Opinion
The right-wing has never had any solution to the Palestinian issue
Dr. Arnon Degani
Published: 31.08.19, 19:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. Pipe dream solutions of the Left. Only status quo is viable.
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (08.31.19)
The left has only imported bad solutions because anything that works anywhere else in the world doesn't work in the Middle East.
2. Martin Sherman has the ideal solution to "Palestinian" issue
Chaim ,   Israel   (08.31.19)
Check out Dr. Martin Sherman's call for Incentivized Emigration at Strategic-Israel.org. He has the ideal solution for the "Palestinian" issue. Israel need merely invest in "Palestinian" departure, instead of insanely investing in helping our mortal "Palestinian" foes squat comfortably on our land while plotting our demise. No other nation, in human history, has ever adopted such a clearly insane policy.
3. Thank you
(09.01.19)
for this article. I did not realize greater Israel was the plan from the beginning. In the U.S. American Jews were not told the truth about a lot of things. Just blind faith and keep your mouth shut, were expected.

It's all very sad.
4. The left has no answer either. Simple reason.
Jake   (08.31.19)
The raison d'etre of the palestinian "cause" is to wipe Israel off the map.
Compromise can't solve a problem of that nature.
5. Israel has created its own entrapment..Annex or no annex..
TheWall   (09.01.19)
one way or another, the zionist experiment is nearing its finishing line.
It is going to end and pretty soon.
Jewish population of Israel is diminishing.
In 1970s jewish population was 85%, today 65%.
By 2030 there will be almost a perfect balance: 55%.
That will be the END of Israel as a jewish state.
Israel should not have been created in the first place.
Never and NOWHERE in 2000 years, so many jews have lost their lives, like in Israel since 1948 till today: OVER 50,000 !!!
Israel likes to call itself as a "homeland for jews". NO. It is NOT. It is A Lie.
Israel is a graveyard for those who want to believe that and pay for that.
6. right offers Pals 3 options:apartheid, expulsion or genocide
kms ,   Jerusalem   (08.31.19)
7. IT AINT ROCKET SCIENCE
ALBERTO EINSTEIN ,   SAFED GENIUS   (08.31.19)
The solution is to be found in the Torah ,of course ,which tells us many times to vacate the land of its inhabitants i.e. palestinians ,or else it will be almost impossible to live here .
8. But dear: there never were any “Palestinians”,thus: no issue
(08.31.19)
9. Find me any Palestinians first,then I'll find you a solution
(08.31.19)
10. There never was a need for any "solution" to a non existing
(09.01.19)
"issue".
With our own two hands, Israel has created a phantasmagoria of "Palestinians".
Now you tell me , how we're supposed to walk back that Chimera?!
11. There is only one solution to the Palestinian problem
DSM ,   USA   (09.01.19)
12. LET'S GET THINGS STRAIGHT !
FO ,   Belgium   (09.01.19)
"A Hopeless, Dreary, Hart Broken Land", this is what Mark Twain wrote in 1867 after visiting Palestine. Its population, including Muslims, Jews and Christians, was no more than halve a Million at the end of the 19th Century! So, how do we find ourselves, today with, as told, six million so-called Palestinian Muslims? So read the still classified history! In 1922, the League of Nations gave the Jewish people the IRREVOCABLE RIGHT to settle between the Sea and at least the Jordan River, including the Golan Heights, to create their Jewish independent state in formation. Britain was appointed Mandatory of Palestine. Remember a Mandate is a Trust. Britain had to follow a road map, in this case the League's "Mandate for Palestine" consisting of 28 articles. But Britain behaved from the beginning as a colonial power, betraying the Jewish people, blocking Jewish immigration even during World War II, but permitting (encouraging?) hundreds of thousands Muslims to migrate into Palestine through British guarded territorial borders, but NO JEWS, just to prevent by all means the creation of a Jewish state! The so-called Palestinian Muslims are the descendants of the migrants during the British Mandate, transformed by the Soviet KGB into a "people" in the early sixties, and as leader a certain Yasser Arafat born in... Egypt! Last but not least, Jordan, an artificial country created by Britain on 77% of territory stolen from the Jews, gave during its illegal occupation of the so-called West-Bank, during the period between 1949 and 1967, the Jordanian citizenship. Must Israel bear the consequences of British betrayal? Is it not the international community, responsible for what happened in the past, to solve the problem, with an attractive financially accepted transfer back to Jordan, for those who agree?
13. Left enables mass murderers Hamas, Fatah like antifa, blm
(09.02.19)
All evil rascists and fascist.

Stop pretending the Palestinians were ever peaceful you r the problem.

The plo should be sent back to Tunisia and the tribal leaders should be in Charge.

Israelis don't support one of the most evil institutions on the planet the plo having a state on their land.

The fact you pretends the centuries of ethnic cleansing and pogroms against Jews on the land doesn't exist yo are clearly the problem not the solution.
14. Dr in front of your name clearly doesn't mean educated
(09.02.19)
A dozen different options from the right.
The left can only say appease appease appease.
Back to article