News
Academic: Israeli-Arabs want end of Jewish state
Yaakov Lappin
Published: 22.01.07, 14:39
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
80 Talkbacks for this article
31. Putting things black on white.
Keren ,   SP-now in Israel   (01.22.07)
A solution could be the Sovereign Jewish State of Israel to obligate all its citizens to join the Army, and swear loyalty to the state.Forbid the practice of other religions than the Jewish one,as well as to forbid the practice of any manisfestation on the behalf of other cultures or countries than Israeli's. Israel should exert this right as soon as possible ,as the gravity of the situation has required. If muslims and arabs in general,and all,agree to it,they will be welcomed in the Jewish State;if not, they must be striped of their citizenship and leave the Country. It seems to me fair and just. Israel can not let live ,in its tiny State ,people that aim its destruction. The Israeli concept of democracy should be reviewd ,because Israel is in danger.It must open its eyes,and quicly!
32. So what's new.
Choni Davidowitz   (01.22.07)
The great Jewish leader Rabbi Meir Kahane (may God avenge his blood) stated this fact over 30 years ago. As with all his other warnings,if Israel does not invoke his policy of expelling all Arabs from Jewish Land,they will continue to harass evey Jew by violent means. Good (Jews) and evil (arabs) cannot co-exist. THEY MUST GO!!!!!
33. Everyone likes to complain
Sam ,   Canada   (01.22.07)
When given the choice of being traded to a new Palestinian state in return for some Jewish settlements in the west bank, Israeli -Arabs want to stay in Israel. What Israeli-Arabs want is to live the Israeli lifestyle and democracy in an Arab state. IT DOESN"T EXIST.
34. There IS a solution
The Raccoon   (01.22.07)
But we are too weak and PC to talk about it. There are some 1 million enemies in our midst (yes, Rami - 1 million enemies, 0.3 million citizens). They openly want us dead and our state destroyed. The solution is obvious - transfer. Transfer NOW, before it's too late. Make them vow allegiance to the state and deport them if they refuse of break their vow. Make incitement to terrorism or destruction of Israel a capital crime. When did we, Jews, lose our will to live? People like "Palestinian" from Haifa (#15) should not be in our state, unless they are standing in front of a wall and having a brief cigarette. These are the words of a traitor, of an enemy - and we should kill or expel traitors and enemies, not give them rights and social security.
35. Wake; up Eti Livni you are dreaming
elianna ,   USA   (01.22.07)
She wants to be told what she wants to hear so thats what she hears
36. Arabs prefer to live in Arabs-only land
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (01.22.07)
Take you pick, 22 to choose from.
37. Palestinian #5 1/2 Israelis from Arab lands
Laila ,   Montreal,Canada   (01.22.07)
Palestinian #5 as usual the Arab lie that all Israelis are from Poland / Europe. Half of the Israeli Jews are refugees from Arab lands. We were chased out of the Arab countries because they said we were "disloyal." Israeli Arabs except for Druse and Bedouins are a 5th column and a danger to Israel.
38. #20
Palestinian ,   Haifa, Palestine   (01.22.07)
Before you occupiers came along, there existed in Palestine one of the most sophisticated agriculture, the most advanced infrastructure, and the most powerful economies in the near east. There were oil refineries, industries, railways, roads , bridges, universities, mosques, synagogues, churches, the list goes on and on. Ofcourse its normal for you zionists to deny the existence of our culture, its against your sick twisted interests. And saying jews are the natives is just plain ridiculous (read ancient history for more on this), Palestine existed long before the jews came, and will continue to do so after they are gone. The jews ofcourse have every right to live in Palestine, and have done so for centuries, but not at the expense of its native inhabitants (called PALESTINIANS).The fate of the romans and the crusaders will be yours as long as you continue on this road of injustice and intolerance. (I agree with you that the rest of the middle east is crap though, thanks to your financers, the USA). Shalom/Salaam
39. Great Arab Moon Rocket
dave ,   dallas, USA   (01.22.07)
I have a solution! Lets send all the arabs to the friggin moon! They can have the whole thing to fight and kill each other for without bothering the rest of the world. The whole world is sick of arabs and their problems.
40. What u were expecting
1.5 billion Muslims   (01.22.07)
that they run away their Homes so so-called fake Jew around the World can come to Fake Promise land . wake up Arabs r not going anywhere. Reality check , world
41. Is Eti Livni shtooping a Palie?
Freejay ,   Israel   (01.22.07)
42. Moses said, but who listened?
David ,   Israel   (01.22.07)
Numbers 33:55 'But if you do not drive out the inhabitants of the land from before you, then it shall come about that those whom you let remain of them will become as pricks in your eyes and as thorns in your sides, and they will trouble you in the land in which you live.
