Opinion  Ben-Dror Yemini
Does Jewish anti-Semitism exist?
Ben-Dror Yemini
Published: 28.04.19, 16:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
71 Talkbacks for this article
31. NYT
Renee ,   tel aviv   (04.28.19)
THERE IS NOTHING WORSE THAT A JEW WHO IS ANTI-SEMITIC. SHAME ON ALL YOU JEWISH SELF HATERS. LETS SEE WHO WILL TAKE YOU IN WHEN THE SHIT HITS THE FAN BIG TIME, AND YOU HAVE TO RUN AWAY FROM THE COUNTRY WHERE YOU WERE BORN WITH YOUR TAILS BETWEEN YOUR LEGS. ONLY ISRAEL WILL TAKE YOU. YOU SHOULD BURY YOURSELF IN THE DIRT.
32. new york times
simon ,   new york   (04.28.19)
The critical attitudes , from the democrats and their paper against president Trump and against Netanhay u are so irrational and full of hate, , that the so -called liberal journalists forget who they are and their origins.

That's wgat Sigmund Freud called the self-hatred jew.
It happened in Gerjany with the liberal jews, and that what's happening todaay in the States.
33. What an idiotic question! Is Pope catholic?! Of course it
(04.28.19)
does exist, countless scoundrels have proven that!
We’ve got our own, Israeli born & raised cretins in spades.
NY Slime is one of the leading antisemitic outfits with seal of political correctness approval!
34. Kissinger, Soros, Shulamit Aloni, Zandberg, Amos Oz, Beilin.
(04.28.19)
Shall I go on?
35. The very question is surprising
Jack Siegal ,   CA, USA   (04.28.19)
Many news items both broadcast on radio and TV and published media that emanate from the Israeli media qualify, without a doubt, as Jewish anti-Semitism. Apparently, the media considers it acceptable to bash anyone and anything right wing, anything related to settlers or haredim. Bashing any Jew or Jewish group is a form of anti-Semitism.
36. Except that the NYT is no longer owned by Jews
Maurice Solovitz ,   London   (04.28.19)
The NYT was owned by assimilated upper class people whose accident of birth made them nominally, Jewish and absolutely, 'House Jews'. But the current owners are converts to Christianity and some minor management roles are retained by Jewish distant members of the ruling family who will, no doubt, also be Jewish Uncle Toms. Just correcting your label!
37. Truly despicable!
Raoul Schur ,   Herzliya   (04.28.19)
Error by the New York Times? Don't make me laugh - or should I say cry?! Yes, some of the worst anti-Semites are Jews. The NYT times proves this again and again. We have to tragically face up to this terrible truth.
38. Whithout skullcap the caricature wouldn't be anti-semitic
N ,   N   (04.28.19)
Why on earth that black suit and black skullcap? Trump isn't even Jewish, only his son-in-law is and his daughter converted. And also for them it would be odd since they are Modern Orthodox.
39. New York Times anti Jew incitement
Garry ,   NYC   (04.28.19)
New York Times= KKK= Der Stürmer is responsible for muredr of Lori Gilbert-Kaye because of long long anti Jewish incitement
40. JEWISH ANTI SEMITISM
LARRY LISS ,   us army vet 24 years   (04.29.19)
NO we disagree too much as in what to do in reaction to impending danger since the tribes were scattered by the romans . in the ghettos of ww2 some jews looked down on the population who were in denial example the ghetto fighters were by the population who refused to believe there were death camps rabbi Kahain hated the passive nature of american jews in the 60 s who the general jewish population relied on the police to stop the beat downs of jews in brooklyn there are partisian fighters who were fighting jews in ww2 i a former army man and police officer in civilian life and american jew shame for the passive jew i also look with pride to the IDF and our great fighting men and woman with pride
41. m
moishe   (04.28.19)
NYT carries on a tradition established in the 1930's. it was not sympathetic to the plight of Jews in Europe. it did little to encourage emigration to America. nothing like a Jew that hates Jews. a 'yekki' tradition now practiced in America.
