Jewish Scene
U.S. Jewish groups warn Israeli politicians against West Bank annexation
i24NEWS
Published: 07.11.19, 20:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
43 Talkbacks for this article
1. self hating Jews
larry ,   Jerusalem   (11.07.19)
J Street and NIF are super left organizations that seem to hate Israel and are very pro Arab. they do all that they can to punish Israelis.

Shame that they are not embarrassed from their actions, from their statements, and from their self hatred of being Jewish.

feh!
2. These groups are not Jews.
Michael ,   Raanana   (11.07.19)
They have4 no understanding of the existential threat 2 states is to the existence of the state of Israel.
3. Let them come over here and be citizens of Israel
Genghis Cohen ,   Raleigh   (11.07.19)
Or they can sit down and shut up
4. ATTORNEY AT LAW
Ross Gallen ,   IRVINE   (11.07.19)
LEFTIST PROPAGANDA!
5. WHAT AMERICAN COMMUNITY. LIES!!!!
DACON9 ,   BROOKLYN NY   (11.07.19)
WE DO NOT ACCEPT A 2 STATE DESTRUCTION.
WHAT AMERICAN JEWS ARE AGAISNT ANNEXATION?
ISRAEL FOR JEWS BY JEWS FOR JEWS AND ONLY JEWS
AMERICAN TRUE REAL OBSERVANT JEWS WILL STAND BY ISRAEL IS JEWISH..JUDEA SAMEREA IS JEWS...GAZA IS JEWISH AND JORDAN IS JEWISH AMND PART OF SYRIA IS JEWISH....
LOOK AT THE OLD MAPS,,,LOOK AT THE TORAH MAPS....
WHAT KIND OF NONSENSE IS THIS ARTICLE....
TORAH HASHEM SAID ''''DO NOT GIVE 'MY' LAND AWAY THAT 'I' GAVE YOU AS A GIFT.....
6. US JEWISH GROUPS
YOSSI THE SABRA ,   SAFED HONESTY   (11.07.19)
Nu yalla ,so come live here ,in Israel and then we will talk ,tachlis sababa.
7. SUCH ARROGANCE !
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED HONESTY   (11.07.19)
American jewish groups ,who do not live here in Israel ,imagine they have the right to make strategic life and death decisions about Israel from thousands of miles away .
8. The first question is....
DSM ,   USA   (11.07.19)
just who is the American Jewish community? In regards to this article it is more than likely progressives that are aliened with J Street, Trump haters and those who will make money from a two state solution. No Jewish group speaks for the "vast majority of American Jews". The groups being written about in this article do not really care if Israel even survives and so the two state solution is perfect for them. Leaders of Israel, listen to them at your country's peril.
9. Israel Agenda
Michel Keslacy ,   Michigan,USA   (11.08.19)
Only Israelis should decide about Israelis Policies, we the american Judeans We Should support Israel unconditionally. We simply love and support our Holy Israeli country.




























10. Perhaps
Boaz   (11.08.19)
American “jews” are willing to send their gentile kids to the army first, before adviising on Israeli internal policies?
11. what arrogance. typical leftists. want to over ride voter
ralph   (11.08.19)
we have no place in this discussion. arrogance of the highest order. israeli's must live with the decision. we do . there is no other argument which can be made.
12. Most jews here in the U.S can’t stand J Street and the Nif
Lance ,   Boston   (11.08.19)
These fringe groups do not speak for majority of Jews in the U.S. They just make a lot of noise that some in the media like to quote.
13. These are left wing anti Israel group
David ,   New york   (11.08.19)
J-street and new Israel fund?!?!
These are the same people who fund breaking the silence and other anti Israel groups
They are funded by soros and support our enemies
Why does Ynet pretend these are “Jewish” groups?
14. fake news
weiss ,   america   (11.08.19)
this demented "news" article is referring only
to suicidal "Jews" who are rapidly
assimilating and who won't therefore
exist much longer.
15. Nothing for nothing, but who cares what American Jews think?
(11.07.19)
16. American Jewish Groups
BOAZ ERICKSON ,   Big Lake   (11.08.19)
Israel is the only country in the world that everyone tries to order around.
By: Jeremy Bernstein
Dozens and dozens of countries were created after WW1/2. Only Israel is contested, even though 2/3rds of the original "Mandatory Palestine" territory (formally the Ottoman Empire) was given to Hashemite Arabs, who moved from Mecca, excluding poor Arabs from society.
This is due to various factors. Jew-hatred being one. Another, far more threatening to intersectional Marxists is that Israel ruins the narrative of white oppression.
How could Israel become a thriving Democracy with the only tech sector in the middle-east, in only 70 years, while the conditions of all the Arab neighbors are so horrendous?
Arabs living in Gaza, Judea and Samaria have among the highest wages and life spans, anywhere in the Arab world.
There is modern-day Slavery all throughout the Islamic world. Open air slave markets in Libya. Slavery in Nigeria. De facto slavery in KSA, Qatar and UAE.
Yet Reps Tlaib and Omar focus solely on Israel.
Israel succeeds. Because of culture, Democracy, and IQ. Built from the desert, from scratch. From blood, sweat, tears, and ingenuity.
Ruining the narrative of oppression that the Marxists foist on us, that white Americans are the root of all evil, while ignoring the various forms of the Caliphate. Keeping them entirely out of frame.
This is how Marxists operate. They change language and control the framing of narratives.
Recently, AIPAC, a supposedly Zionist organization, called for the opposition of Israeli law. Attempting to force BDS activism in Israel, against the will of Israelis. In order to appease the Democrat party and AIPAC donors.
The true face of many American Jews came out when given the choice between the Democrat party, and Israeli self-determination.
The true face of Rep Tlaib was shown when her humanitarian aid request was granted, and she turned it down anyway. Because she cares not for her 'grandmother'. She cares about destroying Israel and giving BDS a global stage. Pushing BDS bills through the American Congress.
How many American Jews sided with her, against Israel?
Far too many. Stop protecting those who would destroy our indigenous land, in order to be accepted.
These are the same folks who forced their families to stay in Europe, assuring them everything would be ok. As long as they kept quiet, and did as they were told. Hiding their Jewishness. Meekly walking into concentration camps when asked to. Instead of fighting back.
It's time for the meek Jew to go away.
This is a new era, leave the narrative of oppression.
Leave the Shtetl.
17. International law as the basis for a solution!!
N.K. Shlomzion   (11.08.19)
It is high time to ask the question: Why not advance a resolution to the Arab Jewish conflict based on the fundamental elements of international law, including the UN charter, that are relevant to the conflict and its resolution? Well, if we did, we should promote the following:

Two-States for Two-Peoples on Two-Banks of the Jordan River.

An Arab state consisting of 77% of the Land of Israel/Palestine, located on the left bank of the Jordan River, between the river and the Arabian desert; and, a Jewish state, consisting of 23% of Palestine/Land of Israel, located on the right bank of the Jordan River, between the river and the Med. Sea.
18. American Jewry is increasingly irrelevant.
Hillary Held Her ,   Down For Bill   (11.07.19)
The last gasp of a disappearing minority.

Israel is ultimate expression of the Jewish will to survive; American Jewry is its antipode. Dilution and irrelevance by assimilation.

American Jews, STFU and either make Aliya or get lost. Your days are numbered but your sense of collective self importance knows no bounds.
19. US Jews support Pal+Jewish state but Pals don't.
Sam ,   Montreal   (11.07.19)
Show us where Palestinians support a Jewish state. They don't, so Israel will move forward with other ideas rather than wait forever for Palestinians to come around.
20. Its a group of anti Israel groups
Mordechai   (11.07.19)
Most of these groups don't support Israel under any borders. They aren't mainstream or important. Very few American Jews have heard of radicals like Truah or the NIF. They have zero support among mainstream American Jews
21. These are not Jewish groups. Atmostmodern day capos
(11.08.19)
Nif and Jst are the biggest and most dangerous enemy of Jews.
22. Fascist left anti ddemocracy no different to Mussolini
(11.08.19)
Cant vote their policies in, so use lies, intimidation and even support for terrorists to push their ideology.
23. Bibi policy same as Rabin, these lefties have gone insane
(11.08.19)
24. ***EVERYONE*** who supports the 2 state solution is an ENEMY
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (11.07.19)
of Israel and a DAMNED Antisemite !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
25. Who?????
Rephael Rechitzky ,   Toronto   (11.07.19)
If the Jewish organization, whoever they are, think that Israel can be run according to their music, they are dead wrong. Israel is an independent country who give and gave support and security to the Jewish world communities and not the opposite. Should anything happened, Israel have been and always will be there for the Jewish people. Soooooo, stop telling Israel what to do and if you don't like it, then it is OK too. Only Israelis have the right to decide how their country is going to be and I man those who live in Israel, not even people like me. I am tired to see so many Jewish people side with our enemies, such as Bernie Sanders and others like him. Shame!
26. They watch news channels that tell them islam is A religion
OREN WYSOCKI   (11.08.19)
of peace. They go to universities that taught them that those who oppose open borders, are racists, despite every single muslim, latino and african country opposing open borders. They live in a world of blatant lies, and they actually think it’s immoral to point out that they have been fed lies, or worse yet, can't figure out what is wrong with their news telling them to look out for islamophobia after muslims attack and kill other Jews or americans. They want Israel to play along with their cult, so Israel is not called racist. A lie is A lie, and leftist lies about peace get more Jews killed. In Israel and in America. In G-d I trust.
27. To American Jewish Groups
SUK MAI DIK ,   SAFED LOREA   (11.08.19)
28. PSYCHOLOGY OF US JEWS
STIGMUND FREUD ,   SAFED GENIUS   (11.08.19)
These american jewish groups display vlear signs of Narcissistic Disorder and a grossly exaggerated sense of self-importance,in plain words they are deluded and arrogant. The soultion to these defects are for them to slink off quietly into the shadows and neither be seen nor heard off again ,at least for the foreseeable future.
29. TO US JEWISH GROUPS
YOSSI THE SABRA ,   SAFED HONESTY   (11.08.19)
Just because you give us a few $$$ does not mean you own us.
30. These American Jews live in time bubble
leo ,   usa   (11.08.19)
"two-state solution" is no longer an option and neither side even wanted it from the get go.
Next talkbacks
Back to article