well. I'm European too but from Eastern Europe and we understand Western Europe too well. Only commercial interests. Kurds never represented a force or something worthy of interest in Europe although, genetically, they are Indo Europeans, not Arabs, nor Turkish.
Interesting to explain, to ask Erdogan if his Muslim "principles" allow him to kill Muslim Kurds.
29. "monster" WHO ??? Yemini???
smokeonwater   (12.26.18)
30. Why is Turkey still a member of NATO?
richard ,   brooklyn   (12.28.18)
In viewing Erdogan's policies and behavior, why on earth doesn't NATO do something about it, especially his treatment of the Kurds? Is this what NATO stands for?
Next talkbacks
Back to article