42. He is not Jewish - did come from a Reform Judaism
yaron ,   melbourne   (04.29.19)
Given the NYT track record this is not surprising - it is just an escalation. The NYT suffers from Institutional anti-Semitism - It started when the owner, many decades ago, who was extreme antizionist, decided that Jews are not people – just a religion and this was the cause the overlayed everything. Thus, for example, the NYT during the Holocaust, to publish an article about Auschwitz with no mention of Jews – and the publisher go on to blame Zionists for some of the Holocaust. He was brought up on Reform Judaism whose origin is negating peoplehood (historically, biologically and so on – incorrect) and the land of Israel – denying it only when it comes to Jews sounds a tad anti-sematic. So with this perversion it is no surprising that we have institutional anti-Semitism rife at the NYT.
43. Try to Google "Illuminati" in Hebrew
(04.29.19)
or any other conspiracy myth, such as Chemtrails, to see for yourself, how widespread the conspiracy thought is among Israelis.
44. Israel's enemies
(04.29.19)
Talking of the essence, the message from NYT is exactly the same as that of the Iranian Mullahs. The naïve Trump is led to a war in the Mid-East by the sly and malicious Bibi. Although I am sure the NYT people realize that as well.
45. NYT....RIP
Lucifer69   (04.29.19)
Please join me in canceling the anti-Semitic @nytimes on the day jews were murdered in another hate crime. Yes #NYT you are the problem too. Goodbye after many many years. I’ve had enough.
46. the NYT claims 'error in judgement'...
yaron ,   Melbourne   (04.29.19)
Was it also an error of Judgement during the Holocaust as the former Times editor said? - “I assure you, nobody put a sign on the wall that said downplay the Holocaust. It’s the way of life. You have an organization. Sometimes things are not said, they’re done.” OR restated in current terms ““I assure you, nobody put a sign on the wall that said print antisemitic troupes. It’s the way of life. You have an organization. Sometimes things are not said, they’re done.” The New York Times has had decades of institutional anti-Semitism – it is not that they need to be told- it is simply what they do.
47. Jewish left is full of Jewish Anti-Semites
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.29.19)
Of course, Jewish Anti-Semitism exists, and it is the most destructive type. The Jewish left is full of Jewish Anti-Semites, who work night and day to weaken our sole tiny Homeland and empower our mortal "Palestinian" foes. What do you call a Jew who seeks to trim Israel's waist to nine miles and turn Israel into a nine mile wide concentration camp? An obvious Jewish Anti-Semite.
48. new York times owners aren’t Jewish
David ,   New york   (04.30.19)
Sulzberger, the editor, has a paternal grandfather who was Jewish
His mother and maternal grandparents and paternal grandmother were cristian
He hates Israel, hates the Jewish religion.
What makes you call him “Jewish”?
He isn’t
49. Does Jewish anti-Semitism exist?
lazerbenabba ,   London, England   (04.29.19)
Does a dog bark?
50. Can we ask Yair Netanyahu this question?
(04.30.19)
After all if we look at Yair's tweets and facebook quotes it becomes clear exactly how much he knows about Jewish anti-Semitic commentary and howto post it!
51. Khalil Salim Haddad Aglamaz not Jew
Avi L.   (04.30.19)
Khalil Salim Haddad Aglamaz major share holder doesn't sound Jew ... Khalid?
52. Ynetnews is full of Jewish anti-semitism
Lisa   (06.20.19)
Just you like to present it as 'anti-haredi', or 'anti-rabbinic'. But your Jewish anti-semitism is awful - if the NYT printed stories headlined 'Why we hate rabbis' you'd be screaming your heads off. So why do you think it's OK for Ynet to be printing things like that, and constantly attacking other Jews with anti-Semitic canards just because they happen to be orthodox>
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article