Jewish Scene
Chief Rabbi Metzger supports conversions annulment
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 17.06.09, 14:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
74 Talkbacks for this article
61. #56
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (06.19.09)
You are a piece that is not worth my words,but since you are directing me in such an offensive and destructive manner,I must reply. Where exactly did you conclude that: 1) I am a poor favella inhabitant 2)What are exactly the "hatefull" ideas am I " sending "... . 3) And the more important:where exactly do you" identify" that I would be a "J forj" Now,ch.....(your name gives bad luck to be pronounced),respond in a comprehensive manner,not as -as some movements would say- an animal.If you can and are able ,respond as an human being;I can not say as a Jew,since I permit myself to identify you as a goy erev rav,as you permited yourself to identify myself as jfor j.You know:those who say what they want,hear what they don´t want I look forward to listen an inteligent argumentation.I chalenge you for an interesting and inteligent argumentatin.Let´s see if you are a man that is worth something for that. Ah..I am abroad , in holydays,so it is not Shabbes yet.........
62. K.... , # 61 the ex favella girl
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (06.20.09)
I asked if i had missed something something you wrote , something that this [ i don't remember his name ] ....had given to conclude that you are a J. for j. That's it . You are not , fine and sorry . Happy ? Your "education" did'nt show a high level of knowledge = favella . Your hatefilled tb's . miss "fund" , you more than once wrote them . They were not worth to be remembered , the same as you , nobody will remember you as a fine smart woman . As an "israeli" [ ? ] you should write ShabbAT , not your galut shabbes .
63. #62 I challenged you to show you are a man.Nu?
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (06.21.09)
" I asked if i had missed something something you wrote , something that this [ i don't remember his name ] ....had given to conclude that you are a J. for j. This is not an answer fit to an intelectually fit human being.Human beings,especially Jews,have an elaborated, even trascendent thinking.What you say above is no more than an imbecil answer,proper to instinctive animals and not to humans. What do you mean by the above?What is that"something that this [ i don't remember his name ] ....had given to conclude that you are a J. for j. "Explain what is this "something".Only animals have impulses and react blindly by their internal impulses;human beings analize their insights and act accordindly in a mental fit way. Explain the above. "Your "education" did'nt show a high level of knowledge = favella " Explain,elaborate the above.Where did you conclude thatI ever belonged to a favela.What is lacking in my education according to you?Elaborate your thought in order to be unbderstood ,not only by me but by all ,and do not sound as another animal runt,not fit for human beings ,especially Jews as you afirm that you are. I for my side ,can explain why I think you are not Jew but a goy,belonging to erev rav souls. erev rav,the egyptians who followed we Jews when we left Egypt,they were the ones who made Jews sin.Their souls are like your soul:souls that function as catalyzers for hate.It was them who drove Jews to idolatry because they were not Jews and were not G´od fearing-AS YOU ARE NOT-! Jews fear G´od;Jews respect Torah but you blasfeme G´od and Torah unstop.You gather Jew´s haters around you because that´s your job and agenda.You are not a Jew at all in my understanding ,even having been raised among us.You need to afirm you are 100%jew all the time because you intimately know you are not.That´s how I understand. Explain your point of view about what I say,explain why do think you are 100%jew.Why?What do think makes you a Jew? Listen,#62,I am not intrested at all in talking with you and with your likes,but it is you that from time to time round me as rat looking for its prey to bite and instill its infection,so now face what you have been looking for and show to all readers and to me that you are not a rat but a man.Can you?
64. miss k , "fund" . TRY # 4
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (06.21.09)
if you had been smart you would have understood my tb . You showed this lack also by don't knowing the difference between your HYPOCRISY [ writing on Shabbat & pretending to be religious] and my LOVE for Family members and relatives [ Kosher kitchen allowing all to eat at my home ] Favella girl : your ignorance , hatred and nice words are a proof of the place of your origin . Ignorance : not knowing that it were mostly SECULAR , if not anti religious , Jews who gave their life for MY State . Ignorance by not knowing that TRUE Jews can also be secular . Ignorance by the well known subjects you ignored and i had to teach you . My Jewish origin go back at least 20 generations on my Father's side , a 7 or 8 on my mother's . No one of them never converted to another faith . You know what i mean . So regarding being Jewish , who is the TRUE one if not me . Certainly not you . I know TRUE believers , even some Charidim , they don't show the hatred you show to people not agreeing with your ideas . Idon't hate you , but pity you . You a so called "religious" but who desecrates Shabbat by using her computer .
65. charles and keren: you are both jews
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (06.21.09)
i like a good argument as much as anyone, but as an outsider this is absurd for two jews to question jewishness. i disagree with both of your belief systems. but keren, your words to your brother are disgusting. did you know that nazi propaganda used the rat analogy about jews? i'm not shocked by much, but what you said is shocking.
66. 61 , in holydays ? but time to sprew your hate
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (06.21.09)
When i'm in holydays , not a fantasy as your , i will certainly not waste my time with you . I have very interesting people to whom to talk and don't need you , an Hypocrite , ignorant , hatefull and of a low education level . Not to talk about your intellect , inexisting .
67. #66(APPROPRIATE NUMBER FOR YOU!)
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (06.21.09)
Ynet didn´t publish my reply to 66. Truth sometimes is too shocking. Listen,#66,I don´t like you nor your types.Just go away and don´t keep beeing a putz around;if you think I am not worth reading,just don´t read.People with pride do that. You,talula and your likes say it is not worth reading what I say but you both keep reading fervently what I say.Maybe you look for some light,but I suggest you to dig some pride into yorselves and just keep away if you are not able to face a challenge in a proper intelectual manner.. For Ynet,if my answers to this putz are imprintable,please do not publish its words directed to me. If you can not publish what I say -,what would be meaninfull for the matter Jews/Goyim-, please keep this " thing" away because it is just unusefull and destructive such a discusiion.
68. Judaism must be the coldest religion of them all.
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem Israel   (06.21.09)
No wonder 75+ % of Jews around the world and in Israel are not religious and no wonder why assimilation is an epidemic.
69. Jewish Ayatollah
Alain M. ,   Montreal Canada   (06.21.09)
Those people who dare talk in the name of the jewish people are just a fringe of marginal, extremist, unintelligent folkloric representative of a wanabe biblical messengers.. The jewish version of the Ayatollah!
70. Miss K fund
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (06.21.09)
How was your holyday ? not only are you an HYPOCRITE , IGNORANT , ILL in you head , hatefull , but now a LIAR too . So much "QUALITIES" in one body . You exceed all the permissible borders in all those fields . The GOLD Medal . I knew that you will insult , that's your level , so low , lower than the Dead sea . I pity you , poor "lady"
71. 67 , some light from you ? an ignorant ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (06.21.09)
Yes i read your tb's , and have a good laugh sometimes when i read those "arab Market" in west Jerusalem , or your "reason" for the six days war . Exeeded all limits of ignorance , and you pretend to be a light ? Poor ignorant woman .
72. to 67 , no smart answer from you
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (06.22.09)
You again showed your Dead Sea level , unther ZERO .
73. Wrong course of action
moshe ,   Jerusalem   (06.23.09)
The annulment was because not everyone who converted observed Jewish law. But what about the ones who did. What about the ones who did it because they believed that the right religion was the Jewish one, not because he wanted to get married he had no girl friend yet. A friend of mine did his conversion back in his home country and came to Israel for the final conversion which included Brit Mila and Mikva and walked out of the office feeling very happy that he was now Jewish and could perform all the Mitzva's. He decided to make Aliya and went to Yeshiva to learn. About six months after he was informed that his conversion had been annulled. This was a crime, they took this boys life away from him. Because he could not forgive the Rabbinate for this he left the country not knowing how to continue his life.
74. Chief Rabbi Metzger
menorah ,   golus   (07.25.10)
Kol Hakavod Rabbi Metzger Please stay strong! Am Israel does not need problems of identity.... There is one law Halakha and no leniencies should be allowed in a subject such as conversion!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article