News  Magazine
Facing deportation, children of Filipino workers know no home but Israel
Amir Alon
Published: 23.06.19, 21:26
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. Christian illegals are better than the 'alternative'...
David ,   Hartford USA   (06.23.19)
Let me put this very simply: would you rather live next door to an illegal Filipino family or an illegal Muslim family? Israel needs to build up its Christian population. The women do a great service to Israel and Israel is all their children have even known.

Make an exception for them. Find some rule to twist. These families have caused no trouble, and the women make it possible for elderly Israelis to stay in their own homes.

I think Israel is a gracious-enough country that it should be able to find a way to keep the families here. After all, their kids don't go around stabbing Israelis. 'Nuff said.
2. I guess Jewish racial purity is the gov's motivation,
(06.23.19)
But deporting friends is not fair. Nature does not support racial purity, on thecontrary mixing races is beneficial and promotes evolution.
Let us not work against nature and leave philipino children here.
3. Difficult situation
john zalun ,   tuguegarao city   (06.24.19)
it will be very difficult for those children to leave the country where they were born and learned to adopt and love. Being an Israeli citizen by birth (jus soli), why not let their parents work there meantime until their children reach the age of majority where their children will choose if they want to stay there and remain Israeli citizens or not. Just my thought though.
4. They are in Israel illegally. The fact that they managed
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (06.24.19)
to slip through the cracks for years doesn't justify them staying.
5. Not for a better life
Gracey ,   Tel Aviv   (06.24.19)
I understand that Filipinos come here to work and send money back home - and that's OK - but their stay should not be indefinite and they should not be having children here - it's presumptuous and it's wrong.
6. The Filipino wife of a USNavyOfficer years ago said Alongapo
Rivkah   (06.24.19)
is preferable to living in the USA. Alongapo is the garbage pit city of the Philippines. She came to the USA legally and was a stepmother to three American children and had a biological child. She now works at H&R Block in San Diego and her name is Evelyn Barnhill. She hates the USA and should have gone back to the Philippines a long time ago and stayed there. So, women and children of the Philippines in Israel, REJOICE! You are going HOME! Evelyn Barnhill needs to do the same and take her half Filipino daughter with her. Evelyn Barnhill was so mean to the American stepchildren, not one of them has a photo of the stepmother on their Facebook pages. Evelyn lavished affection and had a lovely bedroom for her biological daughter while putting the American stepchildren in rooms that looked like closets. She discouraged the stepchildren in every way. Please, Filipino people, stay in the Philippines. The Filipino nurses I had at Panorama City Hospital tried to kill me, refusing to give me oxygen after surgery when I was allergic to the anesthesia. It took an hour of my asking to get one of them to get an okay from a doctor. The next day the Cardiologist said I could have died without the oxygen if I fell asleep and stopped forcing myself to breathe. Another Filipino nurse would not help me sit up saying, I'm not going to hurt my back helping you. I don't weigh much. Another Filipino nurse tried to give me a UTI by wiping my anus and then wiping the urethra area and labia vulva. Filipino women are so mean they were banned from coming to the USA until the 1930's. Israel needs to get rid of them all.
7. LEAVE THIS NICE PEOPLE ALONE. THEY ARE LOYAL & LOVE STATE.
EX-ISRAELI   (06.24.19)
DEPORT MOST AFRICANS CRIMINAL RUSSIANS & UKRANIANS. THEIR CHILDREN WILL FIGHT FOR ISRAEL.
8. If Jewish children, regardless of their country of residence
(06.24.19)
can be instilled with a sense of "Home" being somewhere else (namely Zion) why the heck can't Philippine parents do the same ?!
9. Excuse me?! If we can raise Jewish children to want to come
(06.24.19)
to live in Israel, no matter where they were born, why the hell can't the Filipino parents do the very same?
It's pure leftist BS, aimed at diluting our population as much as possible and securing potential future votes.
Nobody is falling for that (I hope)?
10. Jews could quickly become a minority in their own country
JewisNationalSuicide ,   Jerusalem Israel   (06.24.19)
Reality Check if Israel wants to continue to be the safe homeland of the Jewish People after 2,000 years of exile and horror then let the Left Post Zionists and their mouthpiece all 3 of the mainline Leftist dominated Media stations win over the sympathy of the very young and naïve and then wake up one day and find the Jew once again a minority in the hostile anti Semitic world and I would hate to wager how those new immigrants would relate to the Jews who took them in already we have seen instances of this
in south Tel Aviv where Sudanese shout out " This is our country "!
. There are at least 200,000 legal foreign worker perhaps twice that illegal in a small Jewish Population of barely 7 million less than the population of New York City....Europe is already "dying" a slow demographic and cultural death swamped by other foreign cultures , Help
developing countries where they are, its immoral to cause other peoples
to commit national and cultural suicide and as Jews an even worse scenario could await us ...wake up Israel before its too late !!!
11. Renato da Silva (FB) is an agent provocateur
Jake   (06.24.19)
not an Israeli or a Jew.
12. ANYONE WANTS MY ISRAELI CITIZENSHIP.I WILL GLADLY GIVE IT UP
EX-ISRAELI   (06.24.19)
ISRAELI PASSPORT OVERSEAS IS GOOD AS A THIRD WORLD PASSPORT.NOTHING TO WRITE HOME ABOUT. LET THIS PEOPLE STAY IN ISRAEL. DRAFT THEIR CHILDREN TO THE ARMY. THIS PEOPLE DO JOBS THAT THE ELITE JEWS DON'T WANT TO DO. GIVE THEM LEGAL RESIDENCY LIKE THE AMERICAN GREEN CARD. THEY WORK HARD AND SEND AND SUPPORT THEIR FAMILIES BACK HOME. IF YOU VISIT THE PHILIPINO LOVE AND ADORE ISRAEL. SHOW LOVE TOO.
13. MAJORITY OF ISRAELIS IN AMERICA ARE ILLEGAL. I KNOW MANY.
EX-ISRAELI   (07.07.19)
NOBODY IS PUSHING THEM OUT. LIVE AND LET LIVE.
Back to article