News
Yair Netanyahu to Rabin's grandson: Your grandfather murdered Holocaust survivors
Itamar Eichner
Published: 21.02.19, 23:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
38 Talkbacks for this article
1. Michel Grajek on facebook
Me   (02.22.19)
Agree 100% , the country was founded by leftists, Tzahal was founded by leftists. There was nothing to eat, meat was imported frozen at top dollars, margarine instead of butter on subsidised brown bread and yugurt only for the sick. I grew up on compound chocolate and my dad's 2 weeks wages for a pair of shoes.
Nothing to be proud of the founders who run the country on a communist style red carnet with jobs only to party members. So my Shmuck in your dirty mouth
2. If Rabin told truth then why none of his troops died?
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (02.22.19)
He claims to be shot at and bombed first by Irgun members but no one was hurt on Rabin side while his troops murdered 20 Rightist Holocaust survivors.
3. Netanyahu opens mouth shows his stupid!
(02.22.19)
4. Rabin killed more Jews than Netanyahu ever did.
DOA ,   Goeßoeffels, DE   (02.22.19)
Oslo, like Clinton(s), is filth. Too bad Rabin signed on.
5. GOD HELP US ALL. I AM SICK OF THE INFIGHTING DISASTER COMING
OLEG ,   florida   (02.22.19)
6. Vile disgusting waste of space
Talula ,   Tel Aviv   (02.22.19)
It's time for the Bibi clan to bugger off into obscurity. They are despicable and an embarrassment to this country. Feh!
7. Scoundrel Rabin sang Kumbaya and praised Arafat while busses
ab   (02.22.19)
were exploding in Tel Aviv and elsewhere in Israel.
Unworthy "General" and Leader.
8. a pity
amos   (02.22.19)
"Ps Israel had been founded by leftists, Tsahal was founded by leftists." More
the pity! is all I can say. They used Moroccan youth as slave labour in the fields without proper education - they were better off in Morocco.
9. Actually Rabin admitted this himself! Still I suspect Yair
(02.22.19)
is s jerk.
Just call me old fashioned...,
10. The instability of an independent militia within an army?
Lorraine   (02.22.19)
The Altalena Affair was a very unfortunate episode, and it is unclear who launched hostilities, and there were casualties on all sides. No one is happy about what happened. But consider--if the Altalena had been allowed to land with its weapons, what would have been the result? There would have been a separate well-armed militia within the new state, not beholden to the state's leadership. In other words--Israel would have suffered the same sort of unstable situation that exists in certain Third World countries--like Lebanon with Hezbollah. Is that what some of you would have wanted?
11. Leftist are enemies of normal humans
Pm   (02.22.19)
Yair is an intelligent and sincere person who open his heart with the good intentions.Lefties are a curse to normal people.Irrespective of which country, these traitors belongs they always side with their own countries enemies.
12. "Atelena" was just one of many murderous acts of Israeli
(02.22.19)
Left, in that Yair is correct.
Still it does not diminish his image as a punk of sorts....
13. Rabin was a great leader,but.
Joel ,   Hod Hasharon.   (02.22.19)
Rabin may have been great leader,but the Oslo agreement was his biggest mistake.
The Oslo agreement resulted in bringing into Israel terrorist leader and giving him financial resources land and Diplomatic immunity.
We will never forget and never forgive the Labor party for letting into Israel the terrorist gang from Tunis.
14. nethanyahu as nethanyahu; undignified bullies
doda   (02.22.19)
15. is everyone gone mad....????
tomer ,   jerusalem   (02.22.19)
IT is sicking to see the madness creeping out of every hole in israel.
It is time to stop the inflammatory utterings of politicians,sons of politicians,
journalist or pseudo journalists etc. of all all "colours"
before the upcoming elections.Its sheer madness." Trumpstyle" lies
are not what we want or need in Israel.The "post truth" attemps to smear, to install "fear" and "unsecurity",the little dirty talks and "old laundry washing"
of unimportant persons or "hate mongers" should stop,being deleted or
erased.
We want political visions,concepts for the future ,honest politians and
hope for the future for our kids.That whats needed and wanted. Not this daily
dirt or "fear " sales.
Get it?
16. Rabin was a murderer of Altalena
Yosi ,   Jerusalem   (02.22.19)
The majority of the people there, including his men, acknowledged that Rabin started shooting, for no reason, other than orders from BenGurion, who was trying to establish his power base.
17. let rabin rest in peace
mark   (02.22.19)
rabin was a very good planner and put in his service to the state. let him rest in peace. as for relative merits, rabin was not perfect. no soldier is. rabin tried oslo on the instigation of peres and beiliin. he tried it and it failed miserably to this day. ok Israel had to try it.