43. THE ZIONIST STATE OF ISRAEL WILL BE DESTROYED UNLESS...
X-Slave ,   Detroit   (01.22.07)
The Arabs, nor the Iranians, nor any other real or imagined external enemy will destroy Zioniat Israel. No, the causation of the destruction of Zionist Israel will come from within. God will destroy Israel once again because too many of its people disobey The Law. The irreligious, secular-minded Israelis incur the wrath of God by dishonorong the Sabbath. fornicating, homosexuality, eating pork and other sins. Also, until the Arabs have justice and are treated in a humane way, Divine punishment will continue to visit Israel. Seemimgly, Ashkenazic Jews should be especially concerned about human rights abuse and fairness. Until all of Israel repents and submits to The Will of God there will never be peace. The Muslims are not the enemy of the Jews; the sinful actions of the Israelis are making Israel the enemy of God.
44. REALITY KICKED IN, and some people are in SHOCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!
YB   (01.22.07)
The question is WHAT ARE WE GOING TO DO ABOUT IT?????????????????
45. Israeli-Arabs want end of Jewish state
Arthur ,   Israel   (01.22.07)
Dr. Dan Schueftan said it! This is a known secret! We are paying for the mistakes our leaders did in 1948.
46. #2 Arabs have 22 Arab states But Palestenians
Ibrahim ,   Jerusalem   (01.22.07)
Have only one state and one Capital, You can still dream ...good luck
47. Rami 23: Be strong, be LOUD, be patient, be safe!
Aaron   (01.22.07)
You are right on. Please don't give up or be discouraged. Israel as a Jewish state with a successful, integrated, prosperous arab/muslim minority will be 1000 times stronger. The Zionist dream has been achieved, and must evolve to meet reality and modern times. You are a vital part of our Jewish homeland, and we are dedicated to making things right for a better future for all. Please keep posting, I will try to offer more tangible means of support in the future. Best Regards, Aaron
48. #38 oil refineries, industries, railways, roads , bridges
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (01.22.07)
NONE of it built by Arabs, all of it built by Jews or Europeans.
49. Waking Up - Perhaps In Time
Adina Kutnicki ,   US   (01.22.07)
Of course he is correct, but who needed a document to prove their intentions? They have been very clear for decades, and particularly since Oslo. They have ZERO intention of integrating into our Jewish State. They have been mostly biding their time and have demonstrated their intentions in a myriad of ways. Israel's leaders just have NOT been listening. Oslo emboldened them and hence the 2000 riots/intifada were initiated. Their Arab MK leaders are also proof positive of their allegiance with our genocidal foes. During the Hizbullah rocket war even the killing of their fellow Arabs by Hizbullah didn't quench their zeal. They demonstrated their allegiance on behalf of Hizbullah as the rockets killed 'fellow' (Jewish) Israelis! As they say, the proof is in the pudding. Thank heavens some of these academics are waking up and smelling the rocket fire! Israelis will either be politically correct and keep their heads buried in their fantasies and die as a result, or they will assiduously work to protect their homeland. It is that simple.
50. Arab phony Palestinian; More psychotic ramblings from an Ara
Palestiniansareamyth ,   USA   (01.22.07)
THERE HAS NEVER BEEN A PALESTINIAN COUNTRY, LANGUAGE, CULTURE OR PEOPLE YOU ARE AN ARAB FROM ARABIA. JEWS ARE INDIGENOUS TO ISRAEL. GO BACK TO ARABIA NOW! http://www.sullivan-county.com/id3/palestine.htm
51. 30# Arab from Haifa,Israel spouts pure nonsense
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (01.22.07)
Before the Jews arrived back to Israel(some never left in Safed,Hebron,Jerusalem ect.) the country was mostly a wasteland. The Hula Valley was a malaria infested swamp, the area around Lake Kinneret was desolate and Tel Aviv was a desert. Now Israel has millions of trees and millions of dunams of farmland. The Jews created a paradise here.
52. Palestine before Zionism
Jewish History   (01.22.07)
http://www.jewish-history.com/Palestine
53. israeli arabs
leo solomon ,   nahariya,israel   (01.22.07)
Most Israeli Arabs do not serve in the Israeli armed forces. They are spared the years of reserve duty They reject alternative service. They elect leaders who openly consort with and support Israel's enemies. They never demonstrate in solidarity against their brethrens acts of carnage and attempts to destroy the state. They are free in a way that is totally unknown in the Arab world. They have freedom of speach, Freedom of the press and the freedom to vote for whomever they please. They are the recipients of the best medical care. They have a higher per capita income then the Arabs in the twenty two Arab states surrounding Israel. They have a greater life expectantcy than in any arab state. They have a much lower infant mortality than in any Arab country. Their population has increased tenfold since the state was founded. They want all of the benefits of citizenship with none of the responsibilities. They want their cake and they want to eat it! to.
54. Transfer for Cash Plan
Tracy W   (01.22.07)
"Rabbi Shlomo Aviner, head of the Ateret Kohanim Yeshiva in Jerusalem, and MK Benny Elon (National Union-National Religious Party) have joined forces to promote the proposed program, which they said would be funded by the state. "The two men, who are next door neighbors in Beit El, propose paying the refugee camp residents $50,000 to $100,000 each if they agree to emigrate." Source: Jerusalem Post This "transfer-for-cash" plan for Palestinians should also be applied to Israeli Arabs. Their plan has one flaw, withdrawing voting rights from Israeli Arabs. This would not work because: 1) Future Israeli governments might restore their rights. 2) The Arab population in Israel is bound to surpass the Jewish population. 3) Even if an Arab oath of loyalty is demanded from Israeli Arabs, which they envision, that would not take into account how future Arab generations might feel about Israel. But the idea of funding Palestinian resettlement in Arab countries is sound. "Palestine" is not viable. It would continue to be a charity case while engage in hostility against Israel for ever. It's time for Jordan to take in their Palestinians.
55. #38
v n.y. ,   israel/boston   (01.22.07)
"palestine had culture, rfefineries, agriculture, schools, universities, ???????what are you talking about??? every foreign visitor to that area now isreal has seen the desolation, uninhabited lands, desert, rocks, swamps, maliria, no water, no farms, no agriculture, nothiong. it was barren! baren! it was a desolate land on which bedouins and arab sheep farmers crossed on and off. it was land piece by piece owned by missing arab landlords that lived in neighboring arab countries. these lands you are talking about have never been even inhabited prior to the jewish aliyahs where jews bought these lands piece by piece from those missing arab landlords at immensly high prices and they started farming them, draining the area off swampy water and malaria (many died of it in the process), working and tilling the lands to become productive farms, building schools and hospitals there. they created the first infrastructure that these lands have ever seen in milenia. what are you talking about. nothin g existed in israel except some arab nomades and some arab villages scattered all around without any infrastructure and very limited agriculture. universities, schools? where did you fish that one from? hospitals? where? most of these nomads and sheep farmers flocked to these now prosperous jewish settlements looking for medical care, education, work and a better standard of living, asurping any modern convenience jews were more than willing to give these arabs. take your head out of the mid east arabian sand. it's been in there too long. read and educ ate yourself to see that what you are claiming is 100% not true and rubbish. also, the arabs have ceased to contribute anything of value in "palestine" or any other arab country that was not under "occupation" centuries ago. look at the culture and life style in most arab countries and tell me how it even compares to life and progress israel made in 60 years. culture my foot! you fellows are too busy killing yourselves for lies and twisted truth you have been fed for years. of course you won't have the time to spare for progress and improving your lot in life. but then again, you arabs alway blame others for your victimhood and mistreatment and for your complete inability to build a prosperous economy, a great infrastructure and a wonderful society that contributes to the human race other than suicide bombers. it is your mind set and attitude of always extending your hands for donations and playing the victim and blaming others for your staet of affairs that is the true reason behind the conditions you find yourself in nowdays. wake up, whether there was a jewish homeland, an israel, or something else, you would have still found someone else to blame, never looking at really, really the cause for your misfortune. own up to this and go on to better things.
56. #46 Palestinians have only one state and one Capital
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (01.22.07)
one state: Jordan one Capital: Amman You can still dream about murdering all the Jews...good luck...
57. #12-you posed ultimate Israeli questionmark
Cameron   (01.22.07)
Will self-interest cut through the mutual loathing? Talk about needing the wisdom of King Solomon.
58. What's urgent now
tracy W   (01.22.07)
is to keep the Olmert/Livni government from making ANY deals whatsoever. The Israeli public is beginning to wake up to the reality that Jews and Arabs can't live together. The transfer of the Israeli Arabs to Jordan is an absolute necessity. Anything else is suicide. Their population is increasing faster than the Jewish one and in a few decades Israel would become an Arab country simply by their being a majority. This is so obvious, how can anyone still be in denial. The only exception to transfer could be made for the elderly.
59. Transfer the arabs to Jordan
trumpeldor ,   eurabia   (01.22.07)
In 1945,Poland expelled millions of German Czech did the same with sudetes
60. # 47
Rami ,   Nazareth, Israel   (01.22.07)
Thank you for your support. I'm glad to see that finally someoen decided to post a reaction to my post and talk of moderation
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article