Opinion
Main problem with Trump's peace plan
Shlomo Pyuterkovsky
Published: 23.04.19, 23:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
8 Talkbacks for this article
1. Mr Prime Minister
Nameless   (04.24.19)
If you are reading this; as soon as they reject the peace proposal a full curfew on Judea and Samaria and checkpoints on every road. Tanks and Iron Domes to protect the skies. They will start blowing themselves up as they usually do.
2. Trump won’t throw us under the bus like Clinton did
David ,   New yorrk   (04.24.19)
We have never had a president as pro Israel as him
Not even close
3. He’ll make us a deal we cannot refuse...
(04.24.19)
4. Problem with any so called peace plan
Ardeth Bey ,   US   (04.24.19)
The problem with Ye Ol' Trumps peace plan so called as with any of them, is they are calling for a two state solution, which solution is previewed in the giving up of the Gaza strip.
Anyone with an active brain cell or even two, should see you can't divide your land with a terrorist group.
The US wouldn't do it nor would any other country do it but these bright ones insist Israel is going to do it.
Israel should know by now, you cannot follow advice or plans like that. Put Trump or anyone else on ignore that wants another so called state beside Israel that is given to one goal and that is the destruction of the Jewish country!
5. As problematic as a peace plan between Allies & Nazis
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.25.19)
Any peace plan between Israelis and "Palestinians" is as problematic as a peace plan between the WWII Allies and the Nazis would have been. It is simply not based on reality, and can only result in catastrophe.

"Palestine" is an evil fictional state that never existed. It was concocted, in the 1960s, solely to justify the destruction of Israel. Many "Palestinian" leaders have admitted this. The only real path to peace with "Palestinians" is total Israeli victory and "Palestinian" departure.
6. The author fails to explore his own theory
Shachar ,   Eilat   (04.28.19)
The author writes that peace deals tend to end in bloodshed so we should avoid peace at all costs. He doesn't want to identify the problem and certainly has no intention of solving the problem. There are a number of possibilities ie both sides prefer to solve their problems with violence rather than talking, peace would mean an end to their dreams etc....Explore the possibilities, put some meat into a toothless, bland article.
7. At present there is no solution to the Israel-Arab problem
C   (04.30.19)
the issue is religious in nature, inciting the masses.
the arabs want all of israel, and all of jerusalem.
the jews want all of jerusalem and most of the west bank.
besides the arabs, there are other muslims who have no territorial claims.
yet, claim they do. they reference the torah, or the quran, to buttress their
claim. the war is religious in nature and can be solved only through
religious precepts.
8. Total victory over Islam is the cure, not only for Israel,
(04.30.19)
but for the West in general.
No other plan presents itself, not to Trump and not to Moses, should he choose to re-appear.
Back to article