News
Gaza blast: Doubt over IDF's version
Ynet
Published: 17.06.06, 11:17
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
88 Talkbacks for this article
61. Who cares, Israel violence hurt civilians daily !
(06.17.06)
62. 2 Olivia stick to your BBC You are a fake
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
63. 18 Nameless who also has no brains what Next
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
you conspiracy Moonbat ?
64. 43Rustum, London: go and post on the Moonbat media
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
it fits your agenda .......
65. 45 Daniel: The enlightened Moonbat = Zundel team
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
66. The Moonbat Media knows it all: Great news: They are experts
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
67. Looks like in the 30's the Goebbels Propaganda Machine
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
68. 3 Fake Pali Ref.: study real history and stop posting
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
69. to 45
haim ,   mtl canada   (06.17.06)
SHAME ON U TRAITOR TO ACCUSE IDF OF MURDER WHITOUT HAVING ALL THE PROOFS AND SECOND WHO WANTS U A AS JEW NOT ME THTS FOR SURE WE CAN DO WITHOUT TRAITORS LIKE U
70. RE: Ellen Prescott
Yosef Yaakov-lev ,   Baltimore USA   (06.17.06)
Ellen, while you sit in your comfy and safe HAMPSHIRE, I could not help but note (after reading your second "talkback) that: A. It smacks of gross ignorance of the basic realities in the Mid-east. B. Smug contentment of an arm chair philosophers and possible prejudice, of which you may not even be aware. Readers, take her "conclusions" with a big grain of salt.
71. 70 Yosef Yaakov-lev : Ellen is a Fake it's
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
Olivia of the BBC and we know her entire name
72. Enlightened Jew?
Bill ,   usa   (06.17.06)
You are a traitor and far from enlightened. As soon as the Pals cry you condemn your own people. Remember the Jenin massacre? You were one of the first to scream about atrocities, but then and now, your are mistaken. Shame on you, Jew?
73. The Palestinians
???   (06.17.06)
Still haven't explained how their press got to the site before the police and ambulance crews. How in the hell did the press manage to get this little girl (ACTRESS) screaming on film? Could it be more palistinian propoganda? Why yes it could.
74. who cares about elen or daniel
HAIM ,   MTL CANADA   (06.17.06)
the lady is dumb and the other hates himself so just pray for IDF we know how hard it is not to kill civilians in a war and idf is doing the best with hands tied up so in wht world or show me a country where u have this kind of behavior TG FOR IDF AMEN
75. TRUTH is IRRELEVANT to the PA and WORLD MEDIA
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (06.17.06)
Muslim human bomb killers slaughtered such huge numbers of Jewish innocents, the IDF were forced to search for the terrorists in Jenin. 52 Islamists were killed by the IDF. The PA falsely reported to world media that the IDF had killed 1,500 PA Muslims. The anti-Jew world media did not concern themselves to investigate if the false, venomous, slanderous, Jew-hating Jenin report was true. Israel was blasted and condemned around the world. Once again, with the full cooperation of a Jew-hostile world media, the Islamists scored a victory based totally on lies and deception-taqiyya.
76. HHHHmmmmmm
DPC ,   England, UK   (06.17.06)
"This claim is not in line with testimonies given by [PALESTINAN] survivors and [PALESTINIAN] medical personnel who attended to the [PALESTINIAN] injured." As a rational human being, I cannot accept their testimony on face-value. On the other hand, the IDF is the "most ethical army in the world" according to the most moral political leader in the world. Who to believe? They're all liars, yet someone is telling the truth.
77. ELLEN is NOT english or British...maybe she's French
DPC ,   England, UK   (06.17.06)
"In britain, we endeavour for what's right, no matter how unpopular it may be" ...this person is typing in a pseudo-stereotypical Edwardian colonial manner. Clearly, it's someone (from goodness only knows) who has been watching too many Jane Austen and Catherine Cookson films. REAL, NORMAL british people do not speak like colonialists drinking tea and scones looking down on all the "little people out in the colonies who can't look after themselves" PLEASE, don't believe her crap. She (or he) is not representative of ANY English/British people.
