Jewish Scene
Conversion rows and broken Western Wall promises: How Israel is alienating US Jewry
Kobi Nachshoni, Kim Legziel
Published: 06.04.19, 00:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
61 Talkbacks for this article
31. They doth protest too much
Avi Goldstein ,   far rockaway   (04.07.19)
It is sad to see politics being played with Judaism's core tenets. But for the record: 1. I don't understand why Reform Jews are troubled that they are not given equal ritual access to the Kotel. After all, Reform Judaism believes that the Temple will not be rebuilt! Reform has no use for the ritual sacrifices that were brought, and will be brought, at this site. So why the tumult? Unfortunately, the answer is that Reform is not concerned with Jewish unity but with political gain. Reform, Conservative and Orthodox Jews can and do daven together at the Kotel. There is no reason for change.
Conversion is an even more serious matter. The fact is that Orthodox Jews cannot accept Reform and Conservative conversions, on theological grounds. Therefore, if such conversions are recognized, the potential for a divided Jewish people may, God forbid, come to fruition. This is not a political issue for Orthodox Jews, it is a theological one, and the attempt to paint it otherwise is disingenuous.
32. Mister
Pepe ,   MIami   (04.07.19)
Good , we need to continue alienating these Kapo Jews
33. Identified American Jews nearly entirely orthodox
David ,   New york   (04.07.19)
Those who go to Jewish schools, attend synagogues at least weekly and give a s—t about Israel are nearly 100% orthodox.
Many of the “non-orthodox” you speak about are actually viscously anti-Israel
(Eg recobstructionist and many reform activists)
34. Michigan Forum
Isaac Barr ,   Detroit   (04.07.19)
Israel should do what is good for Israel. Reform Judaism could survive without elianating Israel.
35. Headline
Agnes Losonczi   (04.07.19)
What about how know-it-all US jewry is alienating itself from all the rest of us?! Wanting to take over the leading and decision making in Israel,then getting offended at the refusal?! While smooching up to Israel's existential enemies at home in the name of multiculturalism and political overcorrectness!
36. AMERICAN JEWS BELONG TO A FAKE SOCIETY & RELIGION!!!
OLEG ,   FLORIDA   (04.07.19)
THEY ARE WEAK, STUPID AND GREEDY. LIKE THEIR BROTHERS AND SISTER IN HOLLYWOOD OR CNN. THEY SUPPORT CAUSES THAT CREATE PROBLEMS TO ISRAEL AND REAL JEWS. I KEEP AWAY FROM THEM AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE. AMERICAN JEWS WILL PAY DEARLY FOR SUPPORTING LEFTY CAUSES ANTI TRUMP ACTIONS THAT WILL TURN AGAINST THEM. ALL THE ILLS IN AMERICA WILL BE BLAMED ON THE JEWS. SOONER OR LATER. SUPPORT ISRAEL AND PRESIDENT TRUMP ITS THE RIGHT THING TO DO.
37. The problem is not conversion,
nn   (04.07.19)
the real problem of Israel is the lack of civilian registration of marriages at magistrates or internal affairs ministry, in addition to the Rabbinate. And it has nothing to do with eligibility of citizenship laws (the Law of the Return). There is a number of countries whose law grants citizenship based on various personal criteria to people that do not belong to the dominant ethno-nation or to the majority religion of that country. Again, marital registration procedure, congregational belonging and citizenship granting procedure are all orthogonal!
38. Misinformation
Bar Star ,   Jerusalem   (04.07.19)
The article is full of it. Anybody who is familiar with the American Jewry knows this. The non-Orthodox part of it is rapidly disappearing due to the low birth rate and intermarriage. American Jewish Federations can hardly support local activities for the reasons above. They don't give billions and they don't give millions. Many liberal Jews are anti-Zionist.
At the time when our status as an indigenous people of the Land is being questioned even righteous converts are a liability to us. Fake converts are an absolute liability. We should accept only the best of the best!
39. Start with the "Proof of Judaism Letter" from a Rabbi....
NYNY   (04.07.19)
who knows you. Your parents could have had numbers tattooed on their forearms from Auschwitz and the children still won't be allowed residency in Israel without such an insulting letter.
40. Senior
Alan ,   Tel-Aviv   (04.12.19)
The article just shows what Natanyahou really is: an octopus. Spineless in matters of religion and tentacles in everything else. Shabat Shalom
41. US yids lost Jewish Identity
Uzi ,   NY   (04.17.19)
US yids became a forlorn clan: a wreck of former Jewish Majesty. These "liberal" leftist former Jews to be disregarded. Am Yisroel spits them out!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article