Opinion  Sever Plocker
Why do Israelis have a soft spot for generals as politicians?
Sever Plocker
Published: 07.02.19, 18:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. Is Gantz running for leader of Israel or Muchtar of Ramallah
Alan ,   SA   (02.07.19)
2. Israelis love celebrity and respect ex generals
zionist forever   (02.07.19)
The IDF is the most trusted organisation and if somebody has risen to the top in the IDF they have the kind of public respect that no professional politician and there are so many of them because many Generals see politics as the next promotion.

Love or hate Netanyahu if Gantz was next PM it would be a disaster for the country because there is much more to running a country than skills learned in the army, rookie senior politicians are never a good thing.

What we need is a much higher electoral threshold so if Generals or any other celebrities want tp enter politics they need to do it by joining a mainstream party and working their way through the ranks so they learn the skills needed to run the country.
It doesn't matter how you feel about Netanyahu he is an old school MK who started at the bottom and learned the ropes, he did not form his own party to join somebody else's coalition and gain instant access to senior ministries, that's short term thinking and in Israel short term thinkers rarely survive long and if Gantz doesn't win this election next time round people will be asking who is Benny Gantz and they will be looking for the new star because thats the way the dysfunctional Israeli system woks.
3. because they keep us alive!
jore ,   la   (02.07.19)
4. No real freedom just imposing their will on other
Avram Goldsmith ,   Toronto -Kiriat Gat   (02.07.19)
Both experience the same: not to think out from the box, CEO of monopol company translated in leading manner:
Gabbai CEO of monopol company translated in his:behavior of eliminaing all his competitors,
Gantz in creating a poitical realm based on Military Pyramid for same purpose to avoid competion
Both are not leading on order to bring out the best for commoon goals , just personality cult .
Both to be working as a team is imposible , so what is unifying them is a unrational emotional adverse to Bibi?
5. They never will be able to work together as a team?
Avram Goldsmith ,   Toronto -Kiriat Gat   (02.07.19)
Motivated by ego booster, is dangerous to let them to lead Israel into other then total catastrophy, or as a part of goverment they will be only an OBSTRUCTOR or BACKSTABBER as case Rabin -Peres!!!!
6. why did 6 million die
hy   (02.07.19)
though some Jews fought against the overwhelming nazi machine, a lingering question is why the Jews did not fight like Arabs, acquire guns to shoot and flee even if the odds were slim.

i look at Israel now. i see preelection that some candidates want to give up the high ground of defensible borders and bring the enemy closer to the heartland. it is shocking but true. Jewish gene for accommodation and peace makes them submissive and invites aggression. regardless of being a general or a politician, that is what gantz and his potential coalition mate lapid are doing.

worse,w e already know the results of oslo and gaza. we know them clearly. rockets, injuries and death. hamas tells you exactly what they want to do.

finally, gantz the swashbuckling general was passive and did not pursue tunnels until forced to do so by Bennett. he was roundly criticized for it by shapira and others.

this is a real problem. what can one say!!!
7. The Flocker and his identity politics krap
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (02.07.19)
8. Gantz is general in security aware Israel.Gantz is Ashkenazi
Sam ,   Montreal   (02.07.19)
Gabbay has a greater mountain to climb.
9. Why does Israel have soft generals?
Benjamin Kahn ,   Bergen   (02.07.19)
10. GENERALS make lousy politicians...
Al   (02.08.19)
Gantz os a post poor candidate for PM.

Granted Netanyahu has been weak but GANTZ would be a disaster for Israel.

Look at his record.
11. This Author has long lost his plotz. That much is known.
(02.08.19)
12. Generals
Volvi   (02.11.19)
Its beyond my understanding how a guy whos never been in politics who has no policies and very little to say. How can he get more then a few thousand votes and not the ridiculously high polls of the media for a first shot to the Knesset.

ANYONE VOTING FOR GANTZ PROVES THAT HE/SHE IS NOTHING LESS THEN A MORON WHO CANT THINK FOR THEMSELVES.
13. Because asking this question helps Bibi
Avi L.   (02.12.19)
Because asking this question helps Bibi without naming him trying to shift votes from Gantz to Gabbay

As if choosing for a candidate was "racist", as if Barak had blue eyes, as if fake arguments were true
Back to article