News
Massive battles in Marjayoun
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 10.08.06, 12:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
81 Talkbacks for this article
31. YNET !! Shame on you
Ali ,   Leb   (08.10.06)
You have deleted Peter Post from Paris answering Nabil #17 !!! You left Nabil's post and Delete Peter Post my mine!! Wow .. to me this is a big proove that you guy are loosing and I dare you to post this.
32. # 3 Not so fast, IDF # Ali
Ben Avraham ,   Jerusalem   (08.10.06)
Ahmed & Ali - IDF are doing a great job against Jolly Jack Nasrallah. (He certainly doesn't look so happy these days!) How many terrorists will be eliminated here do you think ? Why do you guys get so happy when you always lose - and have you really got a clue what the fighting is all about? How come you can enjoy zero achievement? Is there any creativity out there in the Arab and Iranian world? Surely there must be - Are you put on this Earth just to be destructive? Find something useful to do, Get a life. Learn to compromise. Learn to live with your neighbors. Learn to love. You must know that hundreds and hundreds of Hizbollah terrorists have been killed for absolutely nothing! Absolutely no gain! Why do you continue kidding yourselves about all this? Lets hear frrom you what you really think about losing?
33.  # 1 is right on, napalm the ground
nick   (08.10.06)
thats right.. a sweet welcoming gift to the hibolla rats... some showers of Christian Dior naplam perfume...probably they will asked for more!! Darn!!! Flush out those dirty rats from the hole!!
34. Missing posts r back. YNet I Salute u !
Ali ,   Leb   (08.10.06)
35. #32 To Ben Avraham
Ali ,   Leb   (08.10.06)
You said : "Learn to live with your neighbors" !! Lets start first by you learning not to kill people and steal thier lands for a start.
36. Zai eldrat albalat
sam ,   jerusalem,israel   (08.10.06)
you can bury your head in the sand, but i think you know all too well but refuse to beleive that Hezbollah have 500 dead, if i bought you nasrallah to house dead, you would tell me he was sleeping, tell me is it still reported in arab countries that israel have actually lost all wars so far against arab countries, not withstanding the land gains by israel ,you probebly think the golan heights was n ever sryian.blind as bats
37. # 26 Ali
Ben Avrahom ,   Jerusalem   (08.10.06)
Ali - What are you smoking ?
38. destroyed tanks
alex ,   CA,LA   (08.10.06)
in the month of heavy conflct with well trainned soecial forces, there are only dozen or so tanks destroyed, most of them returned right back into fight, the IDF know what they are doing and they are fighting extremelly well. IDF guys, be safe! & don;t forget: "If I will not, who will!"- thank you guys.
39. # 37 Ali
Ben Avrahom ,   Jerusalem   (08.10.06)
I said : "Learn to live with your neighbors" !! You said "Lets start first by you learning not to kill people and steal thier lands for a start"". Ali - Israel was attacked across the Lebanese/Israeli international border a month ago. Around 80 rockets were fired on Israel, Soldiers were killed and wounded soldiers taken hostage back across the border - that is what started this war and that is why this ugly mess is continuing. You must knolw that the jewsih people have roots in this land that go back thousands of years. About half of Israel's Jewish population originate in Turkish (Arab!) lands. In the city of Bahgdad, for example, up to 1950 the jewish population could trace back a continuous history for around 3,000 years! There a substantial Jewish population had to leave everything behind them and flee the country and many came to Israel with virtually nothing. (You won't find them today living in Refugee Camps over 50 years later!). Maybe you could learn from this? As I said you need to learn to live with your neighbors. You probably know that the French and Germans fought the most bitter wars for around 100 years including World War 1 and 2. Huge numbers of soldiers etc. were killed (in WW 1 it was a generation). In the fields of Verdun in E. France I think there are around one million graves! Yet today the French and Germans manage to co-exist. Both sides have worked to achieve this. You guys need to start thinking positively and get a future.
40. peace
Human   (08.10.06)
#37 Every thing will be ok Avraham, when you and your blooby gues will realise that there was great Britain, ther was USSR and there was hitler. Instead of talk about kill, talk about peace
41. #39 Ben Avrahom, I respect what you are saying but ..