78. This is Oliva's/Ellen's so called Expert
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
This is also Garlasco - the so called HRW expert http://www.aim.org/media_monitor/4187_0_2_0_C/http://www.aim.org/media_monitor/4187_0_2_0_C/ Garlasco, and all of his current and former associates in the government, should be put under oath to determine what they know about the leak to Dana Priest......... The same Garlasco who plays that great HRW ...... He plays political games then ..... and now
79. Reality
frustrated ,   nyc, ny   (06.17.06)
Any human life is precious.....tragedies of this kind will continue, unfortunately, no matter who is at fault. The uproar on both sides is nothing more than a divergence to the real issue at hand. THERE IS WAR GOING ON PEOPLE! As long as the PALS continue to shoot Kassams inside the "green line", an expected response in kind should not be surprising to any of you. I was also taken aback, and saddened, by the the comment of the young girl survivor of the tragedy when asked "who did this to you?"......"the jews spilled our blood". How would she know this if not prepped by the ever efficient PAL handlers on the scene. Could this be but another "shocking" episode of Palywood? And, it's also seems indicative of the PAL school system which nurtures hate as a priority in its curriculum. If you teach them to hate what do you expect her to say? Couple of final questions which are still puzzling to me......if we are all in search of the truth, why didn't the PALS cooperate in the investigation with the Israelis? Why also did some of the evidence disappear suddenly? Questions, questions, and more questions.
80. 77 DPC,England: Ellen or rather Oliva is very British and is
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.17.06)
with BBC . when she was emailed To the address she posts herself here on Ynet ........ she fell into her own lies and mixed up emails thinking it was some person she corresponds with normally - and responded with her real name and address, which did not leave any doubt what so ever who and what she is She's trying to refute same now - but Liars always fall into their own lies she fell herself into her own trap She runs obviously as she said in that mistake email - a BBC Forum
81. DPC; What has what I said got to do with Colonialism?
Ellen Prescott ,   Southsea, Hampshire   (06.18.06)
82. tomorrows gaurdian news flash
josh ,   jerusalem   (06.18.06)
ellen you'll just love tomorrow news, it will go something like this: news flash! israeli shells were responsible for the 7/7 bombings in london: reports just fabricated show that israeli army officials altered shelling records to coverup the real landing sights in U.K.. (British Gaurdian-b/s/)
83. Ellen 'I don't care for Jews'
Roy ,   Sydney Oz   (06.18.06)
My my my! Our self proclaimed paragon of moral righteousness & rectitude is now a self confessed racist! What next? The KKK? or perhaps those Chimpanzees in the Aryan Nations? Doesn't surprise me! Where excactly did the sympathies of your so called 'Palestinian' friends lie during WW2 & Beyond?
84. Gaza Blast
howard ,   LA, CA, USA   (06.20.06)
Unpopular! This is meat for the masses for anti-Israel Brits. It takes real courage in Britain/Europe to actually take an objective view toward Israel!
85. To #20
Stacey ,   Walled Lake US   (06.22.06)
The Palestinians are Arabs that migrated to Israel from other Arab countries. If Arabs are genetically similar to the Jews than it is all Arabs not just Palestinians.
86. To #45 Self-hating Jew
Wendy ,   Walled Lake US   (06.22.06)
If you're so ashamed of being a Jew why don't you move to Saudi Arabia then and see how well you'll be treated there ya dumb A$$!
87. To #21 Richard Silverstein
Larry ,   Burlingame US   (06.22.06)
You're post is so ignorant! The UN is anti-semetic and anti-American and the News media lies on a daily basis, because the facts do not meet their agenda which is to put Israel in a negative light at all times!
88. To #26
Stacey ,   US   (06.22.06)
You're right except for one thing, the left in Britain are not impotent, they are running the government.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article