yet now, gantz wants to try it again.

as for bibi, something happened to him because he will not undertake any significant military action seemingly out of fear. he does small stuff, not big stuff. some say he was a coward. he acts like it at times. lately he doesn't act that way. his fellow officeers would be able to comment if he was a coward or not. bibi was also rebuked by shapira.

gantz was rebuked by shapira report for a reason which the media is ignoring. in my judgmeent, he is not in the league with galant or ashkenazi. lapid and livni sided with gantz and yaalon. they were alll wrong. only bennett and to a lesser degree lieberman were correct.

of course ynet will not talk about the gantz mishandling of the gaza war because they are desperate to replace bibi.

bennett is waiting in the wings, bibi will step down so its enough to vote likud to get bennett.

so maybe yair and ben artzi should give it a rest.
18. Exit
Jez ,   Netanya   (02.23.19)
Hopefully Yair will follow his dad to the USA once the old man retires.Andvof course his mum too
19. A lesson to be learned - Yair - if you are old enough :
barbara ,   Haifa   (02.23.19)
It is wiser to not give your opinion when your father is running for elections.
There is a saying - "Silence is golden". And silence is wise.
20. Arrogant bou needs a job and a life!
(02.23.19)
I am tired of paying his upkeep...let's vote his father out and put this loud mouthed momma's boy in his place!
21. Polak
(02.23.19)
Let Poles not be Jews after World War II, we would count on the fingers of one hand.)
22. examination of bibi and gantz
ray   (02.23.19)
both wore the uniform. bibi as pm has been consistently gun-shy in all of his Gaza operations to the point of seeking ceasefires before tunnels were hit. he mostly gives speeches. he buckled under pressure to hold talks via kerry and agreed to concessions not out of conviction but out of pressure. he talks tough but he is actually weak. he has never initiated action like declared sovereignty over area C.He acts fearfully. when shapira criticized him, he seeming had no idea of what they were talking about. bibi lacks understanding of the battlefield period. bottom line,he did not hit iran, and he left hamas in stronger shape than before because he did not want to finish. because he has no conception of how to finish and the stamina to do i t. lieberman diagnosed bibi accurately.

against bibi you now have gantz who was chief of staff. he went through the ranks and rose much higher than bibi. in terms of bottom line performance, shapira found him wanting in the gaza war, where he was seriously criticized which ynet ignores because they hate bibi.i found him to be passive. he underestimated tunnels . he does not go for the enemy's throat.

during the hezbollah war run by olmert(lapid is a follower of olmert)and halutz, both were heavly criticized by winograd and rightfully so for poor leadership. olmert knows next to nothing about combat, and halutz is an arrogant one dimensional general. they both made every mistake in the book. gantz did not to my memory reverse olmert's course. he did not change the outcome to any degree. lieberman, who saw gantz up close in the securiy cabinet said he would not join his govt. he differed with him during the gaza war.


So I tend to understand ben artzi's critiques of bibi. gantz has his own problems.

i would vote for bennett or likud knowing that bibi will step down soon enough. gantz is not the answer nor is lapid who we know is an arrogant ignoramus. yaalon says the right words but he too buggered up the gaza war and he is too protective of turf.

ashkenazi had promise but politically he is also a dumbbell, offering up the golan to western educated assad.

the polls will settle and likud will likely just win but be dependent on coalition allies. bibi will be booted out by such allies in short order.
23. MARY HOLZBERG a YOUNG WOOMAN was killed' IN SABENA'S PLANE!
mira ,   natanya   (02.24.19)
Your father has not asked for forgiveness from his brother! Has your daddy SELECTIVE memory! hit MARY in the forehead, Barak and Dayan apologized ,and your daddy :with selective memory NO"!- SHHHHHHSHHH!!
24. Yair Netanyahu: the apple doesn't fall far from the tree
Rafi ,   US   (02.25.19)
... right into the same pile of s**t
Next talkbacks
Back to article