Ali ,   Leb   (08.10.06)
First let me thank you as you are one of few who at least is responding without insults! I respect that. Let me tell you that the Arab Nations including Lebanon do not have a problem with Jews as a religion as we do agree that Jews used to live among us and in most of Arab countries including Lebanon. Our problem is with the Zionist ! We believe that Palestine belongs to Arabs and I am sure you do have your version of the story. But do you really accept what is happening to the Palestinian for over than 60 years now? They accepted to take a small piece of land and to live in peace but even this was too difficult for the Zionist to give. Regarding Lebanon, you can not start thinking about the problem by just going 29 days ago as the problem was there years and years ago. Israel invaded our land many many times and no need to tell you about the casualties as you can find that by a simple google search. IDF left Lebanese land back in 2000 and kept the Sibaa farms and few of out POWs. Shiba farms are Lebanese and not Syrian and Syria has announced that many time and also before 3 or 4 days they announced that these farms belongs to Lebanon. Was it so hard for Israel to give these few meters square back to where they belong and save this blood? You need to know that Hizballah in the eyes of millions of Lebanese is a resistance movement that was created in 1983 just to free Lebanon from the Israeli invasion. The operation that was done by Hizballah to kidnap the two Israeli soldiers was just to negotiate with Israel to free our POWS ! You can not say that was a terrorist operation because we were at war and the kidnapped were soldiers and not civilians. Israel did not want to negotiate and they chose to go to war. See where we are now and see the causalities at both sides!! There was an easy solution but Israel did not think twice. One more thing, Israel keep saying that Syria and Iran is behind this and you know .. The long song of Iran and Syria .. I would say that sure Iran and Syria has their own agenda in Middle East like every body else including America. The Lebanese Resistance couldn't stand without this support same exactly like the continuous American support to Israel. Probably you will say that Israel is a state and Hizballa is just a militia! I would say no, Hizballa are the people of Lebanon and just few days ago the Lebanese government got the guts to adopt Hizballah points. The points are simple.. Give us our rights (Shibaa Land, Lebanese POWs, Mines maps) and then there would be no need for Hizballah to exist. Let's solve the problems from its roots please and lets save the rest of our people lives.
42. Value of Life
Walldizo ,   Damascus,Syria   (08.10.06)
Hey Opie, You must be blind not to see Lebanon and what became of it. Gaza too is becoming the worst city ever to exist on this world, all because of your life appreciating Government.Don't talk about the gift of life when others are living in hell.You can't appreciate a situation until you live it.Good luck.
43. At last the dogs of war are unleashed!
Hell Dogs squad ,   israel   (08.10.06)
44. 1 day,ali, you will see 1 of them under
malk-a-harb ,   zion   (08.10.06)
your window until then talk as much as you like
45. Live with peace
Lars ,   Finnland   (08.10.06)
We have had many wars with Russia and now both countries have had peace for decades. After WW II we paid enourmous reparations to Russia, we resettled 15% of our population and educated new generation. I do not understand, why rich oilcountries can not do this and even more. We do not have a lots of valuable natural resouces, but we have free education system and inexpensive medical care. Do not ask why Finland is one of the most advanced countries in the world. This is possible because of hard work and with peacefull co-operation with other countries.
46. Peter Pan from Paris... you're a complete bone head.
Proud Grandpa   (08.10.06)
I hope one day when you grow up, you'll be able to see the bigger picture. Islam wants to take over the world just like the Nazis. This will not happen. It's fun being young and dumb but it takes real men to risk their lives to combat the evil of Islam. Grow up Peter Pan.
47. Ali Leb: You sound like a real man. Gay Fest with me?
Greg Sweetcheeks ,   NYC   (08.10.06)
Dear Ali: You sound so brave and strong! I love a REAL man, particularly Arab. Meet me at Joffa Gate Hostel for gay fest in Jerusalem. I don't have AIDS. Do you? Love to see you soon.
48. #39 - battle of Verdun
NilsG ,   Helsingborg, Sweden   (08.10.06)
PMJI, At the battle of Verdun in 1916, 160 000 French were killed and some 300 000 Germans. HTH
49. "Hey" Walldizo of Damascus #42
Stefano   (08.10.06)
Maybe if the Gazans loved their lives more than hating Israel they would have taken the opportunity of Israel's withdrawal and the international funds that pour into PA to build a civilization. Their choices were different: elect Hamas, and rocket Israel. You see, when a country is faced with those who hate them more than they love their own lives, it has few real options. Israel has chosen well. Same story with Hezbollah in Lebanon. If you can't see that, maybe you have the same disease of soul. If so, be careful, it is fatal, in one of two ways: rots your soul slowly from within, or causes you to do foolish things that bring death early.
50. to #41 please check it out
(08.10.06)
you wrote: "But do you really accept what is happening to the Palestinian for over than 60 years now? They accepted to take a small piece of land and to live in peace but even this was too difficult for the Zionist to give. " actually the opposite is true. in 1947 the UN gave the jews a small peace of land and they were prepared to live in peace but instead all arab nations declared war on us and decided to take us out. it was then (1948) that EGYPT occupied GAZA and JORDAN occupied the WEST BANK read all about it in the HISTORY BOOKS
51. Ali lets go to a Hezbollah site.
Mike ,   Israel   (08.10.06)
Yeah thats right dummy there is not one site where hezebollah will like to hear from morons like you. Ever ask yourself why?
52. #18 Chris
Stefano   (08.10.06)
A good way to test the nature of a culture or movement is to see what it does when *not* threatened. Do that thought experiment and tell me if you would rather live in US or Iran or Gaza. False choice, you say? No, but then, some of us wouldn't have needed to wait to see Hitler's Army rolling into Poland and Belgium before we understood the nature and goals of the enemy. Before the Nazi slaughter happened across the world the "enlightened ones", the "peacelovers" of that day, excused his first moves, and blamed their own cultures and gov'ts.
53. LEBANON WILL BE A GRAVEYARD FOR OCCUPANTS IDF SOLDIERS
Lebanese ,   Lebanon   (08.10.06)
This what SHEIKH Nasrallah said yesterday,yesterday 15 soldiers ,today ????
54. major battles in marjayoun
debbie ,   israel   (08.10.06)
No. 18, Chris. You are a disgusting, ungrateful, naive idiot. You sit in L.A., one of the most free, richest places on earth, and talk about how the U.S. "powers" have caused more problems than al quaida. I wish for you a one way trip to Hizbollah land, to any arab controlled land and see if the life you have there is better than in L.A. And I bet you, you wouldnt be able to sound off the way you do, in their lands. You'd have your fool head cut off in a day.
55. nothing much so far
moe ,   montreal, Canada   (08.10.06)
up until now the IDF is still trying and trying to take and keep any piece of land. they advance to any village, thinking it was clear, trying to take a rest or catch a breath, then the rockets starts falling from all direction. f16 fly for help, chopters evacuate the troops alive and dead ones. and the same thing happens at some other village. Marjayoun was the latest, and now it's clear of IDF after it was taken today, and this is suppose to be a friendly ground as the town is mainly christian. lebanon is a shit hole, there is no gain or win on it, the only win is not to go over there, and if Olmert has an office problems, that's his problem, he doesn't have the right to sacrify anyone else to save his ass.
56. OLMERT PLEASE LET IDF WIN !!!
joshua ,   gates of jeriho   (08.10.06)
57. well double that
Danny   (08.10.06)
and you have what the Palestinians managed in Jenin in one go....
58. to #13
mary ,   jerusalem   (08.10.06)
War mongers your beloved IDF does not need advice. They committ all the atrocities that are there in the book, there is no morality which leads them only bloodthirsty leaders and psychopaths like you.
59. to 50
arabic girl ,   tunisia   (08.10.06)
you said"in 1947 the UN gave the jews a small peace of land and they were prepared to live in peace ", does the UN own this small land to give it to you? this small land is a palestinian land, how someone can give someone else's land without his approval? you ll say this land was ours and bla...bla...bla...yes there was jews living there and they still many jews living in many arabic countries uncluding here in tunisia, they refused to get out and still here and now they live in peace with us, why did you get out? you can t ask for something that you gived away since a long time.if you want to come back and live in peace you must accept to live under the palestinian gvmt, not try to violate this land and get their citizens out of it. if what you are doing is ok, so the American Indians can now come and ask all the non American Indian citizens to go out because this land was theirs 500 years ago? is this possible? if you come and violate someone else home it is normal that he resist and refuse to live in peace with you! and after you get this "small land" what did you gvmt tried to do? they wanted more and more and more, you are as a cancer in the middle east and you want to live in peace? get out of the arabic lands and let us live in peace, only then you ll live in peace. we don t have any problem with jews and the proof that the arabic jews in all arabic countries are living in peace and have all rights that we have, our problem is with zionists who want to violate our countries, kill us and with all that they want us to live in peace with them! if hetlar killed you it is not our problem, why we must pay someone else's fault? and also hetlar doesn t kill only jew people, he killed many people from all religions and even handicapped people, i m afraid that next time we ll be forced to give handicapped people a small land in an arabic coutry because hetlar killed so many of them! you must go and read some historic books to know what your leaders and army did to the palestinian and lebanese then only you ll understand why the whole world hates you( exept USA of course because they need you to do their dirty work in the middle east). we are not cowards, will keep on fighting until we free all our lands from you!
60. to arab girl
Charlie ,   Gray Summit, USA   (08.10.06)
Hey arab girl, what rights do the jews in Iran, Saudia Arabia, Somalia, Libya, etc., have, oh, that's right, they have the right to shut up and take what they are given without complaint, or they will be put in jail and tortured. What rights do christians in Iran, Saudia Arabia, Somalia, Libya, etc, that's right, they have no right to build their own churches or synagogs, or anything else, because that is an insult to Allah. They have no rights, and no ability to practice their own religion, unless they want to be put in prision, tortured and killed. You are a fool, and have no clue....tell me how many churches and synagogs do you have in Tunisia?,,,,,,one, two, NONE?